frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: I made an image watermarking tool. What are the issues open-sourcing it?

3•minimaxir•5h ago
A couple months ago, I found that a) visual image watermarking is trivially defeated by AI image editing so invisible image watermarks are likely the future and b) the only steganographic image watermarking tools are hard-to-use open-source tools or proprietary tools like SynthID. So as an experiment I tried using agents to create a novel image watermarking approach…and it unexpectedly worked: mostly imperceptible, tamper resistant, higher capacity, doesn't use a neural network, and real time encode/decode.

I want to open-source it as there are very many legitimate uses for image watermarking. However, as of late there has been a lot of discourse about image watermarking on both sides, namely a) invisible image watermarks can be used to faciliate dystopian user tracking (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48198291 ) and b) tools to strip AI image watermarks are unethical/antisocial (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48200569), so overall I'm confused on the ethics of working with watermarking tools and I am concerned there could be a negative externality I am missing by making it more causally accessible. At the least, having only closed-sourced options for image watermarking isn't a good outcome.

Comments

messagegoel•3h ago
what are the use cases for it, and if its invisible, do the normal users care for it
phillipseamore•2h ago
Watermarking is for fools. Those doing the generation and watermarking will control what is perceived as false or true. Watermarks have historically been about proof of ownership or origin. Watermarking fake creations works in reverse, all of a sudden what's void of watermarking is true, but those that control the watermarking can either add them to truths to turn them into fakes or skip watermarking for certain people or organizations, making their fake creations become truths.

Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?

684•andrehacker•3d ago•1067 comments

Ask HN: Why is the HN crowd so anti-AI?

440•Ekami•1d ago•734 comments

Ask HN: How are thinking efforts implemented?

18•simianwords•12h ago•12 comments

Ask HN: Job market for SDMs/Engineering Managers. Any reliable data?

4•ed_balls•4h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: I made an image watermarking tool. What are the issues open-sourcing it?

3•minimaxir•5h ago•2 comments

Tell HN: Stripe ToS update demands biometrics, freezes payments until given

11•cuz-reasons•6h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: So what happened to Facebook "localhost" tracking?

105•juliusceasar•3d ago•102 comments

Tell HN: Helium is the best browser I ever used

4•prmph•7h ago•5 comments

Ask HN: What is your (AI) dev tech stack / workflow?

158•dv35z•2d ago•130 comments

Ask HN: How do you find deep technical content?

37•f311a•3d ago•28 comments

Ask HN: How to get my contact info off US political party's list

9•kaycebasques•1d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Where do you get the latest updates about AI?

5•d0able•23h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Gin rummy strategies

24•bix6•3d ago•4 comments

Bad MCP design costs your agent 5x more tokens

15•JohnnyZhang483•2d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Is the web for machines (/llm.txt) the one we wished we had as humans?

36•sunshine-o•2d ago•57 comments

New Biochemistry-Based Metabolic Protocol Seeking Alpha Concierge Members

3•joshwprinceton•22h ago•1 comments

Does anyone know since when we are close to building in space?

6•kingleopold•1d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: My competitors have flawed products but I can't get traction

11•saveitincork•2d ago•17 comments

Ask HN: Does robotics capabilities research accelerate AGI timelines?

8•themasterchief•1d ago•1 comments

I'm tired of LLM skill slop, so I built mine with regression tests

7•iliaov•3d ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Were CS profs right to look down on programming in light of modern AI?

4•amichail•1d ago•3 comments

Ask HN: How did you discover Hacker News?

10•chistev•2d ago•30 comments

Supply chain attack alert: .github/setup.js

25•antihero•2d ago•13 comments

Life saving / first aid posters

37•cpu_•5d ago•4 comments

Google killed my $1M ARR startup overnight

23•vadumo•3d ago•13 comments

Ask HN: What would you name your own LLM?

4•akashwadhwani35•1d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Is Everyone an Engineer Now?

7•piratesAndSons•3d ago•12 comments

Ask HN: Is Azure capacity this constraind or am I doing it wrong?

11•lanycrost•2d ago•15 comments

Ask HN: What are the best unknown books you have read?

7•chistev•12h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Why isn't AI image generation closely linked with graphics code gen?

3•amichail•2d ago•2 comments