Photographer spends years on street corner capturing same commuters daily (2017)

https://mymodernmet.com/peter-funch-candid-photographs-commuters/

48•thunderbong•6mo ago

Comments

cs702•6mo ago

Link to many pairs of photos showing the same individual(s):

https://www.peterfunch.com/portfolio/42nd-and-vanderbilt/

In each pair, the photos may be years apart!

What I find most fascinating is how consistent the photographed individuals are, in their demeanor and style, over time.

netsharc•6mo ago

Why are there no dates on the photos (or just month and year for privacy reasons), even in the book there aren't any: https://tbwbooks.com/products/42nd-and-vanderbilt-second-edi... . Seeing the differences (and similarities) while knowing the time gap would be fascinating.

I wonder how he figured out if a person he just snapped had walked by years ago... I guess face recognition is possible.

metalman•6mo ago

this is art,it is not a file.

danhau•6mo ago

Would dates not enhance this art?

JKCalhoun•6mo ago

Maybe. It's possible too it would take something away. As it is we're left to wonder and we would of course lose that.

As I recall, Feynman made a comment in one of his autobiographies about an argument he had had with an artist friend about the beauty of a rose. His friend was frustrated with Feynman's reductionist approach to everything including the rose. Paraphrasing Feynman: "How does knowing more about how a rose works take away from its beauty?"

I wonder if Feynman understood that naivety is a thing you can lose or if he understood that but did not see any value in naivety, mystery.

Perhaps a counterpoint to Feynman: "When I Heard the Learned Astronomer".

Cerium•6mo ago

I think not. I enjoyed looking for details, for example how a backpack is clean in one photo and dirty in the other. Not knowing the details let's the viewer ponder and compair with more curiosity and intrigue. It sets a mystery.

hylianwarrior•6mo ago

"From 2007 to 2016 Funch carried out his project 42nd and Vanderbilt in which he captures the same person twice, mid-commute, leaving the viewer to wonder if they were photographed days, months, or even years apart."

metalman•6mo ago

art is not editable. but I believe that cameras are not prohibitivly expensive, corners where many comuters pass are likely close to where you are, and your time is your own, so feel free to produce another similar art piece, with anotations of your choice, and in 8 or 9 years you can publish it. have fun!

mc32•6mo ago

It's reminiscent of but different from Philip Lorca diCorcia's automated street photographs in NYC from his "Heads" project: https://www.deutscheboersephotographyfoundation.org/en/colle...

Funch's project is more interesting because it captures a person at least twice over time; however, the photos are less well executed compared to the ones from diCorcia, but that's to be expected as diCorcia only had to find good and photogenic photographs once per subject, Funch had to get his subject's photos at least twice --so it was much harder to do.

appease7727•6mo ago

That's weird. The extreme bias towards individuals in the same pose make me think the pairs were found computationally. Could have been done by hand, but I'd expect much, much more variety.

JR1427•6mo ago

Interesting project. Most of the pairs seem to not be taken very far apart.

rapnie•6mo ago

These people on their daily commute reminded me of the work of Ritzo Ten Cate, called "Caught in the App" [0]. The photos of 'phone zombies' walking the street are indicative how much and how quickly society has changed under the influence of our tech devices. On the Dutch website [1] are some more pictures and link to a TEDx talk Ritzo gave on the art campaign.

[0] https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/haunting-photos-of-lo...

[1] https://ritzotencate.com/project/caught-in-the-app/

fennecfoxy•6mo ago

Before that it was newspapers. And the boomers who bitched I was on the computer for too long every day are now also doing their commute with their nose pressed against the glass of the window into a world of easily detectable fake news.

haswell•6mo ago

Before smartphones, there was not an equivalent number of people burying their heads in newspapers.

Many people point to “well this is just the new X”, but I think this underrepresents the impact of modern tech, which in many cases bears a passing resemblance to some earlier era while in reality having a drastically different footprint and impact on society.

fennecfoxy•5mo ago

Oh for sure, wealth accumulation, corporate lobbying, public indifference have certainly created a modern technological dystopian hellscape dissimilar to the comparatively minuscule newspaper conglomerates of the before-fore-times.

FrameworkFred•6mo ago

This reminds me of Auggie's photo album in Smoke..."Sometimes the different ones become the same ones and the same ones disappear."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGV_h36uZ5E

thunderbong•6mo ago

Thank you for reminding me of this movie. It's one of my favorites and I haven't seen it in ages. Have to re-watch it now once more

fennecfoxy•6mo ago

Quite interesting project. I find the topic of street photography interesting as well as many people don't realise that in most places they have no right to privacy in public, also that they use this power themselves even when taking their own photos (there are still people in the background).

Just picked up a Pentax 67ii as well - digital cameras are great for capturing must have moments but recently I've found there's something about film that makes me slow down and enjoy each shot so much more. I still have my phone for quick shots at the end of the day.

PorterBHall•6mo ago

I live in a somewhat small community (~25k) and I commuted into the city on public transportation for about 15 years. 10 years ago, I started working from home full-time.

I often see the people I used to commute with around town. I recognize them and remember them, but I’ve never had any interactions with them.

When I see them, I’m surprised by how much older they look. Then I realize I must look older to them.

moi2388•6mo ago

I’m calling bullshit.

Too many people have the exact same clothes, the same hairstyle, same accessories, and none seem to be aged 9 years

xnx•6mo ago

The project spanned 9 years. The photos in each pair are not 9 year apart.

moi2388•6mo ago

Yes but it said the photos might be years apart; I don’t see any of those

Show HN: Mermaid Formatter – CLI and library to auto-format Mermaid diagrams

RFCs vs. READMEs: The Evolution of Protocols

Kanchipuram Saris and Thinking Machines

Chinese chemical supplier causes global baby formula recall

I've used AI to write 100% of my code for a year as an engineer

Looking for 4 Autistic Co-Founders for AI Startup (Equity-Based)

AI-native capabilities, a new API Catalog, and updated plans and pricing

What changed in tech from 2010 to 2020?

From Human Ergonomics to Agent Ergonomics

Advanced Inertial Reference Sphere

Toyota Developing a Console-Grade, Open-Source Game Engine with Flutter and Dart

Typing for Love or Money: The Hidden Labor Behind Modern Literary Masterpieces

Show HN: A longitudinal health record built from fragmented medical data

CoreWeave's $30B Bet on GPU Market Infrastructure

Creating and Hosting a Static Website on Cloudflare for Free

"The Stanford scam proves America is becoming a nation of grifters"

Elon Musk on Space GPUs, AI, Optimus, and His Manufacturing Method

X (Twitter) is back with a new X API Pay-Per-Use model

Zlob.h 100% POSIX and glibc compatible globbing lib that is faste and better

Show HN: Deterministic signal triangulation using a fixed .72% variance constant

Scientists Discover Levitating Time Crystals You Can Hold, Defy Newton’s 3rd Law

When Michelangelo Met Titian

Solving NYT Pips with DLX

Baldur's Gate to be turned into TV series – without the game's developers

Interview with 'Just use a VPS' bro (OpenClaw version) [video]

EchoJEPA: Latent Predictive Foundation Model for Echocardiography

Disablling Go Telemetry

Effective Nihilism

The UK government didn't want you to see this report on ecosystem collapse

No 10 blocks report on impact of rainforest collapse on food prices