frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Why are Claude models so verbose?

2•JacobWolf•5h ago
Hello! First time poster, longtime reader. I’m a professional software engineer at a startup with about 50 engineers. My primary languages are Ruby (Rails), TypeScript (React), and Go.

Of my colleagues, I’m one of the ones who tries to keep up with new AI models on every release. When there’s a new frontier or open-weight model, I’ll give it an honest try for a few days as my main driver and report back to my colleagues.

I’m a Cursor user at work and in my side projects. My go-to models are GPT-5.6 Sol on high/xhigh for planning, GPT-5.6 Sol on low/Grok 4.6 on medium for implementation, and the occasional Claude Fable 5 for complex, harder-to-understand and implement tasks. Many of my colleagues are exclusively Claude users and use Claude Code.

I’m not the first one to observe this but I feel like any time I use Fable, Opus, or Sonnet, they are extremely verbose. They make a ton of extra code comments, they ignore instructions, and they invent solutions for things solved by language built-ins or preinstalled libraries like Active Support and es-toolkit. I don’t see this happening with any other model at the same rate.

My question are: Why do we think the Claude models do this at a seemingly higher rate? And have people found any effective means to curb this behavior?

Comments

danielovichdk•5h ago
Because models that chat to themselves generate more tokens, hence more money is spent.

Easy

onion2k•5h ago
That's an over-simplification though, because models that waste tokens will lose users. Efficiency is a great marketing feature.
thingstohappy•5h ago
I think there are a few nuances here:

1. On the ignore instructions point: using Cursor with Claude as the underlying model is quite different from using Claude directly through Claude Code. The agent/tooling layer can have a pretty big impact on the behavior.

2. On verbosity: IMO, Claude's default writing style tends to be more verbose than GPT's. GPT models are generally more concise when coding, while Claude often explains more. That said, I think this can be mitigated quite a bit by how you harness the model.

3. I agree that it’s worth trying new models. The pace of AI development is so fast that models can change significantly in a short time. But I’d also suggest trying different agent tools rather than sticking with Cursor alone. The tooling and agent loop can make a big difference too.

JacobWolf•5h ago
I churned off of Cursor for about a year to use Claude Code from spring 2025 to spring 2026 and I noticed it’d regularly ignore CLAUDE.md & Claude rules. It’s part of why I came back to Cursor. The Cursor harness has produced more reliable results, but the excessive verbosity is still pretty common across harnesses, in my experience.
haute_cuisine•1h ago
Why would LLMs be concise and to the point? There is no truth in these machines.

p.s. You've just discovered a load bearing seam with your dossier and have a right to push back on this.

_barban_•1h ago
Consider that verbosity on Token Generation is negligible with respect to the tokens consumed for the prompt and the context, so I think it is just a writing style than can be appreciated or not (to me it is not so bad).

XCancel and Nitter are receiving C&D letters from XCorp

13•mobilio•1h ago•2 comments

Open source in-browser log sanitizer, feedback required

2•andriimb•2h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Is what Open Commonplace legal?

2•VishnuShayeq01•2h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What are you using to access x.com at the moment?

2•throwaw12•3h ago•3 comments

Looking for people to follow designing systems to ship code with AI agents

4•mutahn•4h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Opus 5 is unusable for writing, even internal use. Alternatives/fix?

2•m3h•1h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Why are Claude models so verbose?

2•JacobWolf•5h ago•6 comments

Ask HN: Good large format (>20 inches) touchscreen E-Paper display options?

28•foota•1d ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Those making $500/month on side projects in 2026 – Show and tell

71•kaladan•2d ago•86 comments

Anyone in Legal Tech Here?

4•bgajjela•14h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: What Did Anthropic Bill Me For?

4•OhMeadhbh•20h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Android OS with Linux level customisation

3•KinetiNode•16h ago•8 comments

Is AI slowing you down?

16•charbz•16h ago•9 comments

Ask HN: What business would you build if you couldn't use the internet?

5•spking•16h ago•8 comments

I'm a CTO. We took PE money 6 months ago. AMA

8•scottndecker•20h ago•12 comments

How I Read Books

12•nomilk•1d ago•14 comments

Talk Like Claude Day

20•KenPainter•2d ago•6 comments

A technology that counts reps and scores muscle failure from the Apple Watch

3•baraa_bilal•1d ago•1 comments

Ask HN: What AI companies provide human support?

3•kbrannigan•1d ago•2 comments

Tell HN: HN Algolia Search not showing new results from the past 24 hours

4•infinitifall•1d ago•1 comments

I write my own Markdown

2•KenPainter•1d ago•3 comments

Do teams still use scrum and sprints?

6•peter_retief•1d ago•12 comments

Ask HN: Should GitHub downtimes impact considering Golang for a new project?

2•gchamonlive•20h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Trust Between Agent's Companies

2•mathieu_aithos•1d ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Is there any way to use workflow to control Harness?

2•juntz•1d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: Why is my innovative IDEA is always behind the others?

3•juntz•1d ago•6 comments

You've reached the end!