frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Do you really need an agent?

3•g_br_l•1d ago
I'm an engineer. I use AI both for my work and my personal life, basically every single day. I don't think "AI is a fad".

Here's the thing, though: For the past few months "agent" has been the buzzword. 99% of people talking about it have no clue how it works or what it is exactly, but it's the thing.

"Yo, I'm running 39 parallel openclaws in my 45k Mac Mini tower I built at home" "man these are making me so productive, I'm producing so much stuff you can't even begin to comprehend it" "this changes everything."

You've read at least ~50 variants of each of these. You see it all the time, to the point where you're wondering whether maybe you're missing out on it - maybe you really are "not gonna make it". And while thinking this you scroll down and another related post shows up.

This has pissed me off so much my hand has been forced to post here this half rant, half discussion starter: Do you really need a personal agent? Are you really spending so much time every day on the minor tasks it can do, that you actually trust it -unsupervised- to do them for you? Is it really worth the risk letting <current SOTA model> respond to your emails for you? Have you actually thought of how screwed you could be if it just... does the wrong thing?

I really can't stop coming up with questions like these every time I see one more of these posts, one more analysis on what the best set up for your personal agent is today (which is just so much better than it was 5 days ago I swear!).

I see the timeline and can't help but think: there's no way this many people have so much work that can be automated... right? And if they do have so much work that is easily automated - was that work worth doing anyway?

THE ACTUAL QUESTION: Have any of you actually set up a personal agent and kept using it 2 weeks after? Has it actually helped you with your daily tasks in any noticeable way? Am I really not gonna make it by not buying a Mac Mini?

That's it, I'm not promoting anything or building the next agentic startup btw.

Comments

maxim_manylov•1d ago
I still couldn't figure out what are the purpose of macminis, especially a lot of them? What for?
g_br_l•1d ago
more agents, I guess
stonefull•1d ago
That's a relevant question. But, like any tool ever developed by humans, many will misuse it, and few will take advantage of its resources.

Ask HN: We need to learn algorithm when there are Claude Code etc.

5•JasonHEIN•1h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: What is it like being in a CS major program these days?

178•tathagatadg•22h ago•175 comments

Ask HN: How is AI-assisted coding going for you professionally?

397•svara•1d ago•580 comments

Ask HN: What signals do you look for when hiring?

4•kathir05•1h ago•3 comments

Tell HN: AI tools are making me lose interest in CS fundamentals

88•Tim25659•1d ago•86 comments

Manifesto on Symbiosis: A New Paradigm for Civilization Part III

2•acehs•3h ago•0 comments

Tell HN: Godaddy DNS resolution down for 2+ hours

7•codegeek•10h ago•0 comments

Winstwaker – automated bookkeeping with a real accountant attached

2•kyliandegroot•15h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Did GitHub remove Opus and Sonnet from their Copilot Pro subscription?

12•lgl•23h ago•7 comments

Ask HN: Have you successfully treated forward head posture ("nerd neck")?

54•trashymctrash•2d ago•39 comments

I'm 60 years old. Claude Code killed a passion

231•fred1268•1d ago•180 comments

Ask HN: How to Learn C++ in 2026?

11•creatorcoder•1d ago•13 comments

I traced $2B in nonprofit grants for Meta and Age Verification lobbying

94•theseusares•4d ago•19 comments

Who is using Ollama day-to-day?

3•brauhaus•1d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: What breaks first when your team grows from 10 to 50 people?

14•hariprasadr•1d ago•9 comments

Ask HN: How is your team collaborating while working with coding agents?

2•wek•1d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Got cancer, a new job,new boss in less than a year What do I do now?

20•Goleniewski•3d ago•18 comments

Ask HN: What was it like for programmers when spreadsheets became ubiquitous?

12•yodaiken•2d ago•12 comments

Do you really need an agent?

3•g_br_l•1d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Why can't we just make more RAM?

26•chatmasta•3d ago•20 comments

Tons of new LLM bot accounts here

15•koolala•1d ago•16 comments

Tell HN: iPhone 6s still getting security updates

7•uticus•2d ago•3 comments

Built a 1.3M-line agent-native OS in Rust while homeless. What now?

10•jamieoglindsey•1d ago•24 comments

MiniMax M2.5 is trained by Claude Opus 4.6?

12•Orellius•3d ago•9 comments

AI coding agents accidentally introduced vulnerable dependencies

6•hsin003•1d ago•14 comments

Ask HN: 100k/year individual token usage?

8•alecsmart1•3d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: What's your biggest pain point when joining a new developer team?

8•KevStatic•3d ago•14 comments

How not to fork an open source project

7•jsattler•2d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Why have co-ops never played a major role in tech?

14•AbstractH24•3d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: How do you use Coding Agents/CLIs out of coding?

4•arbayi•2d ago•6 comments