frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Can we classify AI as: subhuman, quasihuman, human, superhumam?

3•aunekiaru•13h ago
Gen 1: subhuman, eq: machine translation, game AI/chess, timeline prediction/protein folding...(1980 - 2020 era).

Gen 2: quasihuman: human assistant that requires human-in-the-loop: human evaluates, gives directions, asks, tries, implements. "you're here": LLMs/chatbots (2020s).

Gen 3: human worker substitute. While not strictly 'human' per se, without will and emotions it can be considered "human job replacement" as it eliminates the need for human-in-the-loop as it verifies successful compilation, rates visual result (videogames it produces/videos/images), validates fiction it writes, marketing strategies/trading strategies and learns from mistakes and improves after many attempts until it finishes task with acceptable result.

Gen 4: Superhuman: like gen 4 but + having full recursive self-improvement (it updates/rewrites its own code and recopmiles while performing a task - full awareness)? Theoretically gen 4 can be ASI if the seed is "make better AI which makes better AI and so on until optimal AI is achieved given the laws of physics" (good learning and ability to update everything should achieve it - though compute limitations may prevent it and well...regulations).

I know the definition is suboptimal and people are extremely opinionated on AI to a point people have different definitions about AGI and ASI but this is at least some definition! I believe after "dry" chatbots in the 30s we may switch to less user-friendly yet smarter and more useful AIs, you will not longer see "you're absolutely right!" and have to spent hours to evaluate and correct errors with the AI, you will just start it and wait for it to finish, kind of like downloading a movie in the old days. Too sci-fi/wrong? Too pessimistic...because Yudkowski/Terminator is coming to get us in 2029? 10x for your comments!

Comments

afzalive•13h ago
None of the above. It's classified as a large language model.
PaulHoule•12h ago
I'd say you put the cart before the horse.

Commercially viable technology is "superhuman" in some sense. That is, tractors and combine harvesters changed everything in agriculture because... they are superhuman. Bulldozers are superhuman, pocket calculators are superhuman, etc. If something isn't superhuman in some narrow sense, humans will just do the job!

Note the gap you talk about between 2 and 3 is a real gap. In the 2010s I was working on (basically) reverse centaur systems that were intended to get radical productivity improvements on specific tasks. I didn't see "Gen 2" systems talking to ordinary people were even possible, at least not until we built a workable world knowledge and language facility via that reverse centaur path: expert input developing the outline of the world model and setting the standards for performance and quite a bit of mass input tagging and evaluating and making judgements that the system couldn't yet been trusted.

As for 4 I don't believe in recursive self-improvement, not like you can't use today's AI to accelerate the progress of tomorrow's AI but it is an evolutionary but not revolutionary change and the limits are fundamental to physics, economics and the nature of intelligence itself. Basically you have heard of this differential equation

  dx
  -- = x
  dt
as representing exponential growth as seen in ecology and economics, but you never hear of the equation that describes recursive self-improvement

  dx
  -- = x^2
  dt
not even from true believers in recursive self-improvement because (1) there are no examples of it because it is unphysical, uneconomic and non-sensical, and (2) any serious discussion of why (1) is will lead to numerous refutations of recursive self-improvement, "the singularity" and such.

To be specific right now, take a look at the semiconductor industry which has been stuck for almost 10 years. For a long time people talked about Moore's Law and the consequences of being able to make smaller transistors exponentially over time. Looking back though, the real issue is that we've gotten cheaper transistors over time. If they don't get cheaper it doesn't matter if they are smaller or faster because you can't afford them. It used to be a video game console was always the most expensive on Day One but it's not true anymore. It is fashionable to blame this on the pandemic or the AI boom, but the real problem is that those EUV machines from ASML cost too fucking much and are just barely economically viable. The industry is stuck, does not have a clear path forward. Maybe AI can increase our capacity 10x but if the problem is 10x harder you don't get "singularity" growth you get a continuation of the old exponential growth.

anotherCodder•12h ago
https://inference.tiyuvta.ai/
fuzzfactor•12h ago
I wouldn't trust the "human" part to be very realistic no matter how uncanny.

I was thinking a more accurate scale would be subintelligent, quasiintelligent, intelligent and superintelligent.

These seem like very logical divisions if you are going to call the whole collection "AI" to begin with.

Even more realistic would probably be based on what capabilities are there, rather than things like "humanity" content or pseudo-IQ.

How about subadequate, quasiadequate, adequate, and superadequate?

Any way you look at it those "super" levels are going to be very challenging to validate or confirm.

mdlxxv•10h ago
Nonhuman

Ask HN: Who is using MCP in production?

34•sukit•17h ago•41 comments

Ask HN: Why were OpenAI, Claude, and Grok simultaneously down?

355•halcdev•14h ago•532 comments

Ask HN: Are others seeing Google's reCAPTCHA rejecting Firefox users?

48•Animats•9h ago•13 comments

Tell HN: NVIDIA's Acquisition of HuggingFace was for $HuggingFace

24•MontagFTB•7h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: 30, burnt out, with 6-10 months of runway. What would you do?

17•throwaway_30yo•1d ago•11 comments

Ask HN: Who is using FPGA for ML inference?

7•softwarewright•6h ago•10 comments

Tell HN: Both recent GCP outages caused by fiber optic maintenance

8•fastest963•7h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Why do many websites use a sign-in code instead of a password?

5•bariumbitmap•1h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: What is the ideal email domain setup?

2•bix6•5h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: How do you market Open Source Software?

5•Daniel-Pan•2h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: Who is hiring? (September 2026)

242•whoishiring•2d ago•318 comments

Ask HN: Founders that raised funding and shutdown, did you raise again?

17•asim•15h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (September 2026)

107•whoishiring•2d ago•423 comments

Ask HN: Laptop or Desktop?

6•Gecko4072•12h ago•4 comments

Ask HN: How do you guys keep up with the most cost-effective AI models?

4•solomonmwalker•14h ago•4 comments

Tell HN: The Thoughts and Woes of a Full-Time Founder Part 1

3•lcampbellsoup•5h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How do we build a team? (bootstrapped B2B startup)

3•theonlinx•8h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: iPhone Camera on indicator

2•zahirbmirza•7h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Is there a test for measuring cognitive affects from LLM usage?

5•niwrad•7h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Could AI eventually build god?

5•olirex99•7h ago•8 comments

Ask HN: Are technical blogs dead?

11•quaintdev•20h ago•19 comments

One-person startup: a Cornell postdoc wants to put AI in everyone's hands

2•modelslive•8h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Accountants working with ecommerce

3•vasyl_kyryliuk•11h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: How do you gate an autonomous coding agent's shell access?

2•alanfuNZ•8h ago•1 comments

Ask HN: Why does free time become another thing you have to use correctly?

2•nullifypreset•10h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Are guardrails being baked into models, or enforced outside them?

2•arkj•10h ago•0 comments

Tell HN: Xbox Game Pass now limits the amount of hours each month

7•nodesocket•4h ago•3 comments

Beware: Malicious Profiles on YC Co-Founder Matching

5•pain_perdu•13h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Can we classify AI as: subhuman, quasihuman, human, superhumam?

3•aunekiaru•13h ago•5 comments

Resources to Get Good at Soldering?

9•tosmatos•1d ago•9 comments