Not sure if he just recognizes the shapes as they appear or tries to make them appear, would be nice if he came here to answer.
I would've also appreciated a discussion of how intuition of geometry might apply to chess playing abilities and how it might not be sufficient for playing chess well.
As a side note, I appreciated the small typos as a further signal that this was written by a human.
False.
Crows for example understand geometry. I’d wager there are plenty more.
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adt3718
“ These geometrical concepts do not exist in nature. There are no lines and squares. If it's obvious then why did it take 4.5 billion years since the development of life to emerge?”
What makes you think lines and squares don’t exist in nature? And what on earth does that have to do with how long life took to emerge?!
Here's Gromov, one of the greatest geometers of the last 50 years, discussing his viewpoint on this.
He also has this series of talks beginning with the question "What is probability, what is randomness?"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJAQVletzdY&list=PLx5f8IelFR...
As we learn that animals do things like have homosexual relationships, giggle when tickled, and understand basic rules of economics... biologists are learning to phrase it as "until we prove animals do _X_ we cannot be sure if animals do _X_", which is much safer.
(Also, there are trillions of lines in nature - WTF? Squares are somewhat rarer, except on the ground in wombat territory...)
This probably goes back to the classic debate between rationalism and empiricism. Do we have squares as a priori knowledge, or do we generalize from examples? But then how do we make abstract deductions about things? Do these deductions skew a certain way?
Clearly, deductive logic exists, yet also clearly, empiric observations exist. How do you properly marry the two?
https://intellectualmathematics.com/blog/rationalism-2-0-kan...
I've beaten over 2500 ELO in Crazyhouse on Lichess (2518 to be exact). Currently rated around 1900.
Am I missing something?
> Shapes are hypothesized to be formed by a programming language in the brain.
And what does this even mean? What does it mean for there to be a "programming language" in the brain?
Only a couple brief mentions about how chess piece moves are lines and transforms of lines. Other than that the author never establishes the title.
I was actually looking for some insight about chess and did not get any.
khelavastr•4d ago