[0] The White House this week argued that the law that clearly and unambiguously requires this does not in fact do so, and OMB removed references to the law and its requirements from their shutdown guidance to agencies, so I would not count on the Administration honoring it, at least initially.
Interesting side note to this (to point out the hypocrisy and attempts at memory-holing): the law in question is the Government Employee Fair Treatment Act of 2019 which passed with extremely broad bipartisan support and was signed into law by Trump during his first term.
EDIT:
https://www.govexec.com/workforce/2025/10/tuesday-trump-admi...
That article covers the backtracking. Yesterday no back pay, today they tell the employees they will get back pay.
The article also states "...the Office of Management and Budget has deleted from its guidance any reference to the 2019 law [requiring back pay after shutdowns] back pay for furloughed federal workers"
OMB also issued a press release stating the law only applies to the one shutdown the law was created after.
So
1. Trump hasn't backtracked himself.
2. OMB has stated an argument allowing them to challenge the 2019 law.
4. The IRS is just one agency and Trump's comment was clear that only those he believed deserve back pay will get it. There's no contradiction in what the IRS said.
Also, A long drawn out executive power court battle will take months to years. People won't be paid unless there is some emergency relief from the courts.
beefnugs•4mo ago
eek2121•4mo ago
Complicating the matter further, employees may choose to work without pay, because backpay is legally required by law (certain individuals are trying to undo this, however, I lack the patience or desire to get into this on HN). That means that if employees have the means to hold out, they will ultimately be compensated.
Perhaps someone more informed can provide more detail.
trenchpilgrim•4mo ago
Jtsummers•4mo ago
wtallis•4mo ago
Jtsummers•4mo ago
This is wrong. If they're furloughed, they aren't working. Yes, by law (passed in 2019) they will get back pay, but they do not have the option to work without pay. If they're not furloughed, they may not be getting paid but it's not by choice that they continue working, it's because they weren't furloughed.
jhbadger•4mo ago
bombcar•4mo ago
The problem is getting everyone to work in such a concerted manner.