frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Why are there an increasing number of outright unhinged high karma users on HN?

8•MichaelZuo•2h ago
I’ve been noticing this disturbing trend for quite a while. By high karma I mean well over 1000 karma.

And some of these leave comments so bizarre, that I can’t find any charitable explanation.

Other than perhaps they may be skipping reading every other word or something… and then respond to an imaginary version of the parent.

Uncharitably, they could be semi-random keyboard bashing, deranged bashing, emotional tantrums, and so on. Or LLM written… except the style doesnt match.

Of course this has always been somewhat prevalent for low karma users, but it’s now creeping up higher and higher.

For example, I had a recent bizarre encounter.

I had double checked the first 10 pages of google results, in regards to a claim that I implied prior in the comment chain, mentioning that it seemed supportive of the claim.

Maybe the novelty of someone doing that, and not just randomly opining, triggered something.

Realistically, it didn’t take more than 5 minutes of effort, but still… it would have been 1 to 5 minutes of genuine effort.

A bit later, a bizarre reply came making the accusation that I had put in “no effort”, and so on.

Which might have made sense in a high effort reply… except it was a hastily written short reply… that obviously took under a minute of genuine effort.

Accusing me of “no effort”, asking me to put in more effort than them, and then themselves putting in “no effort”… created a frankly nonsensical reply.

After pointing it out, that if they spent “no effort” too, I would have already put in more, or equal, effort by definition… there was no response from anyone.

Of course my comments were flagged and theirs was upvoted…

Has anyone else encountered similar or thought about this issue spreading upwards?

Comments

filup•1h ago
Advanced karma farming maybe. It's with in the realm of possibilities today with a much lower bar.

Heck, it's possible your not even speaking to anyone at all.

MichaelZuo•1h ago
I hadn’t thought advanced karma farming was possible… since those would be significant enough to attract moderator attention.

The simple karma farming I can understand since there are too many attempts. So they just let automated filters deal with it and a few might slip through.

Edit: Unless the mods dont bother removing all the falsely accumulated karma after catching the advanced farming rings. Then I could see that being constantly done.

filup•1h ago
The karma street credit system was not designed with LLM's in mind.

It's going to be harder and harder to determine the legitimacy of a post or reply.

There will be no good way to determine if your speaking to a human because it will become completly indistinguishable.

The good news for HN is it's slightly easier to navigate and use judgement with post history.

What can you do with a lot of high karma accounts? Alot. Planting seeds in this community can go a very long way.

WatchDog•1h ago
Those that spend all day posting on HN aren't always the most hinged.
MichaelZuo•1h ago
True… there’s always been some of that.

But the most egregious cases, such as posting short replies that literally self contradict and self negate their own credibility within the span of a few sentences… was very rare before.

At least from high karma accounts.

WatchDog•1h ago
Building up karma only requires that on balance one's contributions are popular.

Many accounts will contribute constructively on topics that are technical or objective, but then become more antagonistic on controversial or political topics.

So long as they don't severely break site rules, it's unlikely that they will be subject to major moderator action.

MichaelZuo•1h ago
Hmmm… This would imply the value of karma is much less and my threshold should be much higher?

To keep the bar at roughly the same relative difficulty.

Say 10,000+ karma?

If so, my example would no longer apply.

Karrot_Kream•57m ago
This site has gotten a lot more popular and so it's a lot easier to rise up in karma these days. It's really easy to get lots of upvotes and downvotes in pretty much any of the controversial/political threads on the site because they get a lot of attention, a lot more than the more technical or sedate posts. My guess is the mods don't have the time to look at as many of the comments anymore just because there are so many.
krapp•1h ago
If you're talking about this (now flagged) thread[0] I don't see anything in the replies to your comments that I would consider "deranged." I just see the typical HN back and forth, and honestly neither side is backing up their arguments. HN certainly does have deranged comments but this isn't it. This is tepid as arguments go, and typical.

I agree your comments shouldn't have been flagged but unfortunately that sort of thing happens all the time around here. When people disagree with you and downvotes aren't enough they'll just start flagging. I don't think that's a "high karma" thing, people will start to do that as soon as they're able, which doesn't take much karma.

And, I mean, only one of the people who replied to you even has more karma than you do. So really you're just complaining about one person and conflating that into some vast systemic issue with "high karma users."

Get over it and move on. I'll get absolutely shat on by people here sometimes and have forgotten about it entirely after an hour. Nothing that happens here is worth getting triggered for over a week.

[0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48329843

MichaelZuo•1h ago
Are you perhaps confused?

The timestamp clearly says “12 days ago”?

Which matches my recollection of how many days ago it was.

I obviously could not be triggered 12 days after the fact…

And it’s just one example I chose because it was recently in my memory?

I don’t think I implied this was the most representative possible example.

krapp•22m ago
>I obviously could not be triggered 12 days after the fact…

That isn't obvious, given that you came back 12 days later with what seems to be a full blown conspiracy theory about a single interaction with a single poster.

>And it’s just one example I chose because it was recently in my memory?

So you are still triggered by it.

>I don’t think I implied this was the most representative possible example.

I can only reply to the comment you actually wrote, and the comment you actually wrote, which you did intend to be a representative example, doesn't do a good job of supporting your case. Feel free to post your evidence, then, I suspect it will just be more of the same.

I stand by my comment and I'm leaving the thread. Good night.

AnimalMuppet•1h ago
I've seen it too, though I haven't often checked the karma of those posters. But yes, there are posts that just make no sense.

There are more posters, though, whose approach makes no sense. They post strong opinions, but they can't or won't defend them, instead attacking anyone who disagrees (or else just stridently repeating the claim). Those I at least can understand. They are zealots, or they are shills.

But the posts that just don't make sense... are they bots? Are they mentally not all there? They sure aren't thinking like I do, and not just because they have different opinions.

k310•1h ago
I got to 1737 the hard way. Lots of 1 point posts (which don't seem to count) but mainly, I collect karma points so I can afford to fend off downvoting trolls.

All done with good intention.

I'm Eric Ries, author of "The Lean Startup" and new book "Incorruptible" – AMA

566•eries•13h ago•437 comments

Notes on DeepSeek

135•vinhnx•14h ago•92 comments

AWS Bedrock to require sharing data with Anthropic for Mythos and future models

399•TomAnthony•19h ago•234 comments

Ask HN: Are most corporate SWE jobs performative?

210•hnthrow10282910•14h ago•246 comments

Why are there an increasing number of outright unhinged high karma users on HN?

8•MichaelZuo•2h ago•13 comments

Ask HN: Why hasn't there been a real competitor to Ticketmaster yet?

257•mdni007•2d ago•232 comments

Ask HN: Releasing code under AGPLv3, but want to block LLM reconstruction?

4•zionsati•2h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Are you still using a Vision Pro?

164•y1n0•1d ago•211 comments

Ask HN: What are tools you have made for yourself since the advent of AI?

427•aryamaan•2d ago•735 comments

Why would someone want to learn code when AI does it better and faster?

4•manimonji•8h ago•7 comments

Ask HN: Would it be useful to have a slop button in addition to flag?

8•BugsJustFindMe•8h ago•5 comments

Ask HN: Favorite text heavy blogs the are a joy to read

37•joshmarinacci•1d ago•16 comments

Tell HN: Stack Overflow seems down

3•tom1337•12h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: The next evolutionary step in LLM usage?

2•tomaytotomato•12h ago•1 comments

AMA: I'm a Random HN User, ask me anything (and I might respond)

14•SpyCoder77•12h ago•33 comments

Ask HN: Those who quit Software Eng. to do something else, what did you do?

5•trwhite•9h ago•0 comments

Will the next high value profession be people who can think independently?

5•ciwolex•7h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Are we all walking into a trap?

6•skor•18h ago•14 comments

Tell HN: Codex once again automatically activates /fast on app update

2•mfi•18h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How to escalate a rejected Google extension?

23•modzu•2d ago•14 comments

Ask HN: Prediction for SpaceX IPO?

7•bix6•1d ago•10 comments

Ask HN: Why is the HN crowd so anti-AI?

458•Ekami•5d ago•760 comments

Ask HN: How do you cope when your startup contracts?

14•jasonephraim•2d ago•13 comments

Ask HN: Which companies gained a competitive edge purely via engineering?

5•j1000•2d ago•12 comments

Ask HN: What's your favorite HN Recap like podcast?

5•randomor•3d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: How are thinking efforts implemented?

26•simianwords•3d ago•18 comments

LeetCode is the best way to learn a new language

2•JasonHEIN•1d ago•4 comments

Ask HN: Options for critical thinking and learning outside work?

6•hnthrow10282910•2d ago•5 comments

Ask HN: How to get your child interested in math?

3•gitowiec•1d ago•7 comments

Ask HN: Were CS profs right to look down on programming in light of modern AI?

6•amichail•4d ago•3 comments