Is it just Mozilla testing the waters with the announcement?
On the other hand, are they even listening to their users or are they just adding AI to everything?
Mozilla's job is to go through the motions of competing for regulatory obfuscation, not to ever actually compete. That's why the salaries at this non-profit keep going up as Mozilla marketshare keeps going down.
If they wanted to actually compete they could integrate with LMStudio or similar to give their non-technical users locally running open models, that would be maximally opt-in and privacy preserving. It wouldn't even take that long.
Instead, we get another resume-padding fake "product" for someone to put on their resume before it's quietly forgotten, all for a browser with 3% marketshare and plummeting.
Does this just mean "the basilisk is coming and we want to make sure we're seen serving it"
and a response discussion:
I think nobody wants AI in Firefox, Mozilla
I've been thinking about this a lot while building in the productivity AI space. Most tools I've tried require you to set up elaborate workflows, connect 12 different services, and spend weeks tweaking prompts. The cognitive overhead defeats the purpose.
What's compelling about Firefox's approach (if they execute well) is that browser-level AI could actually understand context better than bolt-on solutions. Your browsing patterns, form fills, research sessions - there's rich signal there that doesn't require you to explicitly configure anything.
I got early access to ungrind.ai which takes a similar philosophy for email/meeting productivity - zero configuration, just connects to Gmail and starts working. The technical challenge is making the AI smart enough to infer intent without explicit rules, but when it works, the UX is so much cleaner.
The real test will be whether Firefox can resist feature creep. "Built for choice and control" sounds great until product managers start adding dozens of toggles and options.
Anyone know if they're planning to expose APIs for developers to build on top of their AI layer?
Hackbraten•1mo ago
sherr•1mo ago
The page says this thing will be opt-in. As it also says, they can't ignore the effect AI is having in the world. I'm not much of a fan of a lot of this effect, but see some benefits in places.
conartist6•1mo ago
yupyupyups•1mo ago
I've never had this problem. Which OS do you run?
embedding-shape•1mo ago
That's not normal, and certainly not a typical reason people avoid Firefox. Have you given it a try and investigated if this is solvable? Sounds like one of those issues that if you ignore, it'll just pop up elsewhere with some other program.
Tempest1981•1mo ago
DANmode•1mo ago
So, unsurprising.