frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Silicon Valley is in denial in face of widespread backlash

https://www.bloodinthemachine.com/p/with-the-backlash-to-data-centers
53•cdrnsf•1h ago

Comments

atriarch•33m ago
This is a multifaceted problem for sure. As the fruit of leveraging LLM use, from my experience, is held in the hands of experienced, skilled, and gray-haired workers, what hope do young kids today have of BEING in this world?

The economic model since the industrial revolution is approaching it's metamorphosis: robotic servants that can do everything for everyone. Who, in that world, can spend the fiat and for what? I think many humans would prefer going back to picking potatoes out of the ground for a bit of silver than to lose agency to the machine. Everyone else is either bunker prepping or plugging into the matrix.

Will we arrive at the Jetsons? Or Warhammer 40k?

arionhardison•14m ago
This is so closely related to a comment I just made https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49470026 that I am going to just risk and repost it.

> This hit me hard, I have been thinking about this a lot lately. I'm not sure it's what makes "us human" its what makes humans (us) better than other species. It was intelligence, this was used to create distinction between us and other living beings, different races etc... Now its kind of gone; in some ways. Loss of meaning, purpose, place etc... The one thing we used as a ranking metric is now a commodity, so....? I don't even know how to finish that. So why care, why work...shit just why? Capitalism makes it even worse because we are judged based on what we output, does that even make sense anymore? I think the article is confusing because the "state: is confusing; to me at least.

.... 3 responses ....

> Thats totally fair, and TBH - I am also very concerned for my wellbeing as well; I and many others are not doing so well because, in my case I no longer see this "vapid" state of existence as ephermial. I have been reading more and more; I guess looking ot knowledge as some eort of ends vs a means to an end for once. Camus, Stokely Carmichael (Kwame Ture), Dostoevsky's underground man etc...

Camus: The universe was always going to stay silent when you demand meaning from it; the answer isn't a better metric, it's to push the rock anyway ("imagine Sisyphus happy").

Dostoevsky [underground man]: Refusing to be a piano key in someone's optimized Crystal Palace

Stokely Carmichael: "Racism is not a question of attitude, it's a question of power. Racism gets its power from capitalism."

My conclusion: AI didn't take our meaning, It made me realize I have always been looking in the wrong place and thus reacting ignoratly when I felt "denied" this thing I feel entitled to.

Love.

Edit: Love; paradoxically, ive felt both entitled to and unworthy of so I'm not sure WTF to do with that.

To wit: Our love of self is so closely tied to our output and if we have no output do we have value?

Edit: tl;dr - I am not sure I understand the point of anything anymore and many others feel the same way. I do not think this is some "existential crisis" I believe it is a logical conclusion to draw given the evidence presented by the day and age we live in.

spacecadet•12m ago
Well even 40k spent 20k years living like the jetsons... There are no analogs for our future. That's one of the core problems here, you have powerful individuals who identify with and aspire to sci-fi, while living in denial of reality. I would argue someone like Musk is more blue pilled and in the Matrix than they think they are...
quadrifoliate•8m ago
> The economic model since the industrial revolution is approaching its metamorphosis: robotic servants that can do everything for everyone.

Not true at all. If you have a robotic servant that can "do everything" for anywhere close to an affordable amount for even a middle-class person, please post a link and specify what it can do.

There a big gap between a tool that can spew out large amounts of code and something you trust to not screw up your house. Once I can tell a robot to do a simple plumbing task in my house, I'll believe in this metamorphosis you're talking about.

stonogo•7m ago
> robotic servants that can do everything for everyone.

Why do people keep positing this? The robots get better every year, but they don't get better fast enough to make me think there will be a robot servant doing anything for anyone in my lifetime. As has been the case for the past fifty years or so, they're either hyperspecialized or remote controlled by people, and neither of those spell doom for the economy.

arionhardison•2m ago
Honest question, did you forsee the last 2 or 3 years happening as fast as they have?
watwut•6m ago
Or, we can go back to reality and observe that people are not obsolete and all human work was not eradicates

Then we can take down monopolies, tax large corporations, regulate them, empower anti white colar crime agencies again and regulate finance.

That will actually do. Bullshitters and sociopaths are too empowered. That is an issue, and acute one.

panny•33m ago
I'm puzzled how people who didn't care about Snowden are suddenly very upset about Flock. I'm glad they finally decided the 4A is important.
GenerWork•24m ago
I'm not. The same people who seemingly magically cared about Flock overnight will move onto something else within the year. There's always something new to be outraged over, Flock is just the flavor of the week.
cheesemonk66•19m ago
I think this taps in to why big tech companies are unconcerned as well. How many of these people who oppose data centers have stopped utilizing their outputs? How many of these anti AI folks are using AI either at work or in their personal lives? It's just hot to hate AI right now.
Zsfe510asG•22m ago
It is more concrete now. For example the footage that was released about the Kirk shooter showed that you are filmed everywhere, including in residential areas.

People are beginning to understand.

msdz•22m ago
My take is that the difference is simply down to visibility, and by extension broader understanding, of the issue:

- Cameras film me and my family and neighbors everywhere in daily life => Obviously an issue

- Something about secret agencies maybe (?) reading along my messages => “I’ve got nothing to hide in there anyway”

red_admiral•23m ago
Something I never thought would happen: ultra-conservative Moms For Liberty and progressive education campaigners agree on something. Namely "get that AI out of our schools".

The Butlerian Jihad has started.

_aavaa_•15m ago
Can't wait for a society dependent on spice and which is still controlled those with political (or super human) powers.
Grombobulous•15m ago
It makes me wonder how the powers will be will manage to split this issue into powerless factions like they did for Occupy Wall St.
ianjbutler•6m ago
> The Butlerian Jihad has started.

I'll let you know when it's time

simianwords•4m ago
The progressive you speak about are conserving the ideologies they thought were revolutionary.

The conservatives you speak about are conserving ideologies they thought were revolutionary.

What both have in common is that they don't like change.

sergiotapia•22m ago
I thought this was going to be about h1b and the severe backlash ycombinator partners are facing online.
Zsfe510asG•17m ago
SV is also in denial that AI is the final straw that makes people leave the Internet.
cocacola1•11m ago
The industry needs messengers that can put out a positive vision that also aren’t creepy or skeezy seeming dudes. I don’t think Zuck’s WSJ manifesto convinced anyone, plus he’s a terrible messenger.
watwut•3m ago
Non creepy people were rejected by billionaires class, they just dont fit in. And conversely, non creepy people also avoid the tech bro creepy singularity is here crowd.
simianwords•6m ago
If any one follows culture wars, they'd know that a widespread and mostly crude backlash like this will inevitably trigger the correction and the correction will have a stronger inertia.

You must never play your hand like this or you risk being dunked on for your excessiveness.

2020's woke was like this btw.

imglorp•3m ago
For one thing, saying the quiet part out loud takes the covers off: https://www.artisan.co/blog/stop-hiring-humans

For another, apply AI where it's good but stop forcing it where it doesn't belong. Ask the users, they know.

CodingJeebus
•
17m ago
100%. Articles about obscure codename operations is a lot harder to grasp than "You are tracked at all times via your phone and license plate and here are the images to prove it".

It's the same as how communities respond to egregious law enforcement abuses. Accusations get nowhere as opposed to undeniable video of things like George Floyd.

singleshot_•3m ago
“See that thing? It’s watching you” vs. some complicated story about room 641a… I agree, it makes a degree of sense.
WD-42•21m ago
Lots of people cared, it just wasn’t actionable. The situation with flock has avenues for change in town hall meetings or even good ol fashioned vandalism.

Dragnet surveillance by the CIA was a bit harder to oppose.

JsonDemWitOster•19m ago
Optics and zeitgeist.

The Snowden leaks had too much of an abstract bogeyman. PRISM couldn't inspire critical mass outrage because, at the time, Big Tech was still genuinely useful and, besides, the Big Tech involved could be sidestepped with some inconvenience. Flock is neither directly useful nor avoidable unless you resolve to never leave your house.

Metadata tracking is, again, too abstract of a concept, too much a statistical what-if. Compare that with Flock which tracks your very countenance.

Most importantly IMO, Flock has a physical manifestation on which people can direct their anger. There is a "frontend" to actively subvert as opposed to a mere "backend" to avoid.

christophilus•18m ago
Is that the case? It seems to me that the people who cared about Snowden are basically the same people who care about Flock. Most of the people I know who didn't like Snowden also don't seem to care about Snowden. I do find it interesting / strange that conservatives (of which I am somewhat) don't care about Snowden or Flock. To me, the things Snowden revealed, and the crap Flock is doing are completely incompatible with the way I think government should function. But, maybe I'm more libertarian than conservative.
Libcat99•13m ago
If my local groups are any indication the flock stuff is angering both the left and the right, perhaps for different reasons. Same with datacenters.

The datacenter meeting for our board was the largest I've ever seen in town. They had to move it to the school auditorium when 1000+ people showed up the first time.

phil21•7m ago
The world (I guess politics, but more broadly how you envision society to fundamentally function) is far more broad and nuanced than the silly (American) liberal vs conservative buckets.

Just adding a “libertarian vs. authoritarian” axis to both labels changes things up wildly. And shows me at least a little bit how someone can label themselves conservative and also be totally fine with the surveillance state. Or totally against it.

Why does shipping a Nix upgrade move only the difference?

https://www.labcraft.dev/blog/nix-closures
1•anandsuresh•55s ago•0 comments

The agent web crawler census: 60 bots, 6,309 requests, zero payments

https://fetchgate.dev/tools/agent-census
1•chiefgrowth•1m ago•0 comments

Second Solutions

https://www.johndcook.com/blog/2026/08/27/second-solutions/
1•ibobev•1m ago•0 comments

Junk Solutions

https://www.johndcook.com/blog/2026/08/26/junk-solutions/
1•ibobev•2m ago•0 comments

Anthropic Announces Model Hardware Standard, MCP for Hardware?

https://modelhardwarestandard.com/
1•luigipederzani•2m ago•0 comments

BYD Ultra-Fast Charged Han 350 Times in 9 Days

https://insideevs.com/news/806301/byd-megawatt-charging-battery-health/
1•hochmartinez•2m ago•0 comments

US attempts to take noblogs offline

https://cavallette.noblogs.org/2026/08/10083/2
1•chris1993•2m ago•1 comments

OpenAI – Hugging Face Technical Report [pdf]

https://cdn.openai.com/pdf/67869394-cb91-4c12-888c-5cbd85c7814c/OpenAI-Hugging-Face%20Incident-Te...
1•Topfi•4m ago•0 comments

Show HN: A Windows 98 retro voting tug-O-war system

https://www.imright.wtf
1•Dubbo1•5m ago•0 comments

Lawsuit: Grok was trained on child sex abuse images of preschool-age victim

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/08/elon-musks-xai-used-child-porn-to-train-grok-models-l...
3•cdrnsf•5m ago•0 comments

LeanDB a strongly Typed SQL front end

https://theoric.com/blog/drafts/leandb_a_strongly_typed_sql_frontend/
1•hargup•8m ago•1 comments

Show HN: A 70x faster and 5x smaller XSS sanitizer than DOMPurify

https://github.com/ppmpreetham/DOMOxide
2•ppmpreetham•10m ago•0 comments

Traders brought Central American cacao to Georgia 1k years ago

https://arstechnica.com/science/2026/08/traders-brought-central-american-cacao-to-georgia-1000-ye...
2•pseudolus•11m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Get your app online in seconds

https://instapods.com/
1•not_wowinter13•13m ago•0 comments

Only 33 days left in project online retirement

https://onplana.com/migration/project-online-estate-assessment
1•Onplana•13m ago•1 comments

Accessible by default: writing a book like software

https://ben.balter.com/2026/08/27/accessible-by-default/
1•chmaynard•14m ago•0 comments

Lexicon: Manipulate DNS records in a standardized way in Python

https://github.com/dns-lexicon/dns-lexicon
1•gregsadetsky•14m ago•0 comments

Show HN: SvGrid – a Svelte 5 data grid an AI can drive to build a full app

https://github.com/sv-grid/sv-grid
1•boikom•16m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Rosebed – A Minecraft beta 1.7.3 reimplementation in Zig

https://mdmrk.github.io/rosebed/
1•talentedRed•16m ago•0 comments

Canada Hires 48 Scholars Away from Top U.S. Universities

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/27/world/canada/canada-universities-hire-us-researchers.html
4•mykowebhn•18m ago•0 comments

Just Some Generative Art

https://number-garden.com/?114336224149876@THLP@
1•unitX•18m ago•0 comments

$900M paid out to end wind farm project going to firm run by Mar-a-Lago neighbor

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/trump-windfarm-money-neighbors-flor...
3•pseudolus•19m ago•0 comments

The Frictions That Make AI Forecasting Hard

https://twitter.com/AnneliesGamble/status/2087259132667810162
2•gmays•20m ago•0 comments

China's humanoid robots aren't smart enough to take your job – yet

https://www.reuters.com/investigations/chinas-humanoid-robots-arent-smart-enough-take-your-job-ye...
2•YeGoblynQueenne•21m ago•1 comments

Pydantic AI

https://pydantic.dev/docs/ai/overview/
3•monneyboi•22m ago•0 comments

Meta Paid $17B – Gets to Write Safety Rules for Other SocMedia Platform

https://www.techdirt.com/2026/08/26/meta-just-paid-nearly-17-billion-to-make-sure-it-gets-to-writ...
11•ano-ther•22m ago•1 comments

Alleged Russian assassination plot uncovers 'The Sims 3' (2022)

https://www.washingtonpost.com/video-games/2022/04/26/russian-assassination-sims-3/
3•latexr•22m ago•0 comments

libBeresta – cross-platform C library for generating PDF files

https://github.com/libBeresta/libBeresta
2•smartmic•23m ago•0 comments

De-slop the text you shouldn't be writing anyway

https://blog.stephenturner.us/p/deslop
3•epistasis•24m ago•0 comments

Agentic engineering: a practical guide to reliable coding agents

https://scottspence.com/posts/agentic-engineering-practical-guide
3•mellosouls•25m ago•0 comments