I’ve been experimenting with the classic 196 Lychrel problem, but instead of trying to push the iteration record, I wanted to look at the structure of the 196 sequence over time.

Very briefly: starting from 196 in base 10, we repeatedly do reverse-and-add. No palindrome is known, despite huge computational searches, so 196 is treated as a Lychrel candidate, but there is no proof either way.

Rather than just asking “does it ever hit a palindrome?”, I asked:

> What does the *digit asymmetry* of the 196 sequence look like as we iterate?

---

### SDI: a simple asymmetry metric

I defined a toy metric, *SDI (Symmetry Defect Index)*:

* Write `n` in decimal, length `L`, let `pairs = L // 2`.

* Compare the left `pairs` digits with the right `pairs` digits reversed, so each pair of digits “faces” its mirror.

* For each pair `(dL, dR)`:

  ```text
  pair_score =
    abs((dL % 2) - (dR % 2)) +
    abs((dL % 5) - (dR % 5))
  ```

* Sum over all pairs to get `SDI`, then normalize:

  ```text
  normalized_SDI = SDI / pairs
  ```

Heuristic: lower means “more symmetric / structured”, higher means “more asymmetric / closer to random”. For random decimal digits, normalized SDI clusters around ~2.1 in my tests. I also mark ~1.6 as a “zombie line”: well below that looks very frozen/structured.

---

### Experiment

* Start: 196 * Operation: base-10 reverse-and-add * Steps: 50,000 * SDI sampled every 100 steps * Implementation: Python big ints + string-based SDI

By 50k steps, the 196 chain reaches about 20,000 decimal digits (~10^20000). I plotted normalized SDI vs step, plus a linear trend line and reference lines at 2.1 (random-ish) and 1.6 (zombie line).

I also ran the same SDI on 89 (which does reach a palindrome) for comparison.

---

### What it looks like

*For 196 (0–50k steps):*

* Normalized SDI lives mostly between ~1.1 and 2.2. * It does *not* drift toward 0 (no sign of “healing” into symmetry). * The trend line has a tiny positive slope (almost flat). * The cloud stays below the ~2.1 “random” line but mostly above the ~1.6 “zombie line”.

So 196 doesn’t look like it’s converging to a very symmetric state, and it doesn’t look fully random either. It seems stuck in a mid-level “zombie band” of asymmetry.

*For 89:*

* SDI starts around 2–3, then drifts downward. * When 89 finally reaches a palindrome, SDI collapses sharply to 0 at that step. * This matches the intuition: a “healing” sequence that ends in perfect symmetry.

SDI cleanly separates the behaviour of 89 (heals to a palindrome) from 196 (stays in a noisy mid-level band).

---

### Code and plots

Code and plots are here (including the SDI implementation and 196 vs 89 graphs):

* GitHub: [https://github.com/jivaprime/192](https://github.com/jivaprime/192)

---

### Looking for feedback

I’m curious about:

* Similar work: have you seen digit-symmetry / asymmetry metrics applied to Lychrel candidates before? * Better metrics: any more standard notions of “symmetry defect” or digit entropy you’d recommend? * Scaling: ideas for a C/Rust implementation that occasionally samples SDI far beyond this (e.g., at depths comparable to the classic 196 palindrome quests)?

Happy to tweak the metric, run other starting values / bases, or collect more data if people have ideas.

Contact Center Bank Aladin

Tired of checking AWS costs daily. Is this SaaS idea valid?

The Hidden Job Market: How to Access the Roles No One Posts

Ant Design 6.0 is released

The Strange and Totally Real Plan to Blot Out the Sun and Reverse Global Warming

Leading in Low-Trust Times

Windows 95 and 98 emulator with games

Overview of the Spin-Polarized-Fusion Landscape [pdf]

Spinning Fusion Fuel for Efficiency

The Probability Paradox: Why Actuaries Can't Price AI

Show HN: KNothing – A privacy-first, client-side developer tool station (Nuxt 3)

No Longer an Amazon.com Customer

Source of Widespread 'Forever Chemical' Contamination in N Carolina

Marriott's Disastrous Bet on Short-Term Rental Company Sonder

Micromort

How many valid JSON byte sequences are there?

Ask HN: What tools do you pay for today that feel overpriced or frustrating?

RuBee

Japan's gamble to turn island of Hokkaido into global chip hub

The Cloudflare outage was a good thing

KeePassXC 2.7.11 Released

A free tool that stuns LLMs with thousands of invisible Unicode characters

McMaster Carr – The Smartest Website You Haven't Heard Of

Style Reference vs. Image Prompts: What's the Difference?

Visualizing asymmetry in the 196 Lychrel chain (50k steps, 20k digits)

Napster Said It Raised $3B from an Investor. Now 'Investor' and 'Money' Are Gone

Ouya

'The public has been lied to': made doc insists that aliens exist

SecIron Is Recruiting for Technical Support in KL, Malaysia-Challenge Yourself

Show HN: 3M km interferometer concept using Saturn moons

Contact Center Bank Aladin

Contact Center Bank Aladin

Tired of checking AWS costs daily. Is this SaaS idea valid?

The Hidden Job Market: How to Access the Roles No One Posts

Ant Design 6.0 is released

The Strange and Totally Real Plan to Blot Out the Sun and Reverse Global Warming

Leading in Low-Trust Times

Windows 95 and 98 emulator with games

Overview of the Spin-Polarized-Fusion Landscape [pdf]

Spinning Fusion Fuel for Efficiency

The Probability Paradox: Why Actuaries Can't Price AI

Show HN: KNothing – A privacy-first, client-side developer tool station (Nuxt 3)

No Longer an Amazon.com Customer

Source of Widespread 'Forever Chemical' Contamination in N Carolina

Marriott's Disastrous Bet on Short-Term Rental Company Sonder

Micromort

How many valid JSON byte sequences are there?

Ask HN: What tools do you pay for today that feel overpriced or frustrating?

RuBee

Japan's gamble to turn island of Hokkaido into global chip hub

The Cloudflare outage was a good thing

KeePassXC 2.7.11 Released

A free tool that stuns LLMs with thousands of invisible Unicode characters

McMaster Carr – The Smartest Website You Haven't Heard Of

Style Reference vs. Image Prompts: What's the Difference?

Visualizing asymmetry in the 196 Lychrel chain (50k steps, 20k digits)

Napster Said It Raised $3B from an Investor. Now 'Investor' and 'Money' Are Gone

Ouya

'The public has been lied to': made doc insists that aliens exist

SecIron Is Recruiting for Technical Support in KL, Malaysia-Challenge Yourself

Show HN: 3M km interferometer concept using Saturn moons