frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

The truth behind the accuracy of weather forecasts

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-05-16/weather-forecast-accuracy-bom/105297540
47•Brajeshwar•3d ago

Comments

bmink•3d ago
Weather forecast is best told as a narrative and reducing it to a sports score like temperature / rainfall will always be problematic for many regions.

I’m in SF and I have not looked at a “TV/app style” forecast in years. Instead every morning I read:

https://forecast.weather.gov/product.php?format=CI&glossary=...

During the day I look periodically at:

https://fog.today

vrosas•3h ago
Enjoy NOAA’s data while they still have funding.
mplanchard•3h ago
I also like the pure NWS data, and will take a moment to shill Deep Weather on iOS, which provides a nice, easy interface to the NWS products for an area.
fred_is_fred•3h ago
I've been looking for something like this but unfortunately I am halfway between two stations and with the mountains here makes enough of a difference that neither one is accurate.
ttobbaybbob•2h ago
or if you want nicely wrapped pure NWS data you can get results like https://trytako.com/card/EK32MAxL85E5_KOZy6R3/?dark_mode=tru... via our API
hnburnsy•56m ago
NWS already has it wrapped nicely just supply your lat/long, and offers the XML version too. Example...

Hourly Weather Forecast Graph (48 hours)

https://forecast.weather.gov/MapClick.php?lat=28.4963&lon=-8...

XML Version

https://forecast.weather.gov/MapClick.php?lat=28.4963&lon=-8...

hnburnsy•1h ago
>I also like the pure NWS data

NWSNOW for Android, includes the vaunted "Forecast Discussion". Side load, No ads, no tracking, pure NWS and NOAA data.

https://www.nwsnow.net/

gdryke•1h ago
I made a val to clean this up a little better: https://www.val.town/x/greg_dryke/nwsForecastDiscussionWeb

The `<pre>` on the NWS site was really messy on mobile, this is nice and neat. Feel free to fork it and use your own, or this link should work for your NWS site too!

https://greg_dryke--0816a61c279c11f09d52569c3dd06744.web.val...

(No promises on possible future changes if you do start using it, but it's pretty stable.)

jimmaswell•1h ago
I found reader mode in Firefox Mobile worked fine too, but yours doesn't have the broken line breaks like reader mode did.
ggm•4h ago
Dangerous to claim rain forecasts approach perfection. It may be statistically true, but it's highly politicised in Australia, it has strong ties to forward financial outcome in the farm sector which is primed to be suspicious of government and see the BoM as "the enemy" for a clutch of bizarre conspiracy theory reasons.

If you make this claim, be prepared for the hate storm when it gets it wrong for some marginalised community.

Also, the lack of warning processes in flood contexts means the BoM can claim it gets the rain forecast right, but the downstream flood alerts which lie in the hands of 3 tiers of government still break down. Who gets the blame? EVERYONE including the BoM.

I love the BoM. But, I worry about them too. They could be defunded for political gain.

Also: their app is crap and for bizarre reasons they still offer their weather radar in the best, most simplest, 1990s internet form over http:// urls because of the overhang of farm equipment which can't handle TLS https: connections. There is a good https: service but they modernised the UX. I would prefer the 1990s style, but delivered over secure transport. (browsers now routinely preference https: urls so you wind up with an interstitial delay. minor nit only)

If you use windy, or willyweather, it's federating BoM data with other sources.

danpalmer•4h ago
I'm not Australian, and moved here a year ago, but the obsession with the BoM is... odd? As an outsider, I see a website that's a mess from the early 2000s, and weather forecasts that just aren't very good (neither accurate nor detailed?).

An event I was recently supposed to go to was called off because the BoM forecast rain all day 3 days out. Google Weather said it would be dry and sunny. It was dry and sunny. It's an anecdote not data, but so far I'm not understanding the national obsession based on this and a few other personal experiences.

layoric•3h ago
Obsession is a bit much, but one of the few genuinely "for the public good" institutions remaining. Others we have seen get hollowed out or replaced. A lot of hard work has and does go into providing the services that the BoM does. We are a big country with a small population, and they have been around for over 100 years which is a long time considering our federation was around the same time.

I, and many other Australian's, like public institutions without a profit motive. Gutting these institutions usually ends up with worse privately operated ones.

ggm•2h ago
Looking at what is happening to NOAA it's a right wing reaction to climate science: because climate and weather are sister topics, they go after the agency on one political agenda, (climate) and the other side of the coin (weather) suffers. And, most of the opposition from communities like farming comes from the strong suspicion of being "told what to do" about climate and land management.

It's a horrendous impedence mismatch. I did debate not directly putting right-wing into this, but my personal experience of speaking to people in the farming sector who are sharing hate on the BoM is that it's driven in right wing political agenda about "big government" and "world government" and "my tax dollars"

jamesfinlayson•2h ago
I remember talking with someone who worked in Antarctica and he said there was a wall somewhere in the station that displayed weather forecasts from a bunch of government run weather services from a bunch of different countries - Australia's was apparently frequently different to what everyone else was saying (they had some long-running nick-name for it which I no longer recall).
iamthemonster•2h ago
I'm also a blow-in but I've been in Australia 14 years. "The BoM" is a fascinating Australian cultural artefact and even in weather-obsessed Britain (where Michael Fish was a household name in a similar category to Hitler and Stalin) there was nothing similar.

I think the parent comment goes some way to explaining something I find bizarre - the "extreme weather warnings" from the BoM, which they issue for every light breeze. I even have a fabric gazebo erected in my back yard, held down only by sandbags at the corners, and I don't have to disassemble it for every BoM "extreme weather warning" for wind/storms.

There are so many "extreme weather warnings" for wind that they'd be meaningless for everyone who's not in a small boat.

ggm•32m ago
We loved Michael Fish. Nobody in my circuit mistook the Met Office for the NKVD. When he went off air, he had a fan club calling for his return.
magarnicle•41m ago
I've stopped asking my Google Assistant if it will rain because it gets it wrong most of the time, at least for my location. I just look at the radar in the BoM app now (agreed that the website is terrible).
jiggawatts•3h ago
> I love the BoM.

You have no reason to. They're not a well-run, efficient organisation, even by government department standards.

> over http:// urls because of the overhang of farm equipment which can't handle TLS https: connections.

This is the public narrative, and is a brazen lie.

THERE IS NO SUCH FARMING EQUIPMENT!

Certainly not in 2025.

Their site DOES HAVE a certificate, and supports HTTPS, right now.

They just refuse to let you use it, redirecting a successful HTTPS connection back to HTTP.

If there was farming equipment (Which models? Vendors? Affecting how many farmers?) out there they would be broken right now because port 443 is open and listening. If they can connect to port 443, then they don't need to be redirected back to port 80 because they worked. If they can only connect to port 80, then the presence of port 443 makes no difference.

I keep pointing this out, and "true blue aussies that looooove the BoM" keep arguing about this. The BoM spends hundreds of millions on IT, tens of millions on consultancies like Accenture, but they can't manage a $50 certificate and a bog standard HTTP/HTTPS endpoint.

My iPhone, right now, can't connect to most BoM web pages because of this stupid, stupid issue! There is no mystical broken farming equipment, but there definitely are inconvenienced users like me!

After putting up this rant for years and years in various forums, a former BoM employee finally fessed up -- they were the one that tried switching HTTP to HTTPS years ago and "broke" their internal systems. Not non-existent farming equipment, it was BoM's own internal services that fell over.

Why?

Because they hadn't updated any of it in decades, and the software was so old that it couldn't handle "modern" cipher suites and TLS versions. Modern being "newer than SSL 3.0"... in 2015.

That's not the sign of a competently run organisation worthy of admiration.

RachelF•3h ago
Farmers have a reason to be sceptical:

The BoM caused hundreds of millions of $ of damage to livestock farming - they warned about a huge drought in 2022 causing massive livestock culling. Instead there were years of above-average rainfall.

ggm•2h ago
The BoM cop this both ways. People don't look to the candlestick error bars on their statements, and their long range weather forecast is outside the window of the ABC article we're discussing. I get how upsetting it is to de-stock but if their best belief is the risk is high, what else are they meant to do? If they hadn't said this, and there'd been the drought, they would have got your scorn too, right?

If you know a climate/weather bureau of comparable scale of footprint doing a better job, we'd all like to know. AFAIK there isn't one: most of the alternates work in different scale, with different climate forcing functions.

FiatLuxDave•2h ago
Does anyone know of any weather sites which show the actual outcomes? It is very easy to find forecasts. It is quite difficult to find what the weather actually was on a given day at a location, but at least it is possible. I have never seen a site that shows the predicted weather for a day alongside the actual weather for that day. I presume professional meteorologists know where to look for this data, but for the rest of us, it feels like it is hidden.

I know no one wants to advertise their mistakes, but showing a history of your accuracy which was transparently updated would build more credibility with the public than anything else. Perhaps someone is scraping this info and posting it?

nerdralph•2h ago
Environment Canada has hourly historical data for many stations. Some may be daily. https://climate.weather.gc.ca/historical_data/search_histori...
lif•1h ago
agree.

Even a site that displays 'just' recent weather specifics (sans how the forecast was) would be quite helpful.

e.g., the hourly precipitation for the last week or month.

Am NOT talking about generalized monthly climate data, fwiw.

Anyone?

grigri907•38m ago
University of Iowa has a service to aggregate this sort of thing. It's CSV format, but otherwise seems like what you're looking for?

https://mesonet.agron.iastate.edu/request/download.phtml

havaloc•1h ago
Somewhat related: Before launching our new long range (5 day) turbulence forecast tool (for nervous flyers), we spent time experimenting to see how far out we could reliably predict turbulence. Once we had something promising, we started posting daily snapshots—each showing the forecast from five days earlier alongside what actually happened. The model updates continuously, and we’ve kept the process public to demonstrate how well it works, not just claim it does.

https://www.turbulenceforecast.com/drift

sunshinesnacks•1h ago
This NOAA National Blend of Models (NBM) viewer lets you enable observations and then roll back the forecast initialization date to see forecasts and observations at the same time.

It’s experimental, and selecting weather stations is a little clunky, but it has some really cool info that’s hard to find other places.

https://apps.gsl.noaa.gov/nbmviewer/?col=2&hgt=1&obs=true&fo...

Edit:

This GEFS plume viewer is cool, too.

https://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/users/meg/gefs_plumes/index.ht...

You can check a box to plot observations and then pick an older “cycle”.

Both are limited to the US.

BrenBarn•9m ago
I have wondered this for years. Several times I looked for a dataset of historical forecasts. It seems wild that with all the data available out there, there's no go-to source that has past forecasts together with the actual recorded data for each day. That said, these posts do mention some sources:

https://opendata.stackexchange.com/questions/2009/historical...

https://www.reddit.com/r/meteorology/comments/1crs6lu/seekin...

(These aren't "sites" that display the past data, just datasets you can download.)

WalterBright•2h ago
I've often better at predicting "will it rain" by looking out the window.
braiamp•2h ago
Which makes sense depending on what the reach of the forecast is on geographical scales. In my country, you have 6-7 meteorological zones that needs predictions, but the forecasters would always say "area so-so will have rains", because those meteorological zones don't fit neatly into our administrative distributions. That also means that if a administrative area is split between two zones, is a 50-50 whenever or not the prediction will turn out to be accurate.
konfusinomicon•22m ago
I've got an old foot injury that gets sore when rain is coming with surprisingly good accuracy
gerdesj•2h ago
Weather forecasts are based on models and extrapolation based on a lot of factors. I'm not too certain but I think that the smallest weather model cell size is about two miles squared or perhaps cubed - I don't know how the models work.

Weather forecast distribution is by "news". News is deployed at mostly fixed intervals.

Anecdote: In Yeovil, Somerset, UK. The topography here (its quite hilly here in a county with some fairly famous "levels") means that it can be pissing down with rain on one side of the town and be dry on the other side and so on.

Weather forecasting is a quite hard problem. The really hard problem is delivering it.

ccgreg•1h ago
I aggregate weather forecasts for the Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration, which is the collaboration behind those black hole images you might have seen.

We want to pick the best nights during an observing window based on the weather in 12 locations around the world. These are mostly locations on the peaks of mountains, where it's hard to do a good forecast because the ground is rugged on length scales that are smaller than the grid in the numerical computation.

Forecast accuracy has improved in recent years, but I'm really looking forward to AI forecasts. They appear to fix some systematic errors that are still present in traditional forecast simulations.

InfiniteRand•23m ago
I'm curious if anyone has a good solution for this, how to accurately display cases where a storm might hit either Monday or Tuesday, say 50% chance each. If you just say there's a 50% chance of rain on both days, it looks like there's a significant chance (I guess 25%) that it will rain both days, when the real likelihood of both days raining might be far lower.

DDoSecrets publishes 410 GB of heap dumps, hacked from TeleMessage

https://micahflee.com/ddosecrets-publishes-410-gb-of-heap-dumps-hacked-from-telemessages-archive-server/
213•micahflee•3h ago•47 comments

The Windows Subsystem for Linux is now open source

https://blogs.windows.com/windowsdeveloper/2025/05/19/the-windows-subsystem-for-linux-is-now-open-source/
1143•pentagrama•11h ago•739 comments

Have I Been Pwned 2.0

https://www.troyhunt.com/have-i-been-pwned-2-0-is-now-live/
380•LorenDB•6h ago•127 comments

A shower thought turned into a Collatz visualization

https://abstractnonsense.com/collatz/
58•abstractbill•2h ago•6 comments

What are people doing? Live-ish estimates based on global population dynamics

https://humans.maxcomperatore.com/
39•willbc•2h ago•12 comments

Jules: An Asynchronous Coding Agent

https://jules.google/
233•travisennis•6h ago•103 comments

Zod 4

https://zod.dev/v4
609•bpierre•12h ago•188 comments

GitHub Copilot Coding Agent

https://github.blog/changelog/2025-05-19-github-copilot-coding-agent-in-public-preview/
361•net01•11h ago•214 comments

Claude Code SDK

https://docs.anthropic.com/en/docs/claude-code/sdk
290•sync•9h ago•130 comments

Launch HN: Better Auth (YC X25) – Authentication Framework for TypeScript

187•bekacru•13h ago•67 comments

Kilo: A text editor in less than 1000 LOC with syntax highlight and search

https://github.com/antirez/kilo
83•klaussilveira•7h ago•11 comments

Terraform MCP Server

https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform-mcp-server
44•kesor•5h ago•6 comments

Is-even-ai – Check if a number is even using the power of AI

https://www.npmjs.com/package/is-even-ai
183•modinfo•3h ago•81 comments

Run GitHub Actions locally

https://github.com/nektos/act
181•flashblaze•3d ago•73 comments

Game theory illustrated by an animated cartoon game

https://ncase.me/trust/
227•felineflock•11h ago•40 comments

The forbidden railway: Vienna-Pyongyang (2008)

http://vienna-pyongyang.blogspot.com/2008/04/how-everything-began.html
148•1317•9h ago•39 comments

The man who visited every country in the world – without boarding a plane (2023)

https://www.theguardian.com/travel/2023/aug/16/take-the-high-road-the-man-who-visited-every-country-in-the-world-without-boarding-a-plane
12•thunderbong•2d ago•1 comments

Show HN: A free, privacy preserving, archive of public Discord servers

https://searchcord.io
7•searchcord•1h ago•0 comments

Remarks on AI from NZ

https://nealstephenson.substack.com/p/remarks-on-ai-from-nz
133•zdw•4d ago•71 comments

Ask HN: When will managers be replaced by AI?

21•GianFabien•1h ago•13 comments

xAI's Grok 3 comes to Microsoft Azure

https://techcrunch.com/2025/05/19/xais-grok-3-comes-to-microsoft-azure/
99•mfiguiere•11h ago•90 comments

Too Much Go Misdirection

https://flak.tedunangst.com/post/too-much-go-misdirection
154•todsacerdoti•12h ago•74 comments

Patience too cheap to meter

https://www.seangoedecke.com/patience-too-cheap-to-meter/
19•swah•2d ago•7 comments

WireGuard vanity keygen

https://github.com/axllent/wireguard-vanity-keygen
58•simonpure•7h ago•7 comments

Memory Consistency Models: A Tutorial

https://jamesbornholt.com/blog/memory-models/
11•tanelpoder•2h ago•1 comments

ClawPDF – Open-Source Virtual/Network PDF Printer with OCR and Image Support

https://github.com/clawsoftware/clawPDF
180•miles•15h ago•23 comments

Glasskube (YC S24) is hiring in Vienna to build Open Source deployment tools

https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/glasskube/jobs/wjB77iZ-founding-engineer-go-typescript-kubernetes-docker
1•pmig•10h ago

Self-Hosting Moose with Docker Compose, Redis, Temporal, Redpanda and ClickHouse

https://docs.fiveonefour.com/moose/deploying/self-hosting/deploying-with-docker-compose
27•Callicles•5h ago•8 comments

Microbes in Gowanus teach lessons on fighting industrial pollution

https://engineering.nyu.edu/news/microbes-brooklyn-superfund-site-teach-lessons-fighting-industrial-pollution
13•eatonphil•3d ago•2 comments

Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from same cancer as Joe Biden

https://www.thewrap.com/dilbert-scott-adams-prostate-cancer-biden/
292•dale_huevo•10h ago•336 comments