What would you differently, if you could redesign Linux userland from scratch?

11•signa11•3mo ago

Prompted from a similar discussion at lobsters (and i am copying the text verbatim)

    If we kept Linux the kernel exactly as it is today, but redesigned 
    everything in userland from scratch (the init system, the filesystem 
    hierarchy, the shell, libc, packaging, configuration, dbus, polkit, PAM, 
    etc.), what would you do differently, and why?

here is the link to the original lobsters post: https://lobste.rs/s/ko5i9y/if_you_could_redesign_linux_userland_from

Comments

jsifly•3mo ago

I'd have init as a JavaScript runtime, probably some fork of Node that's been rewritten in a memory-safe language like Ada or Rust, and everything else in the system as JavaScript or, preferably, TypeScript programs. Basically, start from scratch and do it more safely and better. Like Android tried to but more modern.

gus_massa•3mo ago

Isn't Android somewhat like that?

d3Xt3r•3mo ago

I'd use:

- Nitro instead of systemd

- musl instead of glibc

- LLVM/clang instead of gcc

- uutils instead of GNU coreutils

- apk as a package manager

- r/o filesystem in a virtual A/B configuration for immutability and instant-reboots (no post-update reboot delays unlike rpm-ostree).

- A minimal Rust-based WM/DE similar to XFCE/LabWC but with user-friendly GUI config and sane defaults, with zero GTK and Qt components.

- Ideally all GUIs will be coded in something fast and minimal, like e-GUI. Ideally the entire system will be free of bloat like GTK/Qt/Electron/Javascript crap, and anything that uses it will be containerised.

brudgers•3mo ago

  Nothing.

  Because breaking existing systems is bad design.
                                                 ^ That's a period

firefax•3mo ago

replace bash with qbasic

Show HN: Knowledge-Bank

Show HN: The Codeverse Hub Linux

Take a trip to Japan's Dododo Land, the most irritating place on Earth

British drivers over 70 to face eye tests every three years

BookTalk: A Reading Companion That Captures Your Voice

Is AI "good" yet? – tracking HN's sentiment on AI coding

Show HN: Amdb – Tree-sitter based memory for AI agents (Rust)

OpenClaw Partners with VirusTotal for Skill Security

Show HN: Seedance 2.0 Release

Leisure Suit Larry's Al Lowe on model trains, funny deaths and Disney

Towards Self-Driving Codebases

VCF West: Whirlwind Software Restoration – Guy Fedorkow [video]

Show HN: COGext – A minimalist, open-source system monitor for Chrome (<550KB)

FOSDEM 26 – My Hallway Track Takeaways

Show HN: Env-shelf – Open-source desktop app to manage .env files

Show HN: Almostnode – Run Node.js, Next.js, and Express in the Browser

Dell support (and hardware) is so bad, I almost sued them

Project Pterodactyl: Incremental Architecture

Styling: Search-Text and Other Highlight-Y Pseudo-Elements

Crypto firm accidentally sends $40B in Bitcoin to users

Magnetic fields can change carbon diffusion in steel

Fantasy football that celebrates great games

Show HN: Animalese

StrongDM's AI team build serious software without even looking at the code

John Haugeland on the failure of micro-worlds

Show HN: Velocity - Free/Cheaper Linear Clone but with MCP for agents

Corning Invented a New Fiber-Optic Cable for AI and Landed a $6B Meta Deal [video]

Show HN: XAPIs.dev – Twitter API Alternative at 90% Lower Cost

Near-Instantly Aborting the Worst Pain Imaginable with Psychedelics

Show HN: Nginx-defender – realtime abuse blocking for Nginx