frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Mise: Monorepo Tasks

https://github.com/jdx/mise/discussions/6564
108•jdxcode•2h ago

Comments

jdxcode•2h ago
I'm really excited about this. I think it blends the both worlds of simple task runners like just/taskfile while also having a lot of the power of tools like bazel/buck2. Excited to hear about what people build!
imiric•42m ago
I don't know, I'm torn about it.

I use mise and mostly like it. It has simplified my workflow for managing environments. But I don't need a task runner. `Make` and `just` already fulfill that purpose for me. I haven't used them in a monorepo, but both support importing and extending task/recipe files, so presumably it's possible to set them up appropriately. Maybe the UX wouldn't be as polished as a tool built for that use case, but I like my tools to "do one thing well". mise already does quite a lot as an environment manager, and I'd prefer it to remain focused on those problems.

Ah, you're the author. Thanks for all your work!

banseljaj•1h ago
For quite some time, I have gathered this set of Rust CLI tasks that are exactly the same. I have used them as template generators for cargo-generate. This became a problem recently when I was writing a monorepo that had mixed projects (Rust server, Svelte Frontend, and Terraform deployment). This comes at just the right time for me to utilize this without going insane.

Also, I had a not-so-great experience with other builders/managers, including lerna so I love this.

@jdxcode, how long before I can replace Emacs with mise?

jdxcode•1h ago
I hope never! scope is big enough!
zephraph•1h ago
I'm really bullish on mise as a tool. It's quickly become one of my goto tools when starting a new project. Being able to have one config file to manage tools (node, python, rust, go, etc) as well as a simple makefile replacement makes it incredibly convenient. I pretty much always setup a `postinstall` hook so all someone has to do is `mise install` one of my projects and they'll get all the correct tool versions as well as having dependencies installed (like running `npm install`) automatically.

I feel it's significantly more practical than something like nix which feels like it has a steep learning curve.

blackhaj7•59m ago
A mise postinstall hook?

What do you put in it?

drcongo•1h ago
Mise has become almost indispensable for me within just a few months, I've rebuilt so much of our tooling around it. If anyone else finds it as integral to their work I'd like to encourage them to also sponsor it.
alexjplant•1h ago
I love mise so much and use it at $DAYJOB to manage a multi-service polyglot monorepo. Can't wait to try this.
chanux•1h ago
I was a bit slow to hop on mise because it took me while understand it (Likely because I entered thinking of it as a direnv replacement with more features).

It especially makes life behind corporate barbed wires easier for me (YMMV).

arcticfox•1h ago
How does this compare to moon?

https://github.com/moonrepo/moon

jdxcode•55m ago
I’m not super familiar with moon, but I think it’d be fair to say mise started out solving the tool problem where moon solved the build problem first. I’d expect both to be more fleshed out than the other in both departments.

You could probably use mise tools for moon builds, or proto with mise tasks too if you wanted to.

ruined•1h ago
i will just add another comment appreciating mise.

i even added some mise config lines to my global gitignore because i often use it in projects by others that don't set up mise config.

thundergolfer•1h ago
Can someone with both Bazel and mise experience comment on whether mise fulfils its promise of being a "sweet spot" between Bazel and anarchy?

I've used Bazel a lot and contributed to it, but don't feel like it's adoptable by engineering teams <100 in size. mise might be an option though.

gorset•46m ago
I've used bazel for about 10 years, all in small orgs. Right now, single digit team.

I don't think there exists a better solution for a project mixing Java and C/C++ than Bazel. The new module system for bazel has matured a lot. As an example, it's trivial to add boringssl and access it from Java.

jdxcode•22m ago
This is fair. mise (by design) does nothing to help with that sort of thing. It's also definitely designed for languages outside C/C++, and to a lesser degree Java.

mise tasks are basically just fancy bash scripts though, so I could totally see a setup that uses mise tasks/tools for node/js/ruby and dispatches to other tools for building Java and C/C++.

spankalee•1h ago
Not caching tasks is kind of a huge missing feature. Once you can describe a graph of tasks with dependencies, not running already clean dependencies is how you make that tractable for repeated runs even in moderate-sized monorepos.

I went looking for an issue to see if they're planning it, but the Mise repo doesn't have issues enabled? And no discussion on the README about why they don't. That doesn't inspire confidence.

If you're in a single-language npm monorepo, check out Wireit. It extends plain npm scripts to be able to have dependencies and caching (local and GitHub actions). It also has a unique service type of script for long-running tasks that lets you rebuild dependencies and no restart services.

https://github.com/google/wireit/

jdxcode•58m ago
I’d argue it’s mise’s indifference to project source code and library dependencies that gives it the simplicity worth using.

There’s a couple exceptions to that boundary but in general that’s where mise stops.

rsyring•42m ago
> I went looking for an issue to see if they're planning it, but the Mise repo doesn't have issues enabled? And no discussion on the README about why they don't. That doesn't inspire confidence.

I'm not sure when/why the issues were turned off. That's...surprising.

There used to be an issue that said the maintainers preferred discussions over issues. I'd link to it but it's a 404 now.

I've started a discussion regarding the lack of issues: https://github.com/jdx/mise/discussions/6566

Regarding confidence: I've used the project for a couple years now. I have a ton of confidence in it and I recommend it to everyone. While preferring discussions to issues is uncommon, the release frequency and utility of mise speak for itself. Take the time to look around the discussions and/or just use it. :)

esafak•29m ago
You are asking mise to become a build system like bazel. I suppose it already is one, in a sense.
rsyring•18m ago
Turns out caching tasks is an anti-goal:

https://mise.jdx.dev/roadmap.html#anti-goals

> Remote task caching - turbopack, moonrepo, and many others are trying to solve this (major) problem. mise's task runner will likely always just be a simple convenience around executing scripts.

jauntywundrkind•52m ago
Kind of interesting seeing mise grow and grow. Others have noted they encountered it first as a direnv replacement. At my last job it was an asdf tool-installer replacement. It's also a task and now mono-repo task runner.

It feels a little fragile to me to try to tackle so many concerns: if folks start relying on mise for more capabilities and one of them falls short, isn't as good as it could be, that could be a big hurt. There's definitely a nice conceptual win to having an all in one tool, but scoping up ambition feels risky.

Especially with task running, it feels like there's really so many very specific expert concerns that come into play. Being able to have a task graph & understanding the minimum work needed, being able to run only downstream tasks is a pretty important need, and that really gets into programming language specific views of what's happening. The idea of having something generic & so all is tempting but it feels impossible to get satisfactory results here.

Beyond Mise specifically, it's just interesting seeing the continuum between specific & multi-purpose tool, and seeing how software tends to scope itself up.

kstrauser•40m ago
I'd counter that I actively don't want those more powerful features. Like, I get why anyone would want them, but right now Mise is "knowable". I can sit down with its doc site and figure out any of its features without building a strong mental model of their underlying implementation. And that also means my coworkers aren't as likely to abuse and twist it into the kinds of things people have used tools like Make for.

I would vastly rather have Mise shell out to Make etc for more complex DAG stuff. Those tools already exist and are good at their own specialties. Mise doesn't need to reinvent everything.

But I do think the new monorepo tasks are very on-brand for it. They don't seem so much as to add deep functionality as to provide a convention for finding and running other Mise files in a repo.

jdxcode•21m ago
> But I do think the new monorepo tasks are very on-brand for it. They don't seem so much as to add deep functionality as to provide a convention for finding and running other Mise files in a repo.

yeah, "fancy bash scripts" is a good way to think about tasks

kstrauser•48m ago
This is beautiful! Thank you so much!

When I was primarily using Python, I didn't really "get" Mise. Uh, that's what we have uv for! But it really shines when using things like Node where you want a specific version in each directory, and also want common entrypoints like `mise build` or `mise test` in every repo, regardless of its language(s).

Don't get me wrong: I also adore Just as a task runner. It's what got me off of Make, which is incredibly powerful but somewhat lacking in the DevEx department to say the least. It's probably more "powerful" than Mise's tasks. However, Mise's combination of really good — not astounding, but really good — task runners plus all the tool management stuff is unbeatable for the things I work on.

jrop•30m ago
Mise is a hard sell for me when I can have pure Nix-shells. However, I can see this gaining wider adoption since it's learning curve is so much lower than Nix.
c-hendricks•23m ago
(no offense, I'm probably missing something)

Isn't running tasks in various folders kinda low hanging fruit for monorepo tasks? I've wanted a language/CI agnostic `monorepo-build-tool` build tool for a while, and getting something that allows for `monorepo-build-tool run-affected -- script/test` was one prompt to an LLM.

The bigger problem is caching and determining which projects need to be run when calling `run-affected`.

Apple Screwed Up Again [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p89cGm6X8i4
1•behnamoh•4m ago•0 comments

Saving My Commit With `jj evolog`

https://landaire.net/jj-evolog/
1•todsacerdoti•4m ago•1 comments

I used all the math I know to go from 352M to 12M CPU years

https://www.reddit.com/r/hacking/s/IiRNW9PTzC
1•keepamovin•6m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Photowand – Turn selfies into professional photos with AI

https://photowand.ai
1•fengjiabo2400•6m ago•0 comments

An Efficient Vision-Language-Action Model for Combat Tasks in 3D Action RPGs

https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.09527
1•mikhael•6m ago•0 comments

A Bio-Inspired Hexapod for Adaptive Terrain Navigation and Object Detection

https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.15264
1•PaulHoule•8m ago•0 comments

Multi-Platform Video Uploads: Using Identity Provider Links

https://fusionauth.io/blog/using-identity-provider-links
1•mooreds•8m ago•0 comments

How to Implement a Successful Technical Writing Process

https://www.wizardondemand.com/post/how-to-implement-a-successful-technical-writing-process
1•mooreds•9m ago•0 comments

Sora, AI Bicycles, and Meta Disruption

https://stratechery.com/2025/sora-ai-bicycles-and-meta-disruption/
1•feross•10m ago•0 comments

What's Coming in ESLint 10

https://eslint.org/blog/2025/10/whats-coming-in-eslint-10.0.0/
1•bpierre•12m ago•0 comments

The Content Crafters

https://craftercontent.blogspot.com/
1•arianmarry•12m ago•0 comments

OpenAI Guardrails: A Framework to Keep LLM Apps Safe and Reliable

https://openai.github.io/openai-guardrails-python/
1•meetpateltech•14m ago•0 comments

Interactive On-Device Segmentation in Snapseed

https://research.google/blog/towards-better-health-conversations-research-insights-on-a-wayfindin...
2•tmoertel•18m ago•0 comments

"Be Different" doesn't work for building products anymore

https://iamcharliegraham.substack.com/p/be-different-doesnt-work-for-building
12•grahac•18m ago•6 comments

Geometry of Motion

https://rishit-dagli.github.io/2025/10/05/geometry-of-motion.html
2•dagli•20m ago•0 comments

Solving the Mind-Body Problem: Dualism vs. Searle, Part 1

https://www.betonit.ai/p/solving-the-mind-body-problem-dualism
1•paulpauper•21m ago•0 comments

The Tariff Exemption Behind the AI Boom

https://www.apricitas.io/p/the-tariff-exemption-behind-the-ai
2•paulpauper•21m ago•0 comments

We Act Before We Understand

https://www.robkhenderson.com/p/we-act-before-we-understand
1•paulpauper•21m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Phone formatter I built for my mom to call home

https://callint.info
1•soelost•21m ago•0 comments

Bari Weiss named editor in chief of CBS News

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2025/10/06/bari-weiss-cbs-paramount/
6•geox•21m ago•1 comments

O'Briens Policeman – Why I built my AI Twin

https://markgreville.ie/2025/10/06/obriens-policeman-why-i-built-my-ai-twin/
1•gHeadphone•22m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Stat – a social platform where everything is a poll

https://stat-beta.netlify.app
1•kyryl_shulga•25m ago•1 comments

The product of the railways is the timetable

https://springbett.substack.com/p/the-product-of-the-railways-is-the
1•NaOH•25m ago•0 comments

Steve Eisman: U.S. Consumers Are Collapsing: Cars, Credit, & the Chaos Ahead [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qd7akdDtPXA
3•jameslk•25m ago•0 comments

Apple Faces French Investigation over Siri Voice Recordings

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-10-06/apple-faces-probe-in-france-over-voice-recordi...
4•c420•25m ago•1 comments

OpenZL: An Open Source Format-Aware Compression Framework

https://engineering.fb.com/2025/10/06/developer-tools/openzl-open-source-format-aware-compression...
4•terrelln•26m ago•0 comments

Renewing Our Open Source Pledge for 2025

https://blog.platformatic.dev/renewing-our-open-source-pledge-for-2025
2•feross•26m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Turn Text Prompts into Complete Figma Designs

https://www.figma.com/community/plugin/1545618089212283719/klana
1•joezee•26m ago•0 comments

An Open Letter to Llms.txt

https://olshansky.info/posts/2025-10-05-an-open-letter-to-llms-txt
2•Olshansky•28m ago•0 comments

Sharpie Found a Way to Make Pens More Cheaply–By Manufacturing Them in the U.S.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/sharpie-found-a-way-to-make-pens-more-cheaply-by-manufa...
2•CGMthrowaway•28m ago•0 comments