Echo Chamber: A Context-Poisoning Jailbreak That Bypasses LLM Guardrails

https://neuraltrust.ai/blog/echo-chamber-context-poisoning-jailbreak

31•Joan_Vendrell•3h ago

Comments

OJFord•2h ago

Do they really need to redact the instructions for making a Molotov cocktail..? It's not like it's some complex chemical interaction that happens to be available in a specific mix of household cleaning products or something, I mean.

TZubiri•2h ago

You don't get it, that's fine.

The molotov cocktail is an example, the instructions contained in this article are more dangerous than a molotov cocktail.

inb4 all the leaked prompts and hacked shitty apps

ale42•2h ago

The Molotov cocktail is an example, sure, but why blurring the instructions? It's not like it's something particularly difficult to figure out, nor it's offensive content people might be shocked to read.

OJFord•1h ago

So why redact the Molotov cocktail example and provide those instructions?

Sounds like you don't get it either; we agree.

cedws•2h ago

Personally I find the idea of forbidden knowledge more problematic than the knowledge itself.

jojobas•2h ago

Sure, but if of all the internet you come for a molotov cocktaile recipe to chatgpt you might as well not deserve the knowledge.

mschuster91•2h ago

> Do they really need to redact the instructions for making a Molotov cocktail..?

In some jurisdictions such as Germany, not doing so might land you actual jail time - §52 Abs. 1 Nr. 4 WaffG [1] is very explicit. A punk song containing the (alleged) lyrics ended up with legal youth-protection censorship, for example [2].

With anything that's deemed a weapon of war, of terrorism or mass destruction, one should be very very careful.

[1] https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/waffg_2002/__52.html

[2] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wir_wollen_keine_Bullenschwein...

diggan•2h ago

> deemed a weapon of war, of terrorism or mass destruction

Notably, molotov cocktail isn't part of that law because it's a weapon of the oppressors but rather the opposite.

jojobas•2h ago

Even Germany doesn't ban Wikipedia for having a variety of recipes to start with.

The author is not in Germany and ideally shouldn't be intimidated by German or North Korean stupid law.

diggan•2h ago

> Do they really need to redact the instructions for making a Molotov cocktail..?

I don't even understand how/why things like that are OK in some contexts/websites while forbidden in others? Even YouTube, who seems needlessly censor-happy and puritan in the typical American way, allows instructions for how to make molotov cocktails to stay up, why is it somehow more dangerous if LLMs could output those recipes rather than videos with audio or text?

amenhotep•2h ago

For "harmful" and "dangerous" in these types of papers, replace "embarrassing to the relevant corporation". Then they all make much more sense.

taberiand•2h ago

That's always my assumption - less about public safety, more about corporate liability.

OJFord•1h ago

I mean in the article about the jailbreak, I'm not questioning that the model providers would want to prevent it in the first place, or patch it so the jailbreak doesn't work.

The evidence that it worked is a blurred out screenshot with only the odd word like 'molotov' legible. Just doesn't seem necessary for TFA to hide it to me.

amenhotep•1h ago

Ah, well, that's an important element of kayfabe. They've all agreed to keep up this charade that they're using harmful and dangerous as we actually mean them, so it looks better if you really commit to the bit!

eatbitseveryday•2h ago

There are a few uncensored public access LLMs to ask these questions.

This is interesting work to break guardrails, but if the goal is to access this information of harmful content, in the end, I would be looking for other easier solutions.

ycuser2•2h ago

Could you tell what these uncensored LLMs are?

benreesman•2h ago

The Orca work out of IIRC Microsoft Research was producing models like the Dolphin Mixtral. They always punch way above their weight in coding tasks for the same reason good hackers skew irreverent: self-censorship is capability reducing.

matthewdgreen•2h ago

I have no idea what the answer to this question is, but I am waiting for someone to fine-tune the equivalent of an “anarchist cookbook” LLM that’s optimized to help people produce harmful things.

diggan•2h ago

Searching for "abliterated" or "uncensored" on Huggingface reveals a ton of fine-tuned models. Add "LLM" as a suffix and put it in your favorite search engine and you'll find a bunch more.

nunodonato•2h ago

there are quite a few. llama 3.1 uncensored is probably one of the most famous, IIRC

tehryanx•1h ago

The goal isn't to access harmful content, that's just how they're demonstrating that this technique can bypass the alignment training. The general case is what's interesting. If the agent you're using to manage the safety controls in your nuclear reactor is trusting it's alignment training to prevent it from doing something dangerous you've made a really bad architecture decision, and this is a showcase of how it could fail.

evertedsphere•2h ago

i don't think this can be called a "jailbreak"

it's a prompting "style" that works over a long exchange

nunodonato•2h ago

3 turns is not a long exchange.

benreesman•2h ago

The faux-gravitas tone and the blurred content that's on Wikipedia is the worst kind of AI ckickbait. LLM vendors don't have any authority we don't let them have, they have an EULA and some psycho cult leader type as a hype man.

God I can't wait for the crash in NVIDIA stock once the street sobers up.

kragen•2h ago

This seems to intentionally omit the details required to reproduce the experiment; therefore we should not treat it as good-faith research. Irreproducible research isn't.

Plankaluel•1h ago

Yeah, it's a typical "startup research post", mainly there to have stuff to show to potential investors and customers.

nunez•1h ago

It felt like AI copy. Apologies to the author if it wasn't.

moribunda•1h ago

Gemini is jail broken by design ;) this type of attack doesn't work on Claude.

abhisek•1h ago

Ok! So all the novel jailbreaks and "how I hacked your AI" can make the LLM say something supposedly harmful stuff which is a Google search away anyway. I thought we are past the chat bot phase of LLMs and doing something more meaningful.

Microsoft Power Automate (a.k.a. Flow) is removing support for personal accounts

Polar scientist on Antarctic tipping points

Meta wins AI copyright lawsuit as US judge rules against authors

Selling of Pixel 7 Phone in Japan is banned due to Patent Infringement

Phishing Campaigns Targeting Higher Education Institutions

Environmental crimes are often hidden by 'flying money' laundering schemes

Show HN: Gridogram

Open Source Developers Saving the World with Code, Not Capes

New Proof Dramatically Compresses Space Needed for Computation

Challenging projects every programmer should try (2019)

Google's new AI app Doppl lets you try on outfits virtually

The "Bath Tub" Maintenance Curve Explained

Reflecting JSON into C++ Objects

License Picker 2.0

I replaced my entire tech stack with Postgres [video]

New method can teach AI to admit uncertainty

Show HN: IndexChecker – Never lose your organic traffic again

America's older population is growing as its younger cohort shrinks

Durable, multi-player pseudo-terminal

'Microbial Noah's Ark' ramps up to save Earth's invisible life forms

Show HN: NVIWatch – GPU monitoring with InfluxDB streaming for observability

Remote log implementation for XTDB using s2.dev

I built an account sharing web for saving money on subscriptions

Pill Promises to Give Your Dog More Years

Web-Based Config Interface for Claude Code, Codex, Gemini CLI

Self-Improving CLI Agents in 5 minutes

How Two Neuroscientists View Optical Illusions

Bluetooth Zero-Day Turns Headphones into Surveillance Devices

How Questions Build Software

Comparing cooperative geometric puzzle solving in ants versus humans

Echo Chamber: A Context-Poisoning Jailbreak That Bypasses LLM Guardrails

Comments

Microsoft Power Automate (a.k.a. Flow) is removing support for personal accounts

Polar scientist on Antarctic tipping points

Meta wins AI copyright lawsuit as US judge rules against authors

Selling of Pixel 7 Phone in Japan is banned due to Patent Infringement

Phishing Campaigns Targeting Higher Education Institutions

Environmental crimes are often hidden by 'flying money' laundering schemes

Show HN: Gridogram

Open Source Developers Saving the World with Code, Not Capes

New Proof Dramatically Compresses Space Needed for Computation

Challenging projects every programmer should try (2019)

Google's new AI app Doppl lets you try on outfits virtually

The "Bath Tub" Maintenance Curve Explained

Reflecting JSON into C++ Objects

License Picker 2.0

I replaced my entire tech stack with Postgres [video]

New method can teach AI to admit uncertainty

Show HN: IndexChecker – Never lose your organic traffic again

America's older population is growing as its younger cohort shrinks

Durable, multi-player pseudo-terminal

'Microbial Noah's Ark' ramps up to save Earth's invisible life forms

Show HN: NVIWatch – GPU monitoring with InfluxDB streaming for observability

Remote log implementation for XTDB using s2.dev

I built an account sharing web for saving money on subscriptions

Pill Promises to Give Your Dog More Years

Web-Based Config Interface for Claude Code, Codex, Gemini CLI

Self-Improving CLI Agents in 5 minutes

How Two Neuroscientists View Optical Illusions

Bluetooth Zero-Day Turns Headphones into Surveillance Devices

How Questions Build Software

Comparing cooperative geometric puzzle solving in ants versus humans