frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Dynamical dark energy and the week that broke cosmology

https://perimeterinstitute.ca/news/dynamical-dark-energy-and-week-broke-cosmology
23•rznicolet•1d ago

Comments

ck2•49m ago
to be fair, cosmology has been broken every several months lately (Hubble Tension, etc.)

I mean that's how science works, discover something new, rewrite knowledge

not like religion where you make stuff up before you know anything about anything and then force everything new to adapt to the legacy of decisions thousands of years prior

Joker_vD•31m ago
Is it? Because it all really looks awfully close to "okay, fine, the dark energy/matter apparently also can do/be this stuff as well, just so we can write in whatever correction factors we need to make the theory fit the observations".
bognition•27m ago
Its fundamentally different. Science doesn't ask you to accept unknowns on faith, its provides evidence that there is something we dont yet understand and that evidence has predictive value.

If science operated like religion it would say "We dont know what dark energy is, but you have to accept it or your wrong".

Instead the argument is "Hmm... our current best understanding of the universe is lacking, when we add in these extra variables many of our predictions go from wildly inaccurate to nearly accurate. There must be something going on here we cannot observe, so lets call it "dark"."

Dark energy is "Wow, there's a factor at play here that we dont understand, without it our equations do not predict what we see, with it the equations are very accurate. Additionally we can predict multiple different things with this."

And the most important part, as soon as there is evidence that refutes the Dark Energy/Matter hypothesis scientists will quickly (over a few years, a decade at the most) walk away from it. Versus religious systems take centuries for people to shift their beliefs.

pdonis•19m ago
> it all really looks awfully close to "okay, fine, the dark energy/matter apparently also can do/be this stuff as well, just so we can write in whatever correction factors we need to make the theory fit the observations".

The dark energy density is already a parameter in the model. The simplest case for such a parameter is that it's just a constant, so in the absence of evidence to the contrary, Occam's Razor led cosmologists to adopt it.

But now we have evidence that suggests that it's not a constant, so we're looking at the next simplest case, a function of time (but still constant everywhere in space at each instant of time). The article describes how the DESI data suggest that it's a slowly decreasing function of time.

What has not happened is people making up models and continuing to insist on them even after the data says otherwise. That's what the GP was saying religion does.

chowells•11m ago
Yes, you're describing cosmology. We can't create separate test universes, so all we can do is argue over which model is the best way to explain our observations. The difference from ad-hoc reasoning is the exact same as any other science. You make predictions based on models and then try to find places where those predictions hold - or are broken. In either case, you're testing the validity of a model. And when something isn't good enough, you either adjust the model or find a new one that works better.

This isn't some slapdash random patching. Everyone involved knows that assuming that the λ in λCDM is a constant is shaky. It could be a function of time, or even location in some way. But it's simplest if it's a constant. So you start by modeling the universe as if it is. Then you determine what sorts of observations would support or contradict that, and you start making them. When you get results, you start examining what version of the model best explains those observations. And someone somewhere goes off to try find a better model than any version of λCDM. If they succeed, their model will eventually supplant it. This is how science progresses, even if the experiments are less under the control of the experimentors than they'd like. The important part that you make revisions in response to observations.

(FWIW, particle physicists are constantly frustrated that they can't find counterexamples to the Standard Model. They know it has to be incomplete, but the lack of contradictory observation leaves them no direction to try to improve it.)

MarkusQ•36m ago
> A recent analysis by the Dark Energy Survey Supernova Program also finds a preference for evolving dark energy, in the same direction as DESI DR2, but with a slightly lower statistical significance (bringing the combined significance down from 4.2 sigma to only 3.2).

Is this right? It would seem that adding another finding "in the same direction" should always increase the statistical significance, even if only slightly if the new evidence is week.

Under what circumstances could additional evidence for X reduce the estimated likelihood of X?

ElevenLabs, TwelveLabs, ThirteenLabs

https://quantumi.sh/public/labs.html
173•jemoka•4h ago•63 comments

A Friendly Introduction to Racket

https://geometridae.bearblog.dev/a-friendly-introduction-to-racket/
84•signa11•4h ago•26 comments

Hister – A private, full content search index that you control

https://hister.org/
48•auraham•3d ago•4 comments

Scrap

https://twitter.com/moxie/status/2091218652133732491
12•tosh•54m ago•0 comments

RF Cafe

https://www.rfcafe.com/
47•gregsadetsky•3d ago•8 comments

Munder Difflin – Agent harness to run an office of your clones

https://munderdiffl.in/
215•simonpure•9h ago•86 comments

typ.ing

https://typ.ing/
42•bookofjoe•4d ago•12 comments

How a Texas student blew the whistle on a rogue AI hacking attempt

https://www.reuters.com/world/how-texas-student-blew-whistle-rogue-ai-hacking-attempt-2026-08-20/
16•olalonde•1d ago•2 comments

Chinese robot runs 100M sprint quicker than Usain Bolt's world record

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2026/aug/22/chinese-robot-runs-100m-sprint-quicker-usain-bolt-w...
24•bookofjoe•5h ago•17 comments

Belgian car salesman becomes prince after DNA test proves royal parentage

https://www.cnn.com/2026/08/22/europe/prince-belgium-secret-son-scli-intl
53•MilnerRoute•1h ago•34 comments

Z80 – The 1970s Microprocessor Still Alive (2021)

https://www.computer.org/csdl/magazine/mi/2021/06/09623402/1yJTvlRLmhi
93•asdefghyk•9h ago•46 comments

New MCP Roadmap

https://blog.modelcontextprotocol.io/posts/mcp-roadmap/
137•pentagrama•5h ago•108 comments

The Creation of Abulafia

https://blog.veitheller.de/abulafia.html
13•saulpw•22h ago•0 comments

ATProto spaces: A new extension to ATProto that enables non-public data

https://atproto.com/blog/atproto-spaces-alpha
19•grappler•1d ago•3 comments

Ameliorate

https://ameliorate.app/
57•hakkikonu•1d ago•17 comments

Why it might be time to rethink the human family tree

https://nautil.us/why-it-might-be-time-to-rethink-the-human-family-tree-1283985
18•Anon84•2d ago•14 comments

Guess which of these LLM outputs is watermarked

https://sgoedecke.github.io/watermark-quiz/
15•gfysfm•2d ago•9 comments

ProgramBench Vetted: Reverse Engineering from a Runnable Binary

https://vetto.ai/companies/programbench-vetted.html
13•rigelbm•2d ago•1 comments

Show HN: Rotation via Double Reflection

https://static.laszlokorte.de/rotor-reflect/
44•laszlokorte•1d ago•9 comments

Show HN: Anonymous age verification with passkey-powered encryption

https://loginwithone.com/
22•mikeysight•3d ago•11 comments

Canada will match US tariffs 'dollar for dollar' as trade talks break down

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvgvyy4x2mvo
183•tartoran•12h ago•795 comments

Anthropic appears to be A/B testing reduced effort levels in Claude Code

https://twitter.com/argofowl/status/2091150597374537729
59•matthieu_bl•2h ago•58 comments

MiniageOS: "Dumbphone" Version of LineageOS

https://github.com/ofdryads/miniageOS
18•ashenke•2d ago•9 comments

One night in Uzbekistan: Why was this one data point so influential?

https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2026/08/20/we-couldnt-reproduce-their-findings-and-realize...
14•paulpauper•23h ago•1 comments

Show HN: Public Muscriptor Instance (latest, most powerful Audio-to-MIDI model)

https://www.pianoify.net/
14•jardy•1d ago•1 comments

What's in a PowerPoint File?

https://editide.com/blog/what-is-a-pptx-file/
21•danielochoa0620•3d ago•18 comments

Mythic's analog compute-in-memory architecture

https://www.mythic.ai
14•janandonly•3d ago•0 comments

Conway's Game of Life in real life

https://blog.coredump.cx/p/conways-game-of-life-in-real-life
12•surprisetalk•2d ago•2 comments

Show HN: terminal-code – VS Code inside the terminal

https://terminal-code.com
17•robpruzan•3d ago•2 comments

Rust Glancer: Rust LSP using 100x less RAM

https://rust-glancer.github.io/blog/hello-world/
373•matklad•23h ago•84 comments