frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Pgbackrest is no longer being maintained

https://github.com/pgbackrest/pgbackrest
106•c0l0•1h ago

Comments

philipallstar•57m ago
Sorry to hear this. Well done for maintaining a successful project for so long.
timwis•54m ago
Really sad to see this. I had only recently learnt about this project, and was really impressed by it. I was planning to set it up this weekend (via autobase). I've also been under the impression that it's likely to be what powers the backups in RDS, Cloud SQL, etc., but I may have misunderstood.
oulipo2•49m ago
Waiting for all the C-level execs saying that "anyway this is not needed, we're going to vibe-code a solution to our production database backups" lol
absynth•34m ago
The backups will then be hyper-optimized from three hours down to 5 minutes using devnull compression technologies. Its super effective!
duskdozer•28m ago
Why even waste all this time and money on backups in the first place? Just don't make mistakes.
theandrewbailey•19m ago
Only for their AI to delete the production database and all the backups, and be forced to write an apology.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47911524

evertheylen•48m ago
Ah, sad to read this. Does anyone know of good alternatives?
DeathArrow•10m ago
Postgres has built-in backups starting with version 18.
hleszek•48m ago
Why not try to find a successor instead of archiving the repo and forbidding the use of the name? I'm sure with a 3.8k stars repo you'll find competent people willing to continue the work.
c0balt•42m ago
It is reasonable to ask for a follow-up project/fork to take a different name. Naming your project, e. G., pgbackrest-ng, does not sound too onerous of a requirement and clearly communicates to users that maintainers have changed (see also paperless ng/ngx as good examples of such a change).

Finding a successor is also not easy nor cheap (in regards to time).

xnorswap•40m ago
You'll also find plenty of potential malware injectors too, and who would want the responsibility of trying to vet a successor and have to work out the difference?
jeswin•39m ago
There's no way to know if a new maintainer will live up to whatever standards they've kept to date. Archiving should be the default decision, unless there's formal and elaborate handover.
dschuessler•36m ago
Because you will attract people who will want to take advantage of the trust these 3.8k stars signal to some people, for example, by means of supply chain attacks.
hombre_fatal•35m ago
Because that rug pulls your users.

3.8k stars and the name is years of built up trust with you, not with the person you gave it to.

duskdozer•30m ago
Those people can just as easily fork it and make a new name then. Otherwise you end up with situations where it's actually an entirely new thing under new developers under the same name. Even riskier in the age of the "AI clean rewrite"
bayindirh•30m ago
Sometimes you want to hang things to your wall, and be done with it.

I'd personally do the same. I wouldn't want to be bothered by the future maintainers' choices and get feedback/flak for it. It's a well-known and well-respected way to cycle the name with a "-ng" or "-nx" prefix to signal that this is the newer project with a different set of maintainers.

Being MIT, while is not my favorite license, doesn't give free license to grab and run with things.

Honestly, in my eyes, 3.8K or 38K stars mean nothing, because Open Source is not about you [0], to begin with.

[0]: https://gist.github.com/richhickey/1563cddea1002958f96e7ba95...

arbll•27m ago
A maintainer that is mainly motivated by the 3.8k stars aspect is probably not the person you want. Working on critical OSS software is fun until it's not, especially when you are not paid for that work.
moritzruth•10m ago
They are not really forbidding the use of the name (unless they have registered a trademark), they probably simply want to avoid confusion.
colesantiago•40m ago
> Since Crunchy Data was sold, I have been maintaining pgBackRest and looking for a position that would allow me to continue the work, but so far I have not been successful. Likewise, my efforts to secure sponsorship have also fallen far short of what I need to make the project viable.

So this was the problem, I thought Snowflake would pick up the sponsorship of this project but since it is a competing database it doesn't really make much sense.

I really wish many critical OSS projects get the sponsorship they need to continue.

Otherwise the software industry is in real trouble.

Forking it just passes the buck onto another maintainer with the same problem, this time without the original creator maintaining it.

wg0•27m ago
Very simple. Name it to pgbackrest-AI and add the line:

"AI driven backups with smartest world class models optimizing every byte stored via deep AI analysis."

With that added, a million dollars is just chimp change. YC alone would be adding them to all the seasons multiple times over summer, winter and monsoon etc.

fabian2k•40m ago
I was about to set up Postgres backups with pgbackrest very soon. It looked like the most mature solution for my use case. What I was aiming for was continuous backups to an object storage provider, without a central DB server but the backup tool directly installed on the Postgres server.

I'll have to look at the alternatives again, I think that was mostly WAL-G and Barman. It looks like Barman doesn't support direct backup to object storage, unfortunately. And I find the WAL-G documentation very confusing. What I'm looking for is WAL streaming and object storage support, to minimize the amount of data that can be lost and so I don't have to run my own backup server.

bobkb•30m ago
So sad. We have been using this amazing project extensively
hauxir•25m ago
been using databasus(https://github.com/databasus/databasus) works pretty well so far.
Nelkins•25m ago
Wow, this is pretty surprising, I was under the impression that this is the leading PG backup/recovery tool.

Anybody know how WAL-G and Barman compare?

https://github.com/wal-g/wal-g

https://github.com/EnterpriseDB/barman

noosphr•19m ago
>Wow, this is pretty surprising, I was under the impression that this is the leading PG backup/recovery tool.

https://xkcd.com/2347/

freakynit•23m ago
So sad to see this happening..

I had just last year prepared a detailed guide for reliable postgre backups to local volume as well as cloud storage, using pgBackRest, for my own projects.. pgBackRest have worked so well for me

https://github.com/freakynit/postgre-backup-and-restore-guid...

Thanks to the author for all the time and effort he put into this project..

2ndorderthought•16m ago
I really wish projects like this didn't fall through the cracks and continued to be funded. The struggles of OSS are too real.
freakynit•9m ago
True.. I truly wish wish we had better open-source license and more open-source projects adopt it..

Tiered pricing license... tiering based upon annual company revenues... should start super low for small companies (free for individuals), and jump to thousands of dollars per year for 10+ milion revenue companies.

I understand that this might not fully be in the spirit of open-source, but, what's happening currently is way worse.. where giant companies rip off the hardwork of open-source software maintainers without compsensating them adequately.

DeathArrow•23m ago
I have recently configured pgbackrest for our app. :(
joshmn•21m ago
I have a moderately sized 2TB production database I have enjoyed using pgBackRest on, and was—this week—going to set it up on another 8TB database we have.

What's the next-closest thing? wal-g? barman? databasus? I only get to cosplay as a DBA.

drcongo•3m ago
I can beat you on the timing - I'd never used pgBackRest before, but started setting it up on a project about 2 hours ago, by the time I'd finished the README had been updated.
dijit•19m ago
Wow! pgbackrest was definitely the premier backup solution for postgres when I last looked at the ecosystem properly.

It was the only solution that seemed to take restoring and validating as seriously as “taking a backup” which lead to an unfortunate situation with my employer. (details here: https://blog.dijit.sh/that-time-my-manager-spend-1m-on-a-bac...)

This is really a major loss. :(

nailer•18m ago
Mentioned this on X but CockroachDB should sponsor this - their audience is Postgres people and open source contributions can be great marketing.
pjmlp•10m ago
Plenty of comments of "So sad I have been using this".

How many actually contributed back to keep it going?

LetMeLogin•7m ago
I am not sure why are you gatekeeping this? People can't comment now that they are sad because of what happened?
pjmlp•2m ago
Gatekeeping?!?

Those that paid, or did any kind of contributions upstream are entitled to be sad.

Others should consider this is what happens to that lego piece in Nebraska, when no one contributes, and everyone uses it.

FartyMcFarter•4m ago
The number of maintainers is always smaller than the number of users for any successful project. GitHub displays the number of contributors as 57, I don't know if that's small or not.
victorbjorklund•4m ago
It's such a strawman to claim that you cannot be sad if something disappears where you have not financially or you work contributed. Someone can say that they are sad that the Notre Dame burned down even if they haven't personally contributed to Notre Dame.
iconicBark•1m ago
I use pgbackrest for some databases in production, and it has been VERY good.

Output Isn't Design

https://linear.app/now/output-isn-t-design
1•julian_digital•22s ago•0 comments

We Are Not Language Machines

https://www.shishyko.com/essays/we-are-not-language-machines.html
1•shishy•38s ago•0 comments

Show HN: Groundtruth – Stop hook that blocks Claude Code from saying done

https://github.com/vnmoorthy/groundtruth
1•vnmoorthy•54s ago•0 comments

FTWA – Free the Web Apps

https://ftwa.mathix.dev/why/
1•mathix•2m ago•0 comments

Creation of Canada's first sovereign wealth fund

https://www.cbc.ca/lite/story/9.7178238
1•colinprince•2m ago•0 comments

AI gives back more equality than it takes away

2•Bashkiroff•5m ago•0 comments

The 2 Hour [Marathon] barrier has been smashed

https://stevemagness.substack.com/p/the-2-hour-barrier-has-been-smashed
2•lordleft•6m ago•0 comments

A Tiny Polish Startup Became the Multi-Billion-Dollar Voice of AI

https://www.forbes.com/sites/iainmartin/2025/12/01/how-a-tiny-polish-startup-became-the-multi-bil...
3•Anon84•7m ago•0 comments

Running DOS and Unix on an 8-bit Commodore (2024) [video]

https://archive.fosdem.org/2024/schedule/event/fosdem-2024-2334-running-dos-unix-on-an-8-bit-comm...
4•michalpleban•9m ago•0 comments

17th-century astrolabe heads to London sale with £2.5M estimate

https://www.turkiyetoday.com/culture/17th-century-jaipur-astrolabe-heads-to-london-sale-with-25m-...
3•geox•10m ago•0 comments

AI apathy is a tragedy, falling behind is a crime

https://loworbitsecurity.com/radar/radar-18/
2•7777777phil•11m ago•0 comments

Maybe you should learn something

https://www.marginalia.nu/log/a_135_learn/
2•ingve•14m ago•0 comments

Supabase Feature Preview: RLS Tester

https://github.com/orgs/supabase/discussions/45233
2•siegers•16m ago•0 comments

On the LOC Controversy

https://github.com/garrytan/gstack/blob/main/docs/ON_THE_LOC_CONTROVERSY.md
2•tie-in•17m ago•0 comments

China orders Meta to unwind $2B buy of AI startup Manus

https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/china-blocks-foreign-acquisition-ai-startup-manus-2026...
2•kilroy123•17m ago•1 comments

Make Europe the Electro Union

https://www.norrsken.org/goodnews/make-europe-the-electro-union
2•imartin2k•17m ago•0 comments

Why QVC's Operational Excellence Became Its Undoing

https://gadallon.substack.com/p/the-inflexible-stack-why-qvcs-operational
3•JumpCrisscross•21m ago•0 comments

The Iran war is hitting the AI supply chain where it hurts

https://thenextweb.com/news/iran-war-pcb-supply-chain-sabic
3•skeledrew•21m ago•0 comments

Securing AI Agents and MCP at the network layer with Tailscale and Highflame

https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260403439638/en/Highflame-and-Tailscale-Partner-to-Secur...
3•grumblemumble•23m ago•1 comments

LogMeIn – Instant Login Links, No Password Sharing

https://logmein.today
2•imkost•25m ago•1 comments

Corporate America Is Minting Money–and Not Just in Tech and Finance

https://www.wsj.com/business/earnings/corporate-america-is-minting-moneyand-not-just-in-tech-and-...
2•JumpCrisscross•28m ago•0 comments

Ketamine, psychedelics, GHB: is the US falling out of love with cocaine?

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/apr/21/cocaine-ketamine-psychedelics-ghb
2•JumpCrisscross•29m ago•0 comments

Chatting with myself about AI

https://2earth.github.io/website/20260426.html
2•2earth•30m ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Is anyone building/selling VT220-type terminals?

3•vrypan•31m ago•4 comments

Taiwan's stock market surpasses the UK's, thanks to AI

https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/taiwan-stock-market-overtakes-the-uk
2•giuliomagnifico•31m ago•0 comments

TopCarPlay Wireless CarPlay

https://www.facebook.com/TopCarPlayWirelessCarPlay.Get
2•jerrycazer•31m ago•0 comments

China blocks Meta's acquisition of AI startup Manus

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/04/27/meta-manus-china-blocks-acquisition-ai-startup.html
2•yakkomajuri•31m ago•0 comments

LFM2.5-VL-450M: Structured Visual Intelligence, Edge to Cloud

https://www.liquid.ai/blog/lfm2-5-vl-450m
2•exploraz•33m ago•0 comments

Choo Choo Words: Spell words to make train tracks, stop the train from crashing

https://choochoowords.chyuang.com/
3•yongyongyong•34m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Webhook API – inbound email –> webhook

https://www.echovalue.dev/webhook-api/
3•emiliano•35m ago•0 comments