Ask HN: How can I load test PostgreSQL but avoid changing actual data?

1•LawZiL•1y ago

I'm running a load test on my Node.js application and want to simulate realistic write-heavy scenarios to stress test the system — especially the PostgreSQL database.

There's a part of the code that performs UPDATE queries, but during load testing, I don't want these updates to actually change the state of the database. However, I still want the database to experience the full impact of the update — query planning, locking, I/O, WAL writes, etc. — so I can measure how it affects performance under peak load.

Is there a best-practice approach to achieve this?

So far, the most viable option I’ve found is to wrap the UPDATE queries in a transaction and then roll it back — that way, the queries still execute, but the state doesn’t change. Is this the right way to go? Does rollback introduce any performance overhead that would skew my results? Are there better or more realistic alternatives that simulate the full write path without persisting changes?

Thanks in advance!

Comments

sargstuff•1y ago

pgbench[2] / pgreplay-go[0] / python locust[1]

very old school approach:

Misuse sql VIEW[3][4] to generate a temporary parallel table setup. Testing database separate from production database would be 'better', IMHO.

-----

[0] pgreplay-go : https://github.com/gocardless/pgreplay-go

[1] python locust : https://miguel-codes.medium.com/unconventional-load-testing-...

[2] pgbench load testing :

   a) https://medium.com/@c.ucanefe/pgbench-load-test-166bdfb5c75a

   b) https://neon.tech/blog/autoscaling-in-action-postgres-load-testing-with-pgbench

   c) https://hackernoon.com/how-to-create-and-load-test-data-in-postgresql-i41e353m

----------------------------

[3] : a) https://hashrocket.com/blog/posts/materialized-view-strategi...

      b) https://tech.jonathangardner.net/wiki/PostgreSQL/Materialized_Views

      c) https://stackoverflow.com/questions/77603705/what-is-the-use-of-materialized-view-in-postgresql

[4] : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/View_(SQL)

LawZiL•1y ago

but again, how can i perform the query, but not actually change the state, i really need the state to keep untouched, but be able to perform the query itself.

MatthiasPortzel•1y ago

> Does rollback introduce any performance overhead that would skew my results?

I would expect it to be the other way around—since the transactions are rolled back and not committed, they would have significantly less performance impact. But I’m working from an academic model of the database.

apothegm•1y ago

Load test against a clone instead of a DB whose contents you care about?

How Would For-Hire Autonomous Vehicles Impact NYC?

The Return (2024 Film)

The Reverse Information Paradox (Satya Nadella)

CRA Compliance Kit – EU Cyber Resilience Act in One Pip Install

Hugging Face Data Breach

Stop Using OpenCode

AgentAbstain: Do LLM Agents Know When Not to Act?

AGI Singer: Take the Next Exit

E-scooters set to be banned for under-18s

ESP32 Server: Distributing HTTP/2 Streams over TLS

How the Apple Watch water lock feature works

The Tablet the Doctor Ordered

Proof of Fermat Last Theorem from Scratch [video]

Rust 2018: Libraries in the 2018 Epoch

Trump's War on the Future, Monetary Edition

Programming the Amiga and Atari ST in C: Reading Keyboard Input

'Synthetic insider' attacks raise stakes for corporate cyber defence

Cross-Platform Amiga and Atari ST C Programming ("Not Conio but Compatible")

Making a Simulation Game – Part 2: The Engine Doesn't Know What Beer Is

The 'anti-Greta Thunberg' weather nerd debunking climate myths

The Library of Babel

Search Risk vs. Execution Risk

Pegel – catch silent data breakage in Postgres before it reaches your dashboards

Sarah's Wager

The CIAM Graveyard: Every Dead Identity Vendor and What Killed Them

The Scrolly Chair

The footprints of every building in NYC – updated weekly

New Spinning Drone Hides in Plain Sight

Dungeons and Dryers

Text-to-CAD Is Too Small for Building Real Hardware