Ask HN: Why Do AI Credits Expire

4•kuberwastaken•1h ago

I was writing a blog when this hit me and couldn't find too many convincing arguments other than incentivizing heavier use, would love to hear takes on this.

Closest parallel I could think of is gift cards, which too do not expire in many places.

Comments

bradly•1h ago

Gift cards do not expire because laws were passed to prevent it. No such laws exist for AI credits, so companies will do what is most profitable.

downbad_•1h ago

Accounting purposes, I guess.

benoau•1h ago

AI credits expire because they make the least money off you if you actually use your full quota, now or later.

Littice•1h ago

The gift card analogy breaks down a bit: a gift card doesn’t get more expensive for the store to redeem later. Compute can.

ben_w•54m ago

Back when I experimented with getting ChatGPT by paying for API access rather than the official subscription, the credit was denominated in money, not in tokens.

Compute does whatever it does, but $5 sitting in an account to be spent on tokens at some arbitrary time in the future, earns money for OpenAI etc. even when they didn't make it expire.

AI is a mass psychotic delusion [video]

Show HN: I built notion to docs website generator

What Does OO Afford? (2018)

Show HN: A Browser Built for Browser Automation

Beyond Visibility: The Linkage Gap

NVFP4 Blockscaled GEMM on NVIDIA RTX Pro Blackwell GPUs (SM12x)

The Minimum Viable Unit of Saleable Software

Thoughts

OpenDroneMap's Documentation

Show HN: Zither – paste JSON/CSV/a spreadsheet table, stats instantly, no AI

Bonfires in the Dark: Ritual, Science, and AI as Compression Interfaces

Can I offer "login with yahoo" using FusionAuth?

Show HN: Fupio – Social RSS Reader

Electrek Drives the Sun-Powered EV from Aptera

Seth Larson on Making Things

Designing a Better strcpy (2020)

Trained a small language model for just generating question

Peter H. Diamandis, MD on X: "The Next 5 Years: A Supersonic Tsunami" / X

Show HN: Open-Source Legends

The Next Generation of Distrobox

Show HN: A TypeScript Pokémon Crystal TUI for Agent Benchmarking

Show HN: Jacobi–IDE for Abaqus subroutine with analytical tests and AI diagnosis

New Postgres Language Server: postgres-lsp

AkaRouter – Flat per-call LLM API gateway (20x cheaper than Claude Max)

Tesla plans to sell modular AI data center hardware called 'Megapod'

The Trap of Pushing Harder

US Grid Energy Price Map

AI Has Broken Hiring

Genuinely impressed, almost shocked, at how good GLM-5.2

Learning to work (very) remotely (2023)