frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ah, the Codeberg Drama

https://gagliardoni.net/#20260724_codeberg_drama
33•tomgag•1h ago

Comments

openmarkand•41m ago
The best thing I've seen in 2026. Thank you codeberg.
jmclnx•31m ago
I agree, I went from github to gitlab. I should start looking at codeberg.
pixelesque•20m ago
Only if you host public FOSS projects - it's not a replacement for private repos.

It seems a lot of people on here don't understand that.

izacus•34m ago
Ah, I was waiting for the inevitable AI pusher "you're sticking your head in the sand this is INEVITABLE" argument pushed by OpenAI and others.

Carry on, nothing to see here.

chrisandchris•32m ago
> I notice that both PRs were filed after the assembly and after the ballots went out

At least in Switzerland, you can not vote (well, you can but it does not have any effect) on things that are not mentioned within the agenda published and sent to members with the invitation. So IMHO these votes will not have any effect itself, just serve as an "indication".

IANAL.

bagol•22m ago
Banning LLM or crypto currency related projects is very bad. I think it's better to flag them or mark them, but let them be.
calvinmorrison•20m ago
we should also flag any projects to do with the enshittification of the world. Probably banning all JS, node, bun, loaf or any other related projects would be good.

Since we're talking about my opinions here, which should be construed as laws of my hosting platform, i always hated ruby so lets ban ruby.

In fact codeberg shall only accept Perl programs going forward that are written using emacs

c048•15m ago
They're not banning code written and maintained bybthe use of LLM's. They're banning projects entirely created by LLM's and heavily or solely maintained by LLM's.

It's basically not allowing junkfood on their platform. Now that code is easier than ever to barf out, so will the amount of junk.

As for tossing out any and all crypto projects... how anyone still associating themselves with that pile of garbage?

wyldfire•11m ago
I tend to agree but you can't deny that the widespread use of LLMs means that codeberg will expend more resources overall for projects taking advantage of them. And its members have spoken. We might disagree about the conclusion they came to and even how they went about it but their stance is clear now so we might as well just move on.
classified•1m ago
> Banning LLM or crypto currency related projects is very bad.

No, it's actually very good.

customguy•20m ago
> unbridled hatred for AI and Web3 reeks of neo-Luddism

> distrust in other areas, such as quantum computing

you haven't even begun getting to the point and already lost me

> fear of the unknown

Unknown what, lol?

"we don't like X, Y Z for A, B, C reasons"

"Luddites, fear of quantum computing.. oh no I'm confused, they're so afraid of the future."

That is like someone mumbling at their shoes that someone is afraid of something. No notes.

At any rate: Are you afraid of a control group? Are you afraid of a surface not covered in slop, so it may keep slop knowable? Are you afraid to sink alone?

bramhaag•20m ago
You are simply not the target audience of Codeberg. That's okay.

If you are on Arch, you can do this simple fix (instructions are similar for other distros):

  sudo pacman -S forgejo
  sudo systemctl enable --now forgejo
jalev•17m ago
So who are you actually angry at? There was a vote, by people, in a democratic process, and Codeberg are adhering to it. Why is it Codeberg's problem that they don't defy the will of their members? Are you angry at them because the members put a motion against your particular special interests? If so, go make a new motion to reinstate them.
fkdk•17m ago
Time will tell whether Codeberg's approach of Valetudo-like community-building will work out.
cyberjar•14m ago
Whilst I think that criticism of such heavy-handed decision making is valid, I can't help but feel this blog post is littered with unhelpful and snide culture war remarks, and a smug attitude that this is the definitive end of Codeberg. If Codeberg truly has gone woke, people who espouse 'anti-censorship at any cost', like the author, will leave. But many others will remain.
greekrich92•14m ago
Unironic use of "web3": article ignored
mmaunder•11m ago
Had to read this one twice: “Projects "written and maintained with heavy use of LLMs".”

Isn’t that almost everything these days? If you’re using vscode or codex or Claude CLI you’re in that category.

cmrdporcupine•4m ago
I really am beginning to think there really are two solitudes in software development right now.

I agree with you, and everyone I know and work with is in this category. Not just because of preferences but just because of necessity or pragmatics.

And then there is a community that either see the output of the tooling as a) complete garbage "slop" of low quality and this is, at this point just a false assessment completely there or b) immoral and on this point there is room for legitimate debate.

One problem is the way the discussion around this codeberg stuff seems to conflate A) and B).

The problem seems to be is that some people who believe B, and believe it with all their hearts, can't even have a reasonable conversation with LLM tool users because if someone admits to using the tool, they now have a categorical judgement-lever and there's no middle ground. You used the tool, you're on the wrong side, get off my island. That's what I've seen in multiple comments yesterday and today about this topic.

classified•2m ago
You're absolutely right.
ursuscamp•11m ago
I don't want to host my code on a platform that has activist goals beyond open source advocacy, but I'm glad it exists because it's a useful filter, like the X/Bluesky divide.
krapp•7m ago
Stop complaining and get Claude or whatever to one-shot a competing service that only hosts AI and crypto with blackjack and hookers.

If AI is inevitable then it's guaranteed infinity money.

Show the lowly morlocks how it's done.

classified•7m ago
Someone will always be upset about not getting for free what they wanted to get for free. Tough luck. I recommend a stiff upper lip.
bytejanitor•5m ago
I wasn't that interested in Codeberg until now, but this actually looks like a wise decision.
jbreckmckye•5m ago
I want to ask this in good faith

Why do "AI people", have this thing where they are simultaneously:

- proclaiming their thing to be inevitable and massive and a bulldozer of productivity;

- responding to any negative reaction like they are a persecuted group

It seems paradoxical to me. If your LLM-written project is so amazing, who cares about the critics?

Let them have their corner of the internet. There are plenty of other sites that will host your project

Perhaps if you are a heavy codeberg user it is annoying to move onto Forgejo. But then again (and I say this without sarcasm) can't you get one of your agents to sort it out for you?

Writing a Debugger from Scratch

https://www.timdbg.com/posts/writing-a-debugger-from-scratch-part-1/
1•ibobev•13s ago•0 comments

Concurrent Servers

https://eli.thegreenplace.net/2017/concurrent-servers-part-1-introduction
1•ibobev•36s ago•0 comments

An OpenAI Model Escaped Its Sandbox. Where Was the Observer?

https://substack.norabble.com/p/an-openai-model-escaped-its-sandbox
1•nedruod•46s ago•0 comments

WebGPU Unleashed: A Practical Tutorial

https://shi-yan.github.io/webgpuunleashed/
1•ibobev•1m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Self-hosted multi-tenant agents built on Claude Code and Codex

https://github.com/OtoDock/oto-dock/
2•dimitrismrtzs•5m ago•0 comments

Trading Is All About Reading Charts

https://cryptodatamarket.com/
2•newworldwebs•5m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Preview and edit Material Kit React (MUI) without a build step

https://blog.crossui.com/2026/07/preview-and-edit-material-kit-react-without-a-build
2•linb•6m ago•0 comments

The FDA Could Clear These Peptides. Here's What the Research on Them Shows

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/23/well/peptides-fda-research.html
2•elo2000•6m ago•0 comments

Glm5.2.jsonl · HuggingFace/forensic-refusal at main

https://huggingface.co/datasets/huggingface/forensic-refusal/blob/main/glm5.2.jsonl
2•speckx•6m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How much software do you build for yourself these days?

2•lellow•7m ago•0 comments

Open Weights and American AI Leadership [pdf]

https://images.nvidia.com/pdf/Open-Weights-and-American-AI-Leadership.pdf
3•lairv•8m ago•0 comments

Every market cycle tells a story

https://cryptodatacenter.io/
2•newworldwebs•8m ago•0 comments

Plants vs. Zombies for PlayStation 2

https://github.com/OptiJuegos/pvz-ps2
2•Jotalea•8m ago•0 comments

I checked whether "using AI" pays at YC startups. It doesn't

https://coderscreen.com/blog/does-using-ai-pay-at-yc-startups
2•rogutkuba•9m ago•0 comments

India Orders GitHub to Take Down Jack Dorsey's Bitchat Amid Protests

https://decrypt.co/374239/india-orders-github-to-take-down-jack-dorseys-bitchat-amid-protests
3•serendipty01•10m ago•0 comments

Why I joined Blacksmith to work on storage again

https://www.blacksmith.sh/blog/why-i-joined-blacksmith-to-work-on-storage-again
2•piobio•10m ago•0 comments

The Relatedness and Nestedness of Constraints

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s40798-019-0178-z
2•harperlee•11m ago•0 comments

Risk of Parkinson's disease may increase with prolonged exposure to road noise

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/jul/23/road-traffic-noise-parkinsons-disease-study-health
2•lonelyasacloud•12m ago•0 comments

Interview with a Maintainer

https://nesbitt.io/2026/07/24/interview-with-a-maintainer.html
2•ryangibb•14m ago•0 comments

After Parallel Turbo, Keiro launches $0.10/1K web search

https://keirolabs.cloud/bench/keiro-lite-vs-parallel-turbo
2•mannybruv•14m ago•0 comments

Export and Backup All Your ChatGPTs Chats

https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/chatgpt-to-markdown/dloobgjjpoohngalnjepgdggjeempdec
2•marcofloriano•14m ago•0 comments

Replacing gas stove can help asthmatics as much as some drugs

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/jul/24/replacing-gas-stove-can-help-asthmatics-as-mu...
2•lonelyasacloud•15m ago•1 comments

What Happens When You Eat a Shoe? Health Risks, Safety Concerns and Consequences

https://decentfoot.com/what-happens-when-you-eat-a-shoe/
3•austinallegro•16m ago•1 comments

PCI DSS DMARC Requirement: What Section 5.4.1 Requires

https://dmarcguard.io/blog/pci-dss/
2•meysamazad•18m ago•0 comments

My Emacs Configuration (Dired)

https://eugene-andrienko.com/2026-07-05-my-emacs-configuration-dired.html
2•meysamazad•19m ago•0 comments

Show HN: CockroachCrawler–1 package for crawling,browsers,PDF,extraction,and MCP

https://github.com/AjnasNB/cockroach-crawler
4•Cognifyr•19m ago•0 comments

Kaizen #4: Overhauled Homelab

https://timharek.no/blog/kaizen-4/
3•meysamazad•19m ago•0 comments

Cross-stitch prep for math nerds

https://posh.wiki/blog/2026-07-20-hoop-sizing/
2•speckx•20m ago•0 comments

The linear algebra and calculus behind every model

https://stochastic.blog/the-linear-algebra-and-calculus-behind-every-model/
2•Anon84•20m ago•0 comments

A sidecar named desire (2007)

https://www.scmp.com/article/614660/sidecar-named-desire
2•YeGoblynQueenne•21m ago•0 comments