frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Show HN: I built a Ruby gem that handles memoization with a ttl

https://github.com/mishalzaman/memo_ttl
48•hp_hovercraft84•1y ago
I built a Ruby gem for memoization with TTL + LRU cache. It’s thread-safe, and has been helpful in my own apps. Would love to get some feedback: https://github.com/mishalzaman/memo_ttl

Comments

locofocos•1y ago
Can you pitch me on why I would want to use this, instead of Rails.cache.fetch (which supports TTL) powered by redis (with the "allkeys-lru" config option)?
film42•1y ago
Redis is great for caching a customer config that's hit 2000 times/second by your services, but even then, an in-mem cache with short TTL would make redis more tolerant to failure. This would be great for the in-mem part.
thomascountz•1y ago
I'm not OP nor have I read through all the code, but this gem has no external dependencies and runs in a single process (as does activesupport::Cache::MemoryStore). Could be a "why you should," or a "why you should not" use this gem, depending on your use case.
hp_hovercraft84•1y ago
Good question. I built this gem because I needed a few things that Rails.cache (and Redis) didn’t quite fit:

- Local and zero-dependency. It caches per object in memory, so no Redis setup, no serialization, no network latency. -Isolated and self-managed. Caches aren’t global. Each object/method manages its own LRU + TTL lifecycle and can be cleared with instance helpers. - Easy to use — You just declare the method, set the TTL and max size, and you're done. No key names, no block wrapping, no external config.

JamesSwift•1y ago
For what its worth, ActiveSupport::CacheStore is a really flexible api that gives minimal contractual obligations (read_entry, write_entry, delete_entry is the entire set of required methods), but still allows you to layer specific functionality (eg TTL) on top with an optional 'options' param. You could get the best of both worlds by adhering to that contract and then people can swap in eg redis cache store if they wanted a network-shared store.

EDIT: see https://github.com/rails/rails/blob/main/activesupport/lib/a...

hp_hovercraft84•1y ago
That's actually a really good idea! I'll definitely consider this in a future update. Thanks!
qrush•1y ago
Congrats on shipping your first gem!!

I found this pretty easy to read through. I'd suggest setting a description on the repo too so it's easy to find.

https://github.com/mishalzaman/memo_ttl/blob/main/lib/memo_t...

hp_hovercraft84•1y ago
As in identify where the source code is in the README?
zerocrates•1y ago
I think they mean just set a description for the repo in github (set using the gear icon next to "About"), saying what the project is. That description text can come up in github searches and google searches.
film42•1y ago
Nice! In rails I end up using Rails.cache most of the time because it's always "right there" but I like how you break out the cache to be a per-method to minimize contention. Depending on your workload it might make sense to use a ReadWrite lock instead of a Monitor.

Only suggestion is to not wrap the error of the caller in your memo wrapper.

> raise MemoTTL::Error, "Failed to execute memoized method '#{method_name}': #{e.message}"

It doesn't look like you need to catch this for any operational or state tracking reason so IMO you should not catch and wrap. When errors are wrapped with a string like this (and caught/ re-raised) you lose the original stacktrace which make debugging challenging. Especially when your error is like, "pg condition failed for select" and you can't see where it failed in the driver.

hp_hovercraft84•1y ago
Thanks for the feedback! That's a very good point, I'll update the gem and let it bubble up.
JamesSwift•1y ago
I thought ruby would auto-wrap the original exception as long as you are raising from a rescue block (i.e. as long as $! is non-nil). So in that case you can just

  raise "Failed to execute memoized method '#{method_name}'"
And ruby will set `cause` for you

https://pablofernandez.tech/2014/02/05/wrapped-exceptions-in...

film42•1y ago
TIL! That's pretty cool. I still think if you have no reason to catch an error (i.e. state tracking, etc.) then you should not.
gurgeous•1y ago
This is neat, thanks for posting. I am using memo_wise in my current project (TableTennis) in part because it allows memoization of module functions. This is a requirement for my library.

Anyway, I ended up with a hack like this, which works fine but didn't feel great.

   def some_method(arg)
     @_memo_wise[__method__].tap { _1.clear if _1.length > 100 }
     ...
   end
   memo_wise :some_method
JamesSwift•1y ago
Looks good. Id suggest making your `get` wait to acquire the lock until needed. eg instead of

  @lock.synchronize do
    entry = @store[key]
    return nil unless entry

    ...
you can do

  entry = @store[key]
  return nil unless entry

  @lock.synchronize do
    entry = @store[key]
And similarly for other codepaths
chowells•1y ago
Does the memory model guarantee that double-check locking will be correct? I don't actually know for ruby.
JamesSwift•1y ago
I think it wouldnt even be a consideration on this since we arent initializing the store here only accessing the key. And theres already the check-then-set race condition in that scenario so I think it is doubly fine.
hp_hovercraft84•1y ago
Good call, but I think I would like to ensure it remains thread-safe as @store is a hash. Although I will consider something like this in a future update. Thanks!
wood-porch•1y ago
Will this correctly retrieve 0 values? AFAIK 0 is falsey in Ruby

``` return nil unless entry ```

chowells•1y ago
No, Ruby is more strict than that. Only nil and false are falsely.
wood-porch•1y ago
Doesn't that shift the problem to caching false then :D
RangerScience•1y ago
you can probably always just do something like:

  def no_items?
    !items.present?
  end
  
  def items
    # something lone
  end

  memoize :items, ttl: 60, max_size: 10`
just makes sure the expensive operation results in a truthy value, then add some sugar for the falsey value, done.
madsohm•1y ago
Since using `def` to create a method returns a symbol with the method name, you can do something like this too:

  memoize def expensive_calculation(arg)
    @calculation_count += 1
    arg * 2
  end, ttl: 10, max_size: 2

  memoize def nil_returning_method
    @calculation_count += 1
    nil
  end
hp_hovercraft84•1y ago
This is why I love working with Ruby!
deedubaya•1y ago
See https://github.com/huntresslabs/ttl_memoizeable for an alternative implementation.

For those who don’t understand why you might want something like this: if you’re doing high enough throughput where eventual consistency is effectively the same as atomic consistency and IO hurts (i.e. redis calls) you may want to cache in memory with something like this.

My implementation above was born out of the need to adjust global state on-the-fly in a system processing hundreds of thousands of requests per second.

kartik_malik•1y ago
In React ?

Turned ArXiv into an AI-Agent-Friendly Interface (No Browser Vision Needed)

https://mediause.dev/skills/arxiv
1•yooibox•3m ago•0 comments

Temporal Primer – Building Long-Running Systems

https://arpitbhayani.me/blogs/temporal-primer/
1•BugsBunnyCodes•5m ago•0 comments

The Database Zoo: Exotic Data Storage Engines

https://blog.gaborkoos.com/posts/2025-09-19-The-Database-Zoo-Exotic-Data-Storage-Engines/
1•theanonymousone•8m ago•0 comments

Please stop talking about Gen Z in the office

https://www.ft.com/content/ff49b595-b5ed-4be9-8cb1-1522b7086b28
1•rustoo•12m ago•0 comments

Documenting my immigrant founder's journey in the Bay Area

https://iamandrespalacios.substack.com/p/series-eh-a-founders-journey
1•andres-palacios•14m ago•0 comments

Elon Musk is going all-in on an unproven technology

https://economist.com/briefing/2026/05/21/elon-musk-is-going-all-in-on-an-unproven-technology
2•andsoitis•17m ago•0 comments

Delivery Hero confirms takeover offer from Uber

https://www.reuters.com/business/delivery-hero-confirms-takeover-offer-uber-2026-05-23/
3•thm•39m ago•0 comments

Seeking a Language in Mathematics 1523-1571

https://tyndale.org/journals/reformj01/bmarsden.html
2•jruohonen•41m ago•1 comments

Show HN: Logo Fonts

https://logofonts.surge.sh/
2•stagas•48m ago•0 comments

Why Every IKEA Product Has a Weird Name [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c89T2snPvNo
3•vinhnx•54m ago•0 comments

Meta's Claudeonomics leaderboard

https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/news/story/meta-shuts-down-internal-claudeonomics-ai-tool-af...
3•phront•58m ago•0 comments

I tracked down the thief who stole $200k of Lego [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wscQpkcwgNU
2•pinkmuffinere•1h ago•1 comments

Limerick

https://www.worldwidewords.org/surprise.html
3•jruohonen•1h ago•0 comments

We Were Wrong About Fasting Study Finds

https://www.sciencealert.com/we-were-wrong-about-fasting-massive-study-finds
3•mikhael•1h ago•0 comments

C Constructs That Still Don't Work in C++ – and a Few That Changed

https://lospino.so/blog/c-constructs-that-still-dont-work-in-cpp/
2•jandeboevrie•1h ago•0 comments

A Data Mining Adventure into the World of Lichess Puzzle Database

https://lichess.org/@/heroku/blog/how-many-different-backrank-mates-are-there/gSUlcRkl
3•heroku•1h ago•0 comments

The Verification Problem (On OpenAI's Erdős Disproof)

https://korbonits.com/blog/2026-05-23-the-verification-problem/
2•korbonits•1h ago•0 comments

AI Can Do Anything

https://clawdcursor.com
3•AmDab•1h ago•0 comments

Does bulk memmove speed up std:remove_if? (No.)

https://quuxplusone.github.io/blog/2026/05/23/chunked-remove/
2•jandeboevrie•1h ago•0 comments

European Data Centers Reuse Waste Heat to Heat Homes

https://letsdatascience.com/news/european-data-centers-reuse-waste-heat-to-heat-homes-48086eeb
1•GeorgeWoff25•1h ago•0 comments

How to Call an API from an Email

https://redo.com/eng-blog/how-to-call-an-api-from-an-email/
3•crcastle•1h ago•0 comments

"Long-Term Support" doesn't mean what you think

https://pointieststick.com/2026/05/23/long-term-support-doesnt-mean-what-you-think/
3•jandeboevrie•1h ago•0 comments

2of3: Enter a secret. Get 3 cards

https://2of3.ente.com
3•anandbaburajan•1h ago•0 comments

SpaceX, OpenAI and Anthropic IPOs set to test limits of AI boom

https://www.ft.com/content/ae9bb47d-bd1d-473c-b4c5-abae0420cc12
1•1vuio0pswjnm7•1h ago•1 comments

Dark trades' risk destroying London's stock markets

https://www.thetimes.com/business/companies-markets/article/dark-trades-risk-destroying-stock-mar...
3•petethomas•1h ago•0 comments

BNoise – The Easiest Music Maker

https://bnoise.pages.dev/
3•telui•1h ago•1 comments

Hacker Typer – Hacker Screen

https://startuplaunchpage.com/hacker-typer
2•vnyarongi•1h ago•0 comments

Reddit stock drops almost 6%, Meta launches standalone app for online forums

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/05/22/reddit-stock-drops-after-meta-launches-forum-app.html
10•1vuio0pswjnm7•1h ago•1 comments

Cleaning Station

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleaning_station
3•pvillano•1h ago•1 comments

The phrase "taste is the differentiator" is not beneficial

https://hazn.com/please-stop-repeating-is-the-differentiator
2•hazn•1h ago•0 comments