frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Massive Attack turns concert into facial recognition surveillance experiment

https://www.gadgetreview.com/massive-attack-turns-concert-into-facial-recognition-surveillance-experiment
100•loteck•1h ago

Comments

lawlessone•1h ago
Rollercoaster headline
jkingsman•1h ago
Feels like this title could benefit from clarification that 'Massive Attack' refers to the band and not the concept of a large scale attack; perhaps "Band 'Massive Attack' Turns Concert into Facial Recognition Surveillance Experiment"
IOUnix•1h ago
Hahah, great point. As a music nut I knew what it was talking about, but to people who don't it might seem alarming.
antonymoose•51m ago
I unironically thought this was going to be about a recent terrorist attack on a concert.
ricardonunez•39m ago
“Turns concert” clarified it to me.
bruffen•34m ago
My next stop was going to be LiveLeak to see the aftermath.
tptacek•1h ago
Neat and all, but I'd be even happier if they flirted with the experiment of actually touring a new album, rather than serving as trip-hop's answer to Roger Waters, touring forever on the same 12 songs.
bigiain•1h ago
While I agree, in that I'd love a new album.

God damn those are 12 great songs!

tptacek•58m ago
I'd say the same thing but I saw them on the Mezzanine nostalgia tour in Chicago, which was very expensive, and it was... not one of the best shows I've seen. I'd seen them a couple times prior and they were fine (I was both times surprised by the guest vocalists they'd managed to drag along on those tours). The Mezzanine tour though was like Spinal Tap's appearance on the Simpsons; "there will be no encore!".
wisemang•39m ago
I thoroughly enjoyed their Toronto show on that tour. To be fair it was the first time I’d seen them in concert so I didn’t have any points of comparison.

I also hadn’t really clued in to just how political they were until seeing their visuals, which I also thought added a lot. Surely not everyone’s cup of tea though.

Loughla•59m ago
You watch your dirty mouth. They're amazing and you know it.

But yes. They do need new material dammit.

jsbisviewtiful•55m ago
Massive Attack has 7 albums, so what are you talking about?
tptacek•45m ago
It's been 15 years since their last original LP and over 20 years since the last album anyone really cared about (Google their setlists --- they play more covers than they do tracks from their last LP).
maplethorpe•1h ago
A few sentences in, I was thinking that the article felt AI-generated, so I scrolled to the bottom of the page. There's no author listed, but there is this disclaimer:

"AI assists in refining our editorial process, ensuring that every article is engaging, clear and succinct."

One thing I hope we'll see in the future on these types of articles is the ability to view the original prompt. If your goal is to be succinct, you can't get much more succinct than that.

ortusdux•1h ago
Just have an AI summarize it for you /s

https://marketoonist.com/2023/03/ai-written-ai-read.html

elpakal•1h ago
or move the disclaimer to the top. or better yet, have aggregators like HN add a badge if it's likely AI generated
jedberg•28m ago
> or better yet, have aggregators like HN add a badge if it's likely AI generated

How could you possibly tell? I've been playing around with AI detectors, putting in known all-human samples, known all-AI samples, and mixed samples.

The only thing it's gotten right is not marking a human sample as 100% AI (but it marked one of the AI samples as 100% human).

Having such a mark would be a witch-hunt for sure.

sarreph•48m ago
The (presumably fully human) author is listed in the byline at the top of the article.

What is sadly rather ironic is the author's first name, "Al" looks like AI when stylised in the article's font.

jonplackett•28m ago
That jovial overly friendly tone is a give away. Like to thinks its writing style is HILARIOUSLY clever
Waterluvian•9m ago
> view the original prompt

I think this assumes a very limited scope of how AI gets used for these. As if the article is a one and done output from a single prompt. I can imagine many iterative prompts combined with some copying and pasting to get an hour’s worth of copy in five minutes.

ajcp•1h ago
Just wait until Coldplay gets ahold of this tech.
thw_9a83c•1h ago
> The band deployed live facial recognition technology that captured and analyzed attendees during their recent performance.

I think more drama has been created around this than is necessary. Based on the video, the real-time projected visitor's faces were not analyzed. They were simply shown with a random description flag attached, such as "energetic," "compassionate," "inspiring," "fitness influencer," or "cloud watcher." It seems to be an artistic provocation showing what a real people analysis could look like.

stevage•59m ago
Oh so it isn't even recognition, in that it doesn't identify the people. Just face detection.
jkestner•47m ago
The fact that people were uncomfortable with simply having their pictures taken and shown without their knowledge gives lie to the idea that "You're in a public place—of course you have no right to privacy." It's great to be given the chance to face your principles.
autoexec•2m ago
> It seems to be an artistic provocation showing what a real people analysis could look like.

I that cause they should have used descriptions like "gay", "muslim", "poor", "bipolar", "twice divorced", "low quality hire", "easy to scam", "both parents are dead", "takes Metformin", "spends > 60 on alcohol a month", "dishonest"

stevage•1h ago
Not having a clear consent statement or saying what they are doing with the data seems the correct artistic choice.
ares623•59m ago
Now that’s what I call art.

It’s hard to explain the concept of surveillance and its effects to laypeople. And the corporations absolutely know that.

hamdingers•58m ago
From the video this appears to be face detection, with some cute strings attached at random to the detected faces.

I don't see evidence of facial recognition.

MyOutfitIsVague•48m ago
It displays the faces on the screen, and you recognize them.
pier25•38m ago
how did the code crop faces without facial recognition?
Gigachad•30m ago
Parent comment is saying the system wasn’t linking the faces to real names, just detecting a face in general.
Eisenstein•26m ago
'Face detection' means it can detect faces. 'Face recognition' means it recognizes the faces. A specific example of the difference: license plate detection will detect the presence of a license plate; license plate recognition will tell you the number on that plate.
dotancohen•25m ago
It was detecting faces, not recognizing them.

Recognition implies associating the faces with an ID.

pcl•23m ago
In the industry, that’s known as face (or facial) detection, which is a different problem than face recognition.

Face recognition means computing which individual from some other database of people a particular face belongs to.

There’s also face tracking — detecting a face in an image and then tracking the same face across subsequent images. Which is often implemented by using a face recognition approach, but without any predefined catalog of people — you just dynamically fill up your face database as faces appear in the image sequence / video source.

ycwatcher•54m ago
They have long been sounding the alarm to society through their art. As a longtime fan, I’m glad to see them being recognized in this way once again.
Lerc•34m ago
The YouTube video is a year old, and says the labels are fake.

Have they done this again with an updated system?

mkw5053•34m ago
Has it ever been confirmed if Robert Del Naja is Bansky?
musesum•30m ago
Well that was timely. I just requested a refund for my new Zenni eyeglasses because the IR blocking was also blocking my iPhone's faceID.

Maybe I should keep them.

zephod•24m ago
This lends even more weight to the theory that Massive Attack’s singer is, in fact, Banksy.
0xbadcafebee•14m ago
I tried to create an art piece sorta like this once. Video cameras in two separate places in the world, hooked up to a monitor. Made to look like a mirror, only you realize you're looking into a completely different place. So if you and someone else walk up to it, it's like you in another dimension. I was told I couldn't bring it to a regional burning man event because "it violates consent" (because they didn't consent to being filmed). Despite their being no storage or recording whatsoever and it only being a live feed to another identical event. The organizers just couldn't come to grips with the discomfort they felt that there are cameras capturing your image. We definitely need more of these projects so people don't keep their heads in the sand.
llm_nerd•12m ago
Are the faces even of audience members? Seems...gimmicky. The faces don't seem to react at all, and all are making almost AI movements. Many look artificial.

And it isn't identifying the people or anything. It's putting some meaningless adjective like "Resourceful" below them.

Have seen this headline a few times and thought it was actual novel, but instead it's just a surveillance gimmick. Put a bunch of generative AI face loops with bounding boxes and adjectives.

Dems wave hands, stomp feet about ICE using mobile face recognition app

https://www.theregister.com/2025/09/15/cbp_has_deployed_billions_in/
1•Bender•1m ago•0 comments

Careless engineer stored recovery codes in plaintext, got whole org pwned

https://www.theregister.com/2025/09/15/ransomware_recovery_codes_plaintext/
1•Bender•1m ago•0 comments

After years of strife, AFRINIC has elected a board. Now the hard work begins

https://www.theregister.com/2025/09/15/afrinic_election_called_what_next/
1•Bender•2m ago•0 comments

Free Online Traceroute Tool

https://tracerouteai.com
1•wantering•6m ago•0 comments

Most Work Is Translation

https://aparnacd.substack.com/p/most-work-is-translation
1•jger15•7m ago•0 comments

Fighting human trafficking with self-contained applications

https://lwn.net/SubscriberLink/1036916/2b10f1356b7ab0e7/
2•chmaynard•8m ago•0 comments

PlugAndData – plug‑and‑play data pipeline with automatic interface generation

https://pluganddata.com/
1•DanielPlugnData•8m ago•1 comments

Post-quantum security for SSH access on GitHub

https://github.blog/engineering/platform-security/post-quantum-security-for-ssh-access-on-github/
2•fcambus•8m ago•0 comments

A smart AI personal executive assistant

https://www.pulse-ai.world/
2•xisen•9m ago•2 comments

Active NPM supply chain attack: Tinycolor and 40 Packages Compromised

https://socket.dev/blog/tinycolor-supply-chain-attack-affects-40-packages
5•feross•10m ago•0 comments

Roblox and Discord sued after teen's suicide, joining wave of litigation

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/roblox-discord-lawsuit-teen-suicide-b2826315.html
1•donsupreme•12m ago•0 comments

Keeping SSH sessions alive with systemd-inhibit

https://kd8bny.com/posts/session_inhibit/
2•kd8bny•20m ago•0 comments

Project Linework – Stylized Vector World Maps

https://www.projectlinework.org/
1•oliverkwebb•22m ago•0 comments

The Shepherd: Minimalism in PID 1 [video]

https://fosdem.org/2025/schedule/event/fosdem-2025-5720-the-shepherd-minimalism-in-pid-1/
1•pykello•23m ago•0 comments

Why do software developers love complexity?

https://kyrylo.org/software/2025/08/21/why-do-software-developers-love-complexity.html
17•PaulHoule•37m ago•16 comments

Alarm and Overload

https://novum.substack.com/p/two-media-tactics-of-the-2020s
2•paulpauper•40m ago•0 comments

Science of Chess: What does it mean to have a "chess personality?"

https://lichess.org/@/NDpatzer/blog/science-of-chess-what-does-it-mean-to-have-a-chess-personalit...
1•tech_ken•44m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Summarize Any Article, Paper, or Video in 5 Bullet Points

https://unrav.io/summarize
3•rriley•45m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Labspace Directory – Biotech resource for lab space

https://www.labspacedirectory.com
2•ejhodges•47m ago•0 comments

Total porn ban proposed by Michigan lawmakers

https://www.fox2detroit.com/news/total-porn-ban-proposed-michigan-lawmakers
35•healsdata•52m ago•9 comments

Germany's Autobahn Bridges Are Going to Pieces

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2025-09-15/germany-s-autobahn-bridges-are-crumbling
2•JumpCrisscross•53m ago•0 comments

The unbearable sameness of Liquid Glass

https://www.theverge.com/apple/778197/liquid-glass-iphone-watch-ipad-mac
5•mastazi•53m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What Are the Best Database AI Agent? NLQ System?

1•desaiguddu•53m ago•0 comments

West Texas Gas Falls to 14-Month Low as Negative Prices Persist

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-09-15/west-texas-gas-falls-to-14-month-low-as-negati...
1•JumpCrisscross•53m ago•0 comments

Russia Made Drone Production a Supreme Priority. Now It Swarms the Skies

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/14/world/europe/russia-ukraine-drone-attacks-production.html
5•bookofjoe•54m ago•1 comments

What Are the Best Database AI Agent? NLQ System?

1•desaiguddu•54m ago•0 comments

Show HN: PHP MCP SDK

https://github.com/dalehurley/php-mcp-sdk
1•dalemhurley•55m ago•0 comments

TerminalTextEffects: A terminal visual effects engine, application, and library

https://chrisbuilds.github.io/terminaltexteffects/
2•podiki•56m ago•0 comments

Show HN: SimKit – TS framework for testing and running AI agent simulations

4•anthonySs•57m ago•0 comments

The peril of unquoted Python strings, and how they caused CVE-2024-9287

https://pythonkoans.substack.com/p/koan-12-the-blacksmiths-hammer
2•meander_water•1h ago•0 comments