frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Strands Harness

https://strandsagents.com/blog/introducing-strands-harness/
52•zuckerborg0101•1h ago

Comments

tontinton•46m ago
Can you also compare in the charts https://maki.sh?

Should give you some competition.

fxwin•44m ago
why would you include oh-my-pi in the comparison but not vanilla pi?
chaos_emergent•37m ago
Am I wrong in saying that the interfaces presented to the model in OMP versus plain old Pi are identical?
c0rruptbytes•32m ago
OMP has a lot of candy that raises token cost compared to vanilla pi
whattheheckheck•44m ago
Pretty crazy amazon is advertising an open source repo. Not suggesting this is an ad but I've seen ads on reddit for it.

Ive heard from a 25 yoe consultant in a meetup group in person that aws agentcore was THE best way to handle enterprise agentic workflows with all of the proper knobs for governance etc since it comes with the iam integrations and arns etc.

theturtletalks•42m ago
Why is Pi not in the benchmarks? Deepseek beats Strands and its built on Pi so that’s all I needed to know.
techscruggs•31m ago
Deepseek was cheaper, but also less accurate. "Beats" isn't a fair assessment.
theturtletalks•11m ago
That’s fair, but Strands is advertising their harness needing way less tokens which does relate to cost.

In that same vein, Pi is less bloated then Deepseek and Oh My Pi, which are built on top of Pi. Isn’t it dubious to leave it out?

leodavi•11m ago
Deepseek harness is not actually built on Pi harness. It's an independent project.
jsw97•6m ago
Came here to say this. They have oh-my-pi in the benchmark but not pi, but those are very different animals. pi is lightweight out of the box so has very little start-time overhead. (And will not spin up agents like crazy.) pi might do worse if those things are actually important for solving the problem, but it certainly has a shot at being most efficient.
llmslave•42m ago
Amazon is so hopelessly behind in AI, nothing they produce aside from cloud infrastructure is actually good

The big threat to AWS is that coding agents dont need all of their complicated infrastructure, which was built for humans. Agents can use low level primitives, i.e. just a raw server

time0ut•35m ago
The sales pressure from them on their agent core stuff has been really shocking over the last six months. Never seen anything like it.
__alexs•33m ago
How are people using custom harnesses cost effectively? Do they avoid Anthropic models so they can use OpenAI subscription pricing and open weights stuff?
agentdev001•32m ago
Yes. Or- use them at work, where management is taking a... hands off approach to ~integrating ai~ into the workplace.
Juvination•27m ago
For what it's worth I've been using Anthropic models on Pi for months now with no issues. It's not recommended since it breaks TOS but you can do it.
everforward•27m ago
I use Pi and mostly open weight models. I pay for the $20/month Ollama plan and use Deepseek and GLM through that. I’ve never hit the limits on it, but I tend to ask for targeted things rather than “implement a whole feature in one prompt”.

I do keep an OpenRouter account topped up for things that Ollama doesn’t have. 99% of my usage there is embeddings, the other 1% is wanting to test some new model Ollama doesn’t have.

behole•17m ago
I'm using Opencode Go in OMP or Hermes. $10 a month and I have only ever hit a limit using qwen3.8MAX on X-High. This is a migration from 20x on Claude.
solarkraft•17m ago
seizethecheese•32m ago
> With Fable 5, Strands harness cost 77% less than Claude Code and scored higher on Terminal Bench 2.1.

Terminal Bench 2.1 is saturated. Many token saving techniques would save money and score basically the same running Fable 5 against Terminal Bench 2.1. (They claim a better score but don’t say how much better. I’d bet my favorite hat that it’s not statistically significant.)

This is at least the fourth time I’ve seen a project hit front page with a “save money with same score on saturated benchmark” claim.

dwoosley•32m ago
I’m sure it was not a coincidence that this was released the day after Kimi 3 was added to bedrock.
hmokiguess•32m ago
Will they block me if I build an agent with this that shops on Amazon?
samusiam•31m ago
> But the moment you build your own agent, you’re on your own. It’s tricky wiring up the right primitives just well enough to match that “it just worked” feeling.

It's wild to me to claim that it's tricky to customize one of these harnesses and for that to be the entire justification for an entirely different harness.

It's really not that hard. If you want to reduce costs then all you need to do is practice delegation: instead of using the strong model, all the time to do everything, instead, you have the stronger model delegate well-defined tasks to a weaker model. Patterns like these are really easy to wire up.

seizethecheese•21m ago
Yes, it’s a wild claim. I built a harness for a random side project without even thinking hard about it. The harness was that from the hardest part of the project.

Is this corporate confabulation?

ChickeNES•30m ago
Does anyone else take these kinds of articles, drop them into ChatGPT, crank it up to Pro, and then have it write issues against your personal harness?
agentdev001•26m ago
"We noticed builders often wished their Claude Code or Codex setup could run in the cloud because locally their agent idea just “worked” with those harnesses.

But the moment you build your own agent, you’re on your own. It’s tricky wiring up the right primitives just well enough to match that “it just worked” feeling."

Im sorry, but who is saying this? If you just throw this statement into agent of your choice- and ask what native integrations exist to cover this use: OAI and Anthropic both have a handful of options here. Claude Agent SDK, Claude managed agents, Codex exec, Codex sdk, Codex app server, openai agents sdk, openai agents api.

agentdev001•16m ago
Beyond that though, I'm certainly interested in the performance side of things. "Keep an eye out for a follow-up paper from our researchers regarding these benchmarks." Yes plz.
johnmlussier•23m ago
I am increasingly hesitant to use non-native harnesses - model providers are now starting to train their agents for use within the harness. An eval like terminal bench can only capture so much data. I don't want to have to assess each harness every model release to make sure it's working as well as it can.
avaer•9m ago
This matters less as models get better and everyone settles on the same overall harness architectures. The model matters more than the harness anyway.

The bigger issue is that the use cases and harnesses for models is infinite, which is hard to compress into benchmark numbers that actually apply to you.

Everyone is benchmaxxing, desperate to sell, and almost nobody except the labs is doing actual science on the results, so harnesses tend to be chosen on voodoo and hunches, like which company made it. There isn't necessarily a good alternative though, bearing the cost of being a harness researcher is probably not many people's goal.

altcognito•2m ago
Agreed, especially since the more frontier models are able to accomplish in a vacuum, the more people will trust them. That being said, tool use is still really important for pulling in the right information.
stogot•4m ago
I’m the opposite. I want one open source harness to rule them all

Cost efficiency is a plus

debarshri•18m ago
This seems to be from AWS team. Is that right?
Oras•17m ago
I remember reading about strands SDK and it looked great in terms how everything is an event that you can extend, so this harness feels quite about right.

However, for this kind of customisation, Pi is actually quite great. One of the most things I love about Pi is ability to ask it to create an extension and it does it quite well as it’s part of their docs. Also ability to customise the system prompt to avoid the clutter that Claude Code add (around 20k system prompt that mostly had nothing to do with the code).

The demo was showing something I have created for my Pi setup, which is asking me in each new session which skills and MCP I would to enable for the session. This works quite well if you have multiple projects where you don’t need all skills but just a small subset

ticulatedspline•16m ago
finally paying up for chatGPT and using the Codex desktop app was my real "I'm sold" moment with AI.

Setting up projects and working with the AI on local files has been great, but only for my personal account. I've been trying to get it set up for work that provides OpenAI models through a 3rd party tool, company hosted models, as local-machine models and the UX is just straight up awful.

there's no GUI for profiles or custom endpoints, the config.toml sucks and the overall experience is primitive.

At this stage I really want a Codex-like harness but I need more fluid control over the models, I want features like pinning a project to a provider, as well as pulling in all the models from that provider, also having all providers available.

So if I need to pop over to one project to consult about product A, then pop to another project to do some code analysis on product B I can do so fluidly and have my tokens billed to the right place for each concern.

or a project that can span all of the resources. like having the OpenAi models orchestrate sub-agents on the local or hosted models.

That’s exactly what I do. OpenAI + Opencode Go subs, 0 interest in Claude.
zamalek•14m ago
OpenAI. It avoids Claudish too.
micromacrofoot•11m ago
pi on open weights, I only use frontier models to do a review pass

Functionally Zen

https://testdouble.com/insights/functionally-zen
2•BerislavLopac•2m ago•0 comments

Trump reveals millions of dollars' worth of share deals in big tech and AI

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c6p3kxpp8lezo
2•tartoran•2m ago•0 comments

OpenAI nabs key Patreon execs ahead of upcoming announcement

https://www.theverge.com/ai-artificial-intelligence/999249/openai-creators-patreon-execs-hire-sam...
1•elffjs•2m ago•0 comments

Open-weight models now carry 56% of production tokens and 14% of the spend

https://fromtheterminal.substack.com/p/your-production-traffic-already-left-the-frontier
1•oldfamily•3m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Volum – An open-source visual library for 3D model files

https://volum.didac.dev/
2•sabatesduran•3m ago•0 comments

iPhone 4 "Antennagate" Q&A – Steve Jobs, Tim Cook and Bob Mansfield (2010) [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiN5ERktXz0
1•Austin_Conlon•10m ago•0 comments

Containers Are No Longer a Security Boundary

https://depthfirst.com/research/containers-are-no-longer-safe
2•conor-•11m ago•0 comments

Data Centers Are Theft

https://www.machinesociety.ai/p/data-centers-are-theft
1•mikelgan•11m ago•0 comments

Is AI killing the forums and wikis your IT team relies on?

https://www.spiceworks.com/ai/is-ai-quietly-killing-the-forums-and-wikis-your-it-team-relies-on/
1•MC995•12m ago•0 comments

The science of Monkey Island: can grog dissolve a metal mug that fast?

https://jgeekstudies.org/2026/09/23/the-science-of-monkey-island-can-grog-actually-dissolve-a-met...
2•zdw•13m ago•0 comments

Top post in R/gamedev: "AI models have caught up with Unity dev."

https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1wo5asm/ai_models_have_caught_up_with_unity_dev_my/
2•ralfd•13m ago•1 comments

We ported the original Doom to SQL

https://cedardb.com/blog/sqldoom/
1•Vaslo•13m ago•0 comments

Show HN: A browser word game about composing Chinese characters

https://www.chunqiuyiyu.com/zigrid/
1•chunqiuyiyu•14m ago•0 comments

What's Inside Fauci's Diary [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dFKRVfguxto
1•db48x•16m ago•0 comments

Systemd v262 Released

https://github.com/systemd/systemd/releases/tag/v262
2•dimonomid•16m ago•0 comments

AI anxiety is sweeping the globe – and cutting across party lines

https://www.politico.eu/article/poll-ai-anxiety-openai-anthropic-elon-musk-silicon-valley-across-...
1•lf88•18m ago•0 comments

Linux Implements Dynamic Bash Tab Completion

https://salivity.github.io/linux/article/how-linux-implements-dynamic-bash-tab-completion
1•ankitg12•19m ago•0 comments

I Couldn't Build Jev at OpenAI – Diogo Almeida, TypeSafe Co-Founder and CEO [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cFx9Z3ZXca0
3•ABS•19m ago•0 comments

Performance and safety of a multi-cancer early detection test

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-026-04618-w
1•brandonb•20m ago•0 comments

Ethics of Agent Exploitation

https://blog.cygankiewicz.com/en/ethics-of-agent-exploitation/
1•mpkc•21m ago•0 comments

Build a devtool once. Mount it anywhere

https://devfra.me
1•flashblaze•21m ago•0 comments

Troubleshooting a weird keyboard on a Pentium III

https://www.rubenerd.au/troubleshooting-a-weird-keyboard-on-a-pentium-3/
1•speckx•22m ago•0 comments

Show HN: a Rust crate to mock concrete type without using trait

https://github.com/XTSoftwareLabs/shimforge
1•xtsoftwarelabs•22m ago•0 comments

Woman Arrested, Dragged Away After Speaking About Flock at City Council Meeting

https://www.404media.co/woman-arrested-after-city-council-denies-residents-right-to-speak-on-floc...
22•latexr•22m ago•3 comments

Anthropic made Opus 5.5 cheaper. Then it broke four things your agent depends on

https://thenewstack.io/claude-opus-agent-migration/
1•rkovashikawa•23m ago•0 comments

I Manage Homebrew from a UI

https://albertoarena.it/posts/how-i-manage-homebrew-from-a-ui/
1•albertoarena•23m ago•0 comments

An agent is not an extension of the employee who created it

https://getlago.com/blog/how-to-bill-ai-agents
1•AnhTho_FR•25m ago•0 comments

Agent Communication Protocol

https://agentcommunicationprotocol.dev/introduction/welcome
2•ChickeNES•26m ago•0 comments

Search is a 2.9 mb browser for the Mac based on WebKit

https://officecommun.com/search
1•aitanabewa•26m ago•0 comments

Tokonomics–AST context compiler to stop hitting Claude/GPT rate limits in VSCode

https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=Tokonomics.tokonomics-ai
1•tokonomics•28m ago•0 comments