frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Ask HN: Would a startup for young creatives who reject AI be feasible?

9•mondobe•7h ago
I am a member of my university's game development club, which puts me around lots of talented programmers as well as artists of all kinds, and I've observed that just about everyone disapproves of AI. The sentiment is especially strong among younger people coming into the club. By "disapproves", I mean they refuse to allow AI-generated content in games and see AI use in general as something like a moral failure.

At the same time, I scroll down the YC startup directory, sorting by launch date, and observe that every non-hardware company (and most of the hardware ones) are entirely based on AI. The demographic I described above, young creatives like the ones in this club, has zero chance of voluntarily using one of these products.

It seems to me, then, that as the moat for most AI startups drops asymptotically to 0 with GPT-6 et al. becoming more capable, this market is mostly a blue ocean (to use the business-book term) for anyone willing to put in the work and actually code something people want. From there, network effects would work as well as they have since the dawn of the Internet.

I am exploring the idea of making such a startup (it started out as a side project which I have been working on by myself for almost 2 years), but I am worried about the attitude of incubators, VCs, and investors in general. Would the lack of AI be a nonstarter for most outside investors? I know people started non-blockchain companies in 2021, but the hype around AI seems orders of magnitude more captivating to anybody who might provide capital. I know bootstrapping is viable for some companies, but would that be the only way? I appreciate any advice people might have.

Comments

ben_w•7h ago
Non-AI-assets: yup, this is sensible. AI is a signal of being unconcerned about being seen as a cheat, absence is good.

Non-AI-code: forget it, you won't be able to avoid it in your libraries, and you won't write the whole engine from scratch.

It's possible to write a whole modern engine without it, but you won't, you'll spin wheels chasing features and never ship.

mondobe•7h ago
Fair point about game development. I'm definitely looking more towards creative tools (like music production apps) because making a game engine is just a Herculean task. I've found that velocity is good (i.e. one meaningful feature every day or two) in the early stages of building for the web without AI.
mircerlancerous•5h ago
You would be foolish to completely avoid AI, but you are also right to be careful. AI is best used for boring stuff that's non-critical, and for stopping you from having to reinvent the wheel.

For example for a game, you could use AI to finish a sprite sheet based on a couple frames you provide, or to give you a pathfinding algorithm.

AI is a resource, and a startup has a better chance of success the better it leverages the few resources it has.

mondobe•5h ago
Thanks for the perspective! I tend to consult ChatGPT with high-level queries as a replacement for Google, and I get a lot of mileage out of combining that with plenty of good old documentation-reading.
LamGC•3h ago
Since the release of GPT, I have found that the hassle of efficiently using keywords to search for hidden information on Google has been replaced by GPT search. AI should become a powerful assistant, but we cannot give up our own abilities.
xyzzy123•5h ago
I'm curious about provenance. What you're describing sounds kind of like Etsy and while there are still genuine things to be found there it's mostly flooded with mass-produced stuff. The more of a premium "hand-made" artifacts attract, the greater the incentive to counterfeit them.
mondobe•5h ago
Good point, and one I've thought about a lot. Right now, I think we're at a stage in the hype cycle where, for the overwhelming majority of founders, appealing to AI hype is much easier than lying to appeal to anti-AI sentiment. If and when this changes, it might manifest as an incentive for companies to be transparent with their source code (either fully open-source or at least "source available" or auditable).
unsupp0rted•4h ago
I’m an elevator operator. You tell me what floor you’d like and I press the button or control the switch.

I also make casual conversation about the weather and yesterday’s sports highlights, which automatic elevators can’t do.

Can I join?

mondobe•4h ago
I have no problem with creative destruction, elevator operators died out for a reason. If there was a group of people who rejected automatic elevators for some reason, it stands to reason there would be a company to snatch up that market. (case in point: no-touch Shabbat elevators for Orthodox Jews)
CoolestBeans•2h ago
I think for kids coming out of university, going against the grain might be one of the most valuable things you can do. The essential skills of critical thinking, problem solving, intuitive and linear thinking, and improvisation are not going anywhere. AI is a very impressive technology but it also is one that steals valuable mental exercise from its users. I can't say that eschewing AI will lead to a successful startup but I have a good feeling that connecting with other people who want to do things the hard way and then doing it will be an extremely valuable experience this early in your tenure. If this AI trend does continue, this will give you and your friends a leg up on those who didn't put in the hours.
mondobe•1h ago
Very insightful and encouraging words, thank you!
thaeli•2h ago
There absolutely is a market - anti-AI sentiment among creatives isn't going away. Like any other "purity" branding, it's a real commitment and severely limits your future ability to pivot.

I don't know of anyone in the VC or traditional incubator communities who has an appetite for this. And the groups who are an ideological fit don't have the funds to be worth pursuing.

It's a niche. Like most niches, there's the opportunity to prosper, but yeah - bootstrapping (or angel-bootstrapping if you're lucky and have a personal connection) is pretty much the only way to go here.

brudgers•2h ago
I am worried about the attitude of incubators, VCs, and investors in general. Would the lack of AI be a nonstarter for most outside investors?

In general, they don’t care about AI or not AI.

They care about the possibility of 100x returns.

This means they care about the possibility of exponential growth.

Most businesses grow linearly at best.

Good luck.

Ask HN: What are you working on? (September 2026)

131•david927•12h ago•365 comments

Ask HN: Would a startup for young creatives who reject AI be feasible?

9•mondobe•7h ago•13 comments

System 3 Thinking

2•rexossbear•5h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What are some privacy/security tools you wish exist, but don't yet?

5•ToriTech•5h ago•6 comments

AI Boom / Bust – Boom Boom Pow

4•wwolfson97•6h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: How is AI actively a threat to humanity if it's only online?

5•CM30•6h ago•11 comments

Ask HN: Multi-agent workflows in production; Where people using 1000s of agents?

2•ramstar3000•7h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Is there an emerging pattern for NEGATIVESKILLS.md files?

3•mehmetoguzderin•9h ago•2 comments

Ask HN: Should we start airgapping our personal devices?

7•emerongi•22h ago•6 comments

Ask HN: What default model do you use and why?

60•stikit•1d ago•101 comments

Ask HN: What would it look like if AI agents "took over the internet"?

4•scripper1•12h ago•11 comments

DietPi released a new version v10.7

3•stephanstsdietp•18h ago•0 comments

Ask HN: Career paths to consider if I am better at supporting than creating?

28•_override•18h ago•28 comments

Ask HN: Why haven't people vibe coded popular 80s word processors as TUI apps?

5•amichail•15h ago•3 comments

Ask HN: Did Google kill its enterprise workhorse model?

26•waldrews•2d ago•16 comments

Tell HN: OpenAI keeps re-enabling the 'allow training' setting

482•jacquesm•3d ago•188 comments

Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

849•cromka•2d ago•392 comments

Reddit Now Blocking Firefox for Android with uBlock Origin?

25•chucksmash•1d ago•6 comments

Ask HN: What's a good "semi-dumb" phone/watch for kids?

8•funkaster•2d ago•12 comments

Ask HN: What is Y Combinator's position on Flock's standing today?

16•chirau•15h ago•21 comments

Tell HN: Claude Code appends new commit signature even if older settings is off

7•ctxc•1d ago•1 comments

OpenAI changed Navier-Stokes press release and Lean4 code on GH

9•rawland•2d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: For Enterprise coding agents, what's your company doing to control cost?

6•m0rde•1d ago•9 comments

Novgraph: Persistent Knowledge Graph for Codebases

3•Shourya_55•1d ago•2 comments

Ask HN: How are much smarter AI models made?

11•superasn•2d ago•5 comments

GoatCode – open-source terminal AI agent with provider failover

3•Arhan-w•1d ago•2 comments

You've reached the end!