Ask HN: Who else got pwned by the Next.js RCE?

12•whycombinetor•2mo ago

I'm a little embarrassed, but not sure what I could have done differently other than reading the Saturday email from GCP with the nondescript subject "New Advisory Notification". Ten hours later, GCP instance suspended due to crypto mining. Now looking at the disk image, it installed something at ~/nxt/ , installed a monero miner at ~/c3pool/ , and added several systemctl services to run these on startup. BRB, killing this machine with fire... This makes me think I should be running everything in Docker, even simple small stuff that "shouldn't" have any potential security issues.

Fortunately this machine wasn't anything important for me and there was no sensitive data to exfil beyond AI API keys. But I imagine there's other orgs that just got catastrophically, irrecoverably pwned.

What's your story?

(RCE context: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46136026 )

Comments

samdoesnothing•2mo ago

I'm sure a lot of people and companies got pwned and they aren't going to disclose it. There are chrome extensions that passively polls sites for the vulnerability, and since the vulnerability is so simple to exploit and leaves virtually no trace...

My gut feeling is that we are going to be feeling the consequences of simultaneous enshittification of software, the mounting complexity of our systems, and AI enslopification combine to create far more vulnerabilities in the future. The only defence is to adopt simple systems and software.

yellow_lead•2mo ago

I don't use Next.js but I'm curious as well. My impression was that most people run it under Vercel who patches quickly, but maybe that's not the case.

aosaigh•2mo ago

You had to patch manually

aosaigh•2mo ago

This might be a hot take, but I feel like the blurring of lines between back-end and front-end apps with platforms like Vercel will lead to more and more of these exploits. I’m an experienced full-stack dev and I’m constantly confused as to “where I am” in a Next code base. Server? Client? Edge? Proponents might say “that’s the point - you don’t have to worry about there you are, it’s one code base” but these sort of issues indicate otherwise.

All platforms can be exploited I guess, but I still wonder at the complexity of the platforms we now rely on and whether it’s justified.

codingdave•2mo ago

That touches on why I never pursued server-side React in any form. It seemed to twist what was a clean break between layers into spaghetti. I totally get that it solves other problems, but it always felt to me more like trying to force React to be something it was not. The better strategy seemed to me to use React on sites where users can handle the bulk of a front-end React app, and don't use it elsewhere.

Specific to security, keeping React 100% client-side keeps things simple: Don't trust the front-end.

brazukadev•1mo ago

> All platforms can be exploited I gues

React did not have this kind of security vulnerability in 10 years. The Vercel/NextJS/RSC rugpull is responsible for that and the people that made those changes should be named. The lack of shared governance is abysmal.

Show HN: Glance – Fast CSV inspection for the terminal (SIMD-accelerated)

Busy for the Next Fifty to Sixty Bud

Imperative

Show HN: I decomposed 87 tasks to find where AI agents structurally collapse

I went back to Linux and it was a mistake

Octrafic – open-source AI-assisted API testing from the CLI

US Accuses China of Secret Nuclear Testing

Peacock. A New Programming Language

A postcard arrived: 'If you're reading this I'm dead, and I really liked you'

What to know about the software selloff

Show HN: Syntux – generative UI for websites, not agents

Microsoft appointed a quality czar. He has no direct reports and no budget

AI overlay that reads anything on your screen (invisible to screen capture)

Show HN: Seafloor, be up and running with OpenClaw in 20 seconds

Tesla turbine-inspired structure generates electricity using compressed air

State Department deleting 17 years of tweets (2009-2025); preservation needed

Learning to code, or building side projects with AI help, this one's for you

Effulgence RPG Engine [video]

Five disciplines discovered the same math independently – none of them knew

We Scanned an AI Assistant for Security Issues: 12,465 Vulnerabilities

Amazon no longer defend cloud customers against video patent infringement claims

Show HN: Medinilla – an OCPP compliant .NET back end (partially done)

How Does AI Distribute the Pie? Large Language Models and the Ultimatum Game

Resistance Infrastructure

Fire-juggling unicyclist caught performing on crossing

Restoring a lost 1981 Unix roguelike (protoHack) and preserving Hack 1.0.3

GPS and Time Dilation – Special and General Relativity

Show HN: Witnessd – Prove human authorship via hardware-bound jitter seals

Show HN: I built a clawdbot that texts like your crush

Scientists reverse Alzheimer's in mice and restore memory (2025)