1. Take a trait (IQ) that is highly heritable within well-nourished, educated, industrial populations. 2. Observe large average differences between populations that differ dramatically in nutrition, disease burden, schooling, and historical trauma. 3. Assume, without any direct genetic evidence, that the between-group gap must be largely genetic because the within-group heritability is high
I have made an effort to acquaint myself with the ACTUAL literature on evolutionary theory. It is nothing like what popular media would have you believe.
DrierCycle•1h ago
https://www.nature.com/articles/mp2014105
adamzwasserman•1h ago
it reflects a pre-1990s dogmatic belief in extrapolationist macroevolution.
It treats high heritability + polygenic additive variance as if that somehow proves the Modern Synthesis was right about everything
It never once mentions developmental constraint, niche construction, active rGE as a macroevolutionary ratchet, cultural-genetic co-evolution, or any of the other mechanisms that the post-2000 literature now recognizes as necessary for understanding why human g exploded in the last million years
YMMV
DrierCycle•53m ago