frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Mass Loss in Black Hole Merger? How Does That Work?

5•AnimalMuppet•2h ago
Let's say we have two black holes, one 20 solar masses and the other 50 solar masses, and they get close enough and merge. In the process, they convert a solar mass or two into gravitational waves, which radiate off into the distance.

Let me restate that, to emphasize what I think is really weird: A solar mass or two that is inside the event horizon got converted to energy and radiated outside the event horizon.

E=mc^2. That part doesn't bother me. It's the "inside the event horizon" to "outside the event horizon" part that bothers me. Can someone ELI5 how that is possible? (Or even ELI20 with an undergrad in physics.)

Comments

sageserpent•1h ago
Sorry, I am not informed about general relativity, but I can say this: the mass (and the angular momentum, and the electric charge IIRC) are all ‘visible’ through the event horizon - indeed, if they weren’t, the a black hole would in some sense wink out of existence as it formed - no gravitational pull, no frame-dragging.

I am oversimplifying, and treating the black hole as already collapsed inside the event horizon from the point of view of somebody well away from it; that’s not accurate. Perhaps thinking of that mass as being ‘just about to collapse into the event horizon’ is the best way to think about it, because that’s what that somebody would perceived from the outside who is not in free-fall into it.

Need a proper physicist to follow up on this, my training stopped at special relativity and Newtonian gravity…

(PS: studying tensor calculus and general relativity is on my bucket list - thanks for reminding me to get a move on with it!)

krapp•28m ago
I'm a layman but as I understand it Hawking radiation (which is what we seem to be discussing) is a consequence of quantum mechanics and uncertainty - it isn't actually possible for a black hole to capture all of the energy that falls into it because the vacuum itself contains random quantum fluctuations of energy states which can result in energy escaping the black hole (although not information) through quantum tunneling, increasing entropy.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawking_radiation

Ask HN: Grant Writers, Worth It?

3•Fundnai•18m ago•1 comments

How did you fund your startup without VC?

5•Fundnai•30m ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Which one do you use for planning and coding between sonnet and Opus?

3•neverenderr•6h ago•5 comments

Tell HN: Airbnb updated "necessary" cookies aren't

5•janalsncm•10h ago•0 comments

Is Cloudflare classifying opencode.ai as malware?

3•_raz•7h ago•4 comments

SFR (French Internet provider) is blocking opencode.ai

5•krikou•8h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: Mass Loss in Black Hole Merger? How Does That Work?

5•AnimalMuppet•2h ago•2 comments

Robotics development made dead simple (open source)

22•Ekami•4d ago•7 comments

YC startup offers interviews to people who get their name permanently tattooed

13•codexon•19h ago•9 comments

Ask HN: Should authors disclose if they are paid to write a blog post?

2•wseqyrku•9h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Is everybody's Claude weekly quota reset time the same?

6•0gs•17h ago•6 comments

Belkin killed my smart switch. I got it working again without their app

13•gaborme•1d ago•1 comments

Do newer coding models end up training on the AI slop generated by older models?

7•tbharath•14h ago•9 comments

Ask HN: Which Jabber clients support SCRAM+ and XEP-0474?

4•Bender•18h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Is Reddit trying to kill old Reddit?

12•lostaccount•12h ago•10 comments

For the cheap price of a permanent tatto, get access to job interview

16•NoRagrets•15h ago•15 comments

Ask HN: Crooked Timber showed showed me a virus captcha, What now?

43•Jgoauh•2d ago•47 comments

Ask HN: Anyone else tired of brands discontinuing your favorite everyday items?

48•GreenPencil7•1d ago•47 comments

How to get more coding productivity with LLMs

6•DaveParkCity•16h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How are you handling production risks from AI generated code?

4•varda_62892•6h ago•5 comments

Ask HN: What do you use for privacy focused analytics?

3•garyhbutton•18h ago•8 comments

Tell HN: Our paid Claude AI subscription unavailable >1 week and no support

45•KellyCriterion•2d ago•22 comments

Ask HN: Stop Looking at Code?

3•grandimam•18h ago•9 comments

Ask HN: Looking for testers for my RAM-based Linux distribution

3•sumtas•18h ago•0 comments

You've reached the end!