The phaseout of the mmap() file operation in Linux

https://lwn.net/SubscriberLink/1038715/e4a2f8f50c244545/

110•chmaynard•4mo ago

Comments

Denvercoder9•4mo ago

To be clear, this is about the internal implementation in the kernel, the mmap() system call is not going anywhere.

K0IN•4mo ago

thank you that was the first thing I had to check.

porridgeraisin•4mo ago

"We do NOT break userspace"

sethops1•4mo ago

_shifty eyes over at cgroups_

o11c•4mo ago

Or the numerous syscall breakages (2.4 to 2.6 was most notable, but there have been plenty before/since).

Or all sorts of things in /proc/ and /sys/.

And the sheer nastiness of PPID 0.

And ...

aa-jv•4mo ago

I'm relieved, but also somewhat befuddled that someone would write such a shocking headline. It immediately had me reaching for the lkml archives to find out whats really going on.

denotational•4mo ago

In its defence, the headline says "file operation" rather than "syscall", which makes it slightly less egregious: it's referring to `mmap` as a member of `struct file_operations`.

dooglius•4mo ago

The mmap syscall operates on files so it's still very easily misinterpreted

commandersaki•4mo ago

Which worked as intended; I first had a shock, did a double take, and realised there was nuance in file operation, read a little bit of the article and confirmed my suspicion it didn't have anything to do with the syscall.

arp242•4mo ago

mmap is POSIX, so it's not going anywhere and you can rely on it until POSIX systems are phased out or the heat death of the universe, whichever comes sooner.

ajross•4mo ago

Indeed. But even so, it's mildly shocking, as struct file_operations has been one of the deepest (and most promiscuously) integrated and most conservative bits of the kernel API. This stuff dates back decades and almost never changes. And there are a lot of raw file drivers[1] still there from eras most people have forgotten about.

This is a big, big reorg even for Linux.

[1] To be fair, most of which probably don't support mapping.

kragen•4mo ago

Yes, that's true. However, it's a kernel-internal API, and those have never been considered stable, unlike the system call ABIs, which are mostly sacrosanct. Except for, like, uselib(). This is because pretty much all the code that calls the kernel-internal APIs is in a monorepo, so you can fix it all when you make the change.

Also, it's not that the core kernel is ceasing to provide a facility that drivers depended on; rather, it's ceasing to depend on a facility that drivers provided. But doing so involves adding this new mmap_prepare() thing, which is making the kernel depend on a new facility that drivers now must provide, I guess?

doubletwoyou•4mo ago

That comment about how /dev/zero used to be used to allocate anonymous pages, anyone have more info? All I could find was a wikipedia article [0]

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki//dev/zero

jeffbee•4mo ago

That's it, there isn't any more to know. When the ancient unixes first began to support anonymous maps, they were just hacked into existing code with "zero" as the file, because the only through-line in the unix family history is that the API must be as hideous as it needs to be to accommodate lazy system authors.

ars•4mo ago

There is more to know, does the code special case this? Does it use the file name? Major minor number? Or does it actually read zero's from it and place them in memory?

convolvatron•4mo ago

it wouldn't be too hard to look at the source for mmap and zero, but since the topic of this article is the removal of the mmap 'virtual function' in the file, that would have been a pretty good place to throw a zero-page allocation

mort96•4mo ago

Wait, by "allocating anonymous pages" we just mean memory allocation from the kernel that's used for implementing e.g malloc, right? Did memory mapped files come before memory allocation so that it "made sense" to implement memory allocation as "mapping in /dev/zero"?

Or was some amount heap memory always just mapped into the process in early UNIX so that the need to map more pages only appeared as programs started to demand more heap memory than whatever the standard amount was?

pdw•4mo ago

In those days malloc would use sbrk to allocate memory. And yes, mmap was designed to memory map files. Using it to allocate anonymous pages came later.

mort96•4mo ago

Oh, I had never even heard of those syscalls before! Thanks, that makes sense.

DonHopkins•4mo ago

I hope the new API is flexible enough to support my proposed /dev/seven, an infinite source of ^G.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17532285

>DonHopkins on July 14, 2018 | parent | context | favorite | on: The everything-is-a-file principle – Linus Torvald...

>I always wanted /dev/zero, which is used to mmap zeros into memory, to be more general and use the device minor number to define which byte gets mapped, so you could mknod /dev/seven with a minor number of 7, to provide an infinite source of beeps!

mort96•4mo ago

I want a /dev/yes. I'm tired of typing 'yes | apt install' etc. I want to type '</dev/yes apt install'. Just an infinite stream of "y\n".

danudey•4mo ago

Can we also have /dev/bseven, which is the same thing but as a block device? Convenient if you ever want to be able to acquire ^G at larger scale, or randomly seek through your infinite ^G.

matja•4mo ago

CUSE on Linux can do that: https://libfuse.github.io/doxygen/cuse_8c.html

drob518•4mo ago

Yea, that’s a clickbait headline. A lot less concerning once you read the first paragraphs.

The purpose of Continuous Integration is to fail

Apfelstrudel: Live coding music environment with AI agent chat

What Is Stoicism?

What happens when a neighborhood is built around a farm

Every major galaxy is speeding away from the Milky Way, except one

Extreme Inequality Presages the Revolt Against It

There's no such thing as "tech" (Ten years later)

What Really Killed Flash Player: A Six-Year Campaign of Deliberate Platform Work

Ask HN: Anyone orchestrating multiple AI coding agents in parallel?

Show HN: Knowledge-Bank

Show HN: The Codeverse Hub Linux

Take a trip to Japan's Dododo Land, the most irritating place on Earth

British drivers over 70 to face eye tests every three years

BookTalk: A Reading Companion That Captures Your Voice

Is AI "good" yet? – tracking HN's sentiment on AI coding

Show HN: Amdb – Tree-sitter based memory for AI agents (Rust)

OpenClaw Partners with VirusTotal for Skill Security

Show HN: Seedance 2.0 Release

Leisure Suit Larry's Al Lowe on model trains, funny deaths and Disney

Towards Self-Driving Codebases

VCF West: Whirlwind Software Restoration – Guy Fedorkow [video]

Show HN: COGext – A minimalist, open-source system monitor for Chrome (<550KB)

FOSDEM 26 – My Hallway Track Takeaways

Show HN: Env-shelf – Open-source desktop app to manage .env files

Show HN: Almostnode – Run Node.js, Next.js, and Express in the Browser

Dell support (and hardware) is so bad, I almost sued them

Project Pterodactyl: Incremental Architecture

Styling: Search-Text and Other Highlight-Y Pseudo-Elements

Crypto firm accidentally sends $40B in Bitcoin to users

Magnetic fields can change carbon diffusion in steel

The purpose of Continuous Integration is to fail

Apfelstrudel: Live coding music environment with AI agent chat

What Is Stoicism?

What happens when a neighborhood is built around a farm

Every major galaxy is speeding away from the Milky Way, except one

Extreme Inequality Presages the Revolt Against It

There's no such thing as "tech" (Ten years later)

What Really Killed Flash Player: A Six-Year Campaign of Deliberate Platform Work

Ask HN: Anyone orchestrating multiple AI coding agents in parallel?

Show HN: Knowledge-Bank

Show HN: The Codeverse Hub Linux

Take a trip to Japan's Dododo Land, the most irritating place on Earth

British drivers over 70 to face eye tests every three years

BookTalk: A Reading Companion That Captures Your Voice

Is AI "good" yet? – tracking HN's sentiment on AI coding

Show HN: Amdb – Tree-sitter based memory for AI agents (Rust)

OpenClaw Partners with VirusTotal for Skill Security

Show HN: Seedance 2.0 Release

Leisure Suit Larry's Al Lowe on model trains, funny deaths and Disney

Towards Self-Driving Codebases

VCF West: Whirlwind Software Restoration – Guy Fedorkow [video]

Show HN: COGext – A minimalist, open-source system monitor for Chrome (<550KB)

FOSDEM 26 – My Hallway Track Takeaways

Show HN: Env-shelf – Open-source desktop app to manage .env files

Show HN: Almostnode – Run Node.js, Next.js, and Express in the Browser

Dell support (and hardware) is so bad, I almost sued them

Project Pterodactyl: Incremental Architecture

Styling: Search-Text and Other Highlight-Y Pseudo-Elements

Crypto firm accidentally sends $40B in Bitcoin to users

Magnetic fields can change carbon diffusion in steel

The phaseout of the mmap() file operation in Linux

Comments