frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Microsoft Needs Windows Lite

https://philipbohun.com/blog/0011.html
43•pbohun•1h ago

Comments

Rotundo•58m ago
The blog post sums up why users of Windows might want this.

However, this is not what Microsoft wants or needs. Microsoft is doing just fine by providing businesses what they need: a platform that can be tightly controlled and is easy to administer for large user counts.

WillAdams•27m ago
I dunno that it's that easy to administer --- time was, one of the concerns about NeXTstep was that it was so easy to setup/administer and so reliable that there was so little work involved, IT departments had to be downsized --- say rather that administering Windows is in-line w/ current budget projections/expectations.
rawgabbit•26m ago
I don't believe businesses "need" Microsoft. Microsoft is entrenched in corporations for a variety of reasons and none of them because Microsoft is technically any good.
thewebguyd•9m ago
Yes 100%. All these discussions around Windows always miss the fact that consumers are not Microsoft's core customer, and haven't been for a long time (outside of GameDiv/Xbox).

The fact that consumers use Windows is a nice side effect for keeping mind share and to get people familiar and preferring windows when they enter the workplace. That's it. It's an accidental userbase that exists to be exploited.

Microsoft's money comes from Azure & Office(365). If you're not spending millions on enterprise support/software assurance (or whatever they call it these days) contracts, you pretty much don't exist to them.

theandrewbailey•8m ago
> No telemetry, no spying, no ads, no AI, no .NET, nothing.

How will MS PMs meet their quarterly targets without Windows phoning home every moment someone is using it? \s

flanked-evergl•29m ago
Terribly written. Also, no, we don't need more Microslop.
theandrewbailey•9m ago
I'd love a currently supported, slop-free Windows XP or 7, hell even 10.
haunter•27m ago
LTSC, surprised the post doesn't mention that. No forced feature updates, no unnecessary preinstalled apps. I'm using them for years without any problems. There was only one extreme edge case where an app didn't work because it was hard coded to only work on Windows 10 Pro and couldn't do anything with the LTSC version.

Yes you can't get it legally as a regular end user but MSFT also doesn't care about piracy either. They don't lose money on you (they rather keep you as a Windows user than switch to another platform).

Windows 10 IoT Enterprise LTSC 2021 is supported until 2032, Windows 11 IoT Enterprise LTSC 2024 is supported until 2034.

pdntspa•7m ago
Yeah but who gets that legally
nairboon•7m ago
> Yes you can't get it legally as a regular end user

That's why it's not mentioned, it's not a product for "normal users", the audience described in the post.

haunter•5m ago
But that's also kind of the point too: Windows Lite exists but MSFT is "gatkeeping" it to enterprise users only. Probably because they are paying for it.
chris_money202•26m ago
OP says Windows needs builders to make applications and that is what Windows Lite would enable (or expand) but then says Windows Lite shouldn't include .NET one of the primary frameworks to build applications on Windows.
pbohun•20m ago
Honestly, I think starting from win32 again would be a breath of fresh air. Also, note that I described it as an option, no one would be forced on Windows Lite. It was my own speculation that it would become popular.
miah_•19m ago
.NET is still installable as a standalone thing. In fact I probably have several versions installed on my current Windows PC. No reason Windows Lite couldn't also have .NET installed _when you need it_.
summermusic•24m ago
Without fixing the fundamental business incentives that drove Windows to be the heap of shit that it is today, something like this will never happen
delta_p_delta_x•24m ago
> no .NET

Not quite sure about this. .NET is a superb platform, easy to write reasonably good code, huge standard library, well-maintained, many languages supporting a wide variety of paradigms (C#, VB, F#, PowerShell, C++). .NET is one of Microsoft's success stories.

bmurphy1976•11m ago
It should be installable, just via a package management system. You choose what you need. I think OP hasn't thought this through completely so he's missing this nuance in his post.

That said, knowing Microsoft they WOULD release something like this but cripple it by doing something stupid like disallowing the use of virtualization technology, even as an installed package.

CamouflagedKiwi•8m ago
It's also kind of pointless. Almost immediately, something will be installed that will require installing the .NET runtime, maybe multiple versions of it.

If the argument is to try to prohibit it, then it just won't work as a platform, because too much existing software won't work on it. There's a lot of garbage I'd love to not have (all the stupid hardware config apps all the manufacturers push on you) but just having that functionality not work can't be the answer.

mschuster91•23m ago
> The biggest pull keeping people on Windows, outside of shear inertia, is content creation and gaming.

Oh hell no. The one big pull keeping people on Windows (and, for similar reasons, Office) is the insane amount of legacy enterprise stuff that depends on it.

WINE and, with it, Valve/Proton have done a lot in that regard, but still, it's by far not enough.

rolph•12m ago
[delayed]
romanovcode•17m ago
> no .NET

> Windows Lite is perfect for gamers and developers.

What? All modern Windows software requires .NET

CamouflagedKiwi•17m ago
I like the idea, but I don't really see why this would change the 'Builder' population. Gamers would love it (I have a Windows 10 install around for gaming, I'd take this in a flash, I'd probably not even complain too much about the money), but that isn't the same. To make it work for builders it needs to be an attractive place to do development and I don't see how this really helps with that (other than maybe improving the audience for their products). Although I am speculating there - I haven't written any code on Windows for maybe 15 years now and I don't expect ever to do so again.
otikik•16m ago
How would this help any of the in-fighting MS teams get ahead next quarter?
throwa356262•14m ago
Windows problems are major tech debt and an architecture that is just not working anymore

Sure ads and AI are horrible but they are root of like 5% of the Windows problems.

A good example of a real windows problem is the garbage filesystem performance

haunter•12m ago
>Windows problems are major tech debt

tbh the backwards compatibility is not the best and you might have better chance with Wine on Linux but it's still better than MacOS where even software from a couple years ago is unusuable (no 32 bit apps anymore). And will be only worse once Rosetta2 is dropped.

dspillett•13m ago
> Windows Lite is $49 for a permanent license. No subscriptions.

That will never happen. Much as I hate everything being subscription based these days, there is too much effort involved keeping it updated for security changes and dealing with advances in hardware for a cheap lifetime licence to be practical. The best we could hope for from them would be a buy-a-new-one-every-few-years model similar to how Windows and Office used to be sold to no-corp users.

MS would be better off ditching Windows for non-commercial users and concentrating on Azure, Office (pivoting more completely to online versions), SQL Server, and AI services (assuming that bubble doesn't burst too damagingly soon), with a few other things that prop these things up a bit largely by driving people to host them in Azure (VisualStudio & VS Code, DevOps, Exchange, Outlook, Teams, Windows Server for corps who need/want to self-host, Windows Desktop for corps only). Windows desktop for corporate use only makes things a lot easier - they can limit the hardware support needed to a whitelist, and discard a lot of backwards compatibility tech-debt, and so forth.

What would everyone else do? Use Linux or Apple, or one of the BSDs. They can still run VSCode (and maybe VS if that gets ported) to produce things hosted in Azure, they can still use hosted versions of Office/Outlook/Teams or perhaps even VS, so they aren't lost customers for the things that MS actually makes good money from (Windows Desktop has long since stopped being the cash-cow it once was). PC gamers would end up moving to consoles (or console-a-likes from the likes of Steam) including MS's offering if they keep in the games market.

internet2000•13m ago
No, more SKUs is not the answer.
shevy-java•12m ago
Ever since Win11 I lost all desire to retain Windows. I still have Win10 on my computer on the left side, mostly for testing, but I also decided it will be my last version of Windows anyway. Now, I have been using Linux since many years, so it is not an issue, but Win11 feels as if Microsoft finally declared total war on the user and I can't support that anymore. The telemetry sniffing and spying and now the upcoming age sniffing - sorry, my energy will only go towards opposing Microsoft now. I think it is time for ALL users to stop accepting these corrupt corporate overlords in general and the paid lobbyists that work for them. Mandatory age sniffing is the thing that will break societies here; mandatory AI slop also contributed to this problem.
ivanjermakov•12m ago
Microsoft needs to repeat their Edge trick. Migrate Windows to the Linux kernel and get Linux compartibility out of the box. Immense research of running Windows programs on Linux was already done by Wine/Proton teams.
okanat•5m ago
NT is a better kernel for consumer systems compared to Linux unlike first generation Edge which was a worse browser compared to Chrome.
ck2•9m ago

     r/WindowsLTSC/wiki
dvrp•8m ago
Nice dream; the world is a bit more complicated than that.
c0l0•8m ago
Windows actually needs to be laid to rest forever. Win32 may live on as a legacy/stable API (via WINE) on superior free and open platforms.
bunderbunder•6m ago
I don’t think things are quite so dire for Windows. People (including me) have been predicting the end of Windows due to losing mindshare with builders since the turn of the century, and it still hasn’t happened.

The harsh truth is that most consumers pick Windows because PCs cost less than Macs. Businesses pick them for employee computers for the same reason.

And Windows Server more or less became a moot point when the cloud took over. They don’t want you hosting your own Exchange server anymore, they want you in Office 365. And they’ll just as happily sell you Linux compute instances on Azure because lower COGS means more profit.

mschuster91•4m ago
> The harsh truth is that most consumers pick Windows because PCs cost less than Macs.

Ever since the MacBook Neo, that's no longer the case. And frankly... Apple has now demonstrated that an old iPhone SoC is enough to drive macOS. I think that it should be feasible for them to run macOS on iDevices as a hypervisor-style guest, yielding you the full macOS experience when plugged into an USB-C dock.

moralestapia•6m ago
>Windows Lite is $49 for a permanent license. No subscriptions.

Lol, I wouldn't use it if they paid me to do it.

daft_pink•5m ago
it would also be really nice to have arm and x64.
greenavocado•5m ago
Already addressed in my previous comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48675898
999900000999•4m ago
What is this ?

Can I get upvotes by inventing imaginary products ?

Microsoft doesn’t want 50$ from you once for a decade. They want you subscribed to OneDrive, Gamepass and Office 365.

If they care about consumers at all. Azure prints money. Windows is the defacto standard for most businesses.

Microsoft even contributes to WINE at this point. VS code is most popular IDE on Linux.

Heck, they wrote an official guide to use Gamepass cloud on SteamDeck. Cool use Linux, just keep paying Microsoft 30$ a month.

Prosecutors used ChatGPT logs in a wildfire trial; jury split 10-2 for defense

https://www.theverge.com/ai-artificial-intelligence/958751/prosecutors-chatgpt-palisades-wildfire...
1•Lihh27•2m ago•0 comments

JetBlue flight hits drone while landing at JFK: Officials

https://abcnews.com/US/jetblue-flight-hits-drone-landing-jfk-officials/story?id=134313280
1•jaredwiener•5m ago•0 comments

Build from Anywhere with Cursor for iOS

https://cursor.com/blog/ios-mobile-app
1•meetpateltech•5m ago•0 comments

The middle-class home was always a historical accident

https://fortune.com/2026/06/29/harvard-housing-report-middle-class-homeownership-historical-accid...
1•lorecore•6m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Rust / Red Alert inspired WASM game in the browser (open source)

https://punnerud.github.io/mpe-ra/
1•punnerud•6m ago•0 comments

An impossible first task at Google

https://sparr.substack.com/p/an-impossible-first-task-at-google
2•denysvitali•7m ago•0 comments

Homemade Transistor from Cadmium Sulfide Photocell (2009)

http://sparkbangbuzz.com/cds-fet/cds-fet.htm
1•thenthenthen•7m ago•1 comments

Meta uses CXL to reuse old DDR4 and cut some inference fleets by 25%

https://www.theregister.com/systems/2026/06/29/zuck-saves-meta-bucks-by-reusing-memory-from-old-s...
1•p_stuart82•7m ago•0 comments

We've uncovered a master gene that switches on human development

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2531950-weve-uncovered-a-master-gene-that-switches-on-human-...
2•01-_-•8m ago•0 comments

Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Are Being Sued for "Fixing"

https://www.thegamer.com/samsung-sk-hynix-micron-sued-ram-crisis/
2•01-_-•8m ago•0 comments

Metasearch Tooling for Agents

2•chambertime•9m ago•1 comments

China's Z.ai claims it can match Mythos on cybersecurity

https://www.theverge.com/ai-artificial-intelligence/958804/chinas-z-ai-glm-52-mythos-cybersecurity
2•Brajeshwar•12m ago•0 comments

What LLMs are doing to conference programs

https://di.nmfay.com/llms-conference-programs
2•speckx•13m ago•0 comments

Android's earthquake warning system alerted 11 Million people in Venezuela

https://www.techradar.com/phones/android/google-says-androids-built-in-earthquake-warning-system-...
4•ck2•13m ago•0 comments

Show HN: MCP-compress-router – MCP Compressor

https://github.com/ameshkov/mcp-compress-router
1•ameshkov•14m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Create and Maintain Filesystem Structures for LLMs [v1.0.13 Out]

https://pypi.org/project/seed-cli/
1•hunterx•15m ago•0 comments

Amazon Is Awash with AI-Written Guideslop for Games That Aren't Even Out

https://kotaku.com/amazon-ai-game-guidebooks-alien-isolation-gears-of-war-2000711365
4•logickkk1•15m ago•1 comments

AI loops: who pays for the tokens?

https://www.jackfranklin.co.uk/blog/claude-code-ai-feedback-skill/
1•jackfranklin•15m ago•0 comments

11tyx5: Five Whitestone Foundation Sites, Eleventy, and the Long Open Web

https://www.adamdjbrett.com/blog/11tyx5-five-sites-long-web/
1•evolve2k•18m ago•0 comments

Is aerc better than neomutt now?

1•hardikxk•19m ago•0 comments

Dbrand cancels Companion Cube because it didn't ask Valve for permission

https://www.theverge.com/games/959056/dbrand-steam-machine-companion-cube-valve-take-down-canceled
1•minimaxir•19m ago•1 comments

Obfuscation: Building the final boss of cryptography (Part I)

https://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2026/06/29/obfuscation1.html
1•fbrusch•19m ago•0 comments

The Truth about Space Data Centers (IEEE Spectrum Magazine)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_qpdUNMt2yg
1•mudil•20m ago•0 comments

Floating Point: The Origin Story

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/floating-point-the-origin-story
1•rbanffy•21m ago•0 comments

South Korea announces more than $1T AI, chip investment drive

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/6/29/south-korea-announces-more-than-1-trillion-ai-chip-inves...
3•mgh2•23m ago•0 comments

The Laziest Generation

https://idiallo.com/blog/the-laziest-generation
2•firefoxd•25m ago•0 comments

A deep dive into SmallVector:push_back

https://maskray.me/blog/2026-06-27-a-deep-dive-into-smallvector-push-back
2•mariuz•25m ago•0 comments

The Radiation Exposure Lie

https://worksinprogress.co/issue/how-to-lie-about-radiation/
3•duffydotsvg•27m ago•0 comments

What Do You Do When You Lose Gigantic Megalodon Shark Vertebrae?

https://nautil.us/what-do-you-do-when-you-lose-gigantic-megalodon-shark-vertebrae-1282295
1•Brajeshwar•28m ago•0 comments

Ford rehires human engineers after AI fails to match quality checks

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cgrkd41n2v9o
1•_ua_•28m ago•1 comments