Ask HN: Why Do People Prefer YouTube Videos over Big-Budget Movies and TV Shows?

9•Gtex555•1mo ago

I understand the basic arguments—YouTube’s rise in short-form content, faster dopamine hits, and lower expectations placed on creators. But even if we set short-form content aside, the contradiction still stands. You’ll find people calling the new Avatar movie boring, even if they pirated it and watched it for free, while those same people will happily spend hours watching livestreams where someone reacts to content or talks about nothing in particular, day after day, for an entire year. How can Avatar be dismissed as boring, yet that kind of content is considered engaging? I would understand if it was a Wikipedia like scenario were all those hours of User generated content just lead to better quality content being produced by process of selection but that isn't really the case with youtube.

Comments

baubino•1mo ago

On youtube, people are watching other people’s lives, often in place of living their own fully. I don’t think it’s a matter of big-budget movie vs youtube, but of fiction vs reality content. The general public isn’t interested in fictional stories anymore; they’re interested in something that seems like real life (even if that “reality” is as fictionalized as a big budget movie).

Gtex555•1mo ago

Interesting, your point kind of reminds me of the reality TV boom.

spudlyo•1mo ago

I can't speak to everyone's motivation, but for me YouTube, and only YouTube has the kind of fascinating niche content that I want to watch. Often that content is created by random people who have a passion and zero profit motive, which makes it more authentic and charming. Sometimes it's an elderly Mexican grandmother explaining how she makes Chilaquiles[0], or maybe it's someone explaining why the Great Reform Act of 1832 was necessary[1], or perhaps it's a professor doing a deep-dive the history of the Vulgate and the life of Jerome[2], or maybe it's a YouTube series[3] that dives into a huge rabbit-hole (pun intended) on restoring a weird 1980s minicomputer -- whatever interests you that moment, someone is likely passionate and knowledgeable about it, and has made a video on it.

[0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mQx1zzBpuU

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_9PGNHd5Zs

[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EF98_HnYHjQ

[3]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DJ1HwuYBuss&list=PLnw98JPyOb...

mmcdermott•1mo ago

This is the big one for me. I have no inherent problem with bigger budget stuff, but it is seldom about the things that interest me.

Gtex555•1mo ago

This I can understand and if you look at the body of my post I talk about understanding if youtube was a selector of quality content, but people will watch hours of slop on youtube that is neither authentic or niche and that's what I want to get to the heart of. I fall victim to this too, I watch hours of youtube (long form) which in retrospect I accept as garbage, but will refuse to watch the the new hot netflix show that cost 100 million with some of the top writers and actors in the world, that's what I'm trying to understand.

spudlyo•1mo ago

I'm not as sure as you are that people are watching hours and hours of slop every day -- I feel like there are still plenty of humans out there trying to make a buck and getting their egos stroked by creating rage-bait for the normies. The algorithm is also pretty good at surfacing this dreck and keeping people watching. You know the sharpest minds at Google are hard at work making this happen.

zalah•1mo ago

>day after day, for an entire year.

That’s the answer. The creator, other creators they have interacted with and their friends, they become your (para) friends too. Almost like comparing big-budget vacation with a random person vs hanging with people you dear.

Gtex555•1mo ago

Fair, but people will watch a random youtuber doing a video essay for the first time on an old topic like sbmm or AI in games and enjoy it yet find a 500 million dollar movie boring. I feel that your answer it correct, but there is something deeper than just para friendships to explain these other cases and I'm guilty of it too (watching a random youtubers video essay).

zalah•1mo ago

I see where you're coming from. Interested in verifying indeed it's something deeper. Leaning towards that it isn't, like there's nothing deep in debating sweet food vs salty food; sometimes you crave one and despise the other but not 7 days a week.

Bad_Initialism•1mo ago

Because big-budget films and TV are increasingly fascist. They focus on the nuclear family as being qualitatively and quantitatively more important than anything else. Within that context, the plot inevitably seeks to establish the absolute uniqueness and superiority of the individual. Superhero stories are an extremely good fit for this narrative.

Deep down, we all know that having a family is exactly as great a biological accomplishment as taking a nice shit in the morning. Dad came; mom squeezed one out. Lampreys and slugs do basically the same thing just as successfully. It's not special. We are not special. Movies and TV push the lie that we are, and we recognize the lie and we have begun to resent it and to be unable to suspend our disbelief.

Youtube is enormously better because it discards the lie. It's just some dude earnestly trying to figure out why a plane crashed or how to run Doom on a smart toilet. It's refreshing because it's real. It's interesting because it's real and it doesn't alienate us by spending all its time trying to shove the big lie down our throats.

ffuxlpff•1mo ago

Never seen any of Avatars but I see nothing that would interest me. I've understood they're stories about some imaginary creatures. Why should I care?

The best in YouTube are probably classical music master classes that give you an incredible insight on music. No hope seeing anything like that on television. Instructional videos are good too. Like installing stuff on computer and fixing bicycles.

Personally I never watch anyone speaking. Seeing a talking face somehow creeps me. Maybe its a bit sensitive but I see watching anyone eye to eye as a game of social dominance.

Is the Detachment in the Room? – Agents, Cruelty, and Empathy

The purpose of Continuous Integration is to fail

Apfelstrudel: Live coding music environment with AI agent chat

What Is Stoicism?

What happens when a neighborhood is built around a farm

Every major galaxy is speeding away from the Milky Way, except one

Extreme Inequality Presages the Revolt Against It

There's no such thing as "tech" (Ten years later)

What Really Killed Flash Player: A Six-Year Campaign of Deliberate Platform Work

Ask HN: Anyone orchestrating multiple AI coding agents in parallel?

Show HN: Knowledge-Bank

Show HN: The Codeverse Hub Linux

Take a trip to Japan's Dododo Land, the most irritating place on Earth

British drivers over 70 to face eye tests every three years

BookTalk: A Reading Companion That Captures Your Voice

Is AI "good" yet? – tracking HN's sentiment on AI coding

Show HN: Amdb – Tree-sitter based memory for AI agents (Rust)

OpenClaw Partners with VirusTotal for Skill Security

Show HN: Seedance 2.0 Release

Leisure Suit Larry's Al Lowe on model trains, funny deaths and Disney

Towards Self-Driving Codebases

VCF West: Whirlwind Software Restoration – Guy Fedorkow [video]

Show HN: COGext – A minimalist, open-source system monitor for Chrome (<550KB)

FOSDEM 26 – My Hallway Track Takeaways

Show HN: Env-shelf – Open-source desktop app to manage .env files

Show HN: Almostnode – Run Node.js, Next.js, and Express in the Browser

Dell support (and hardware) is so bad, I almost sued them

Project Pterodactyl: Incremental Architecture

Styling: Search-Text and Other Highlight-Y Pseudo-Elements

Crypto firm accidentally sends $40B in Bitcoin to users

Is the Detachment in the Room? – Agents, Cruelty, and Empathy

The purpose of Continuous Integration is to fail

Apfelstrudel: Live coding music environment with AI agent chat

What Is Stoicism?

What happens when a neighborhood is built around a farm

Every major galaxy is speeding away from the Milky Way, except one

Extreme Inequality Presages the Revolt Against It

There's no such thing as "tech" (Ten years later)

What Really Killed Flash Player: A Six-Year Campaign of Deliberate Platform Work

Ask HN: Anyone orchestrating multiple AI coding agents in parallel?

Show HN: Knowledge-Bank

Show HN: The Codeverse Hub Linux

Take a trip to Japan's Dododo Land, the most irritating place on Earth

British drivers over 70 to face eye tests every three years

BookTalk: A Reading Companion That Captures Your Voice

Is AI "good" yet? – tracking HN's sentiment on AI coding

Show HN: Amdb – Tree-sitter based memory for AI agents (Rust)

OpenClaw Partners with VirusTotal for Skill Security

Show HN: Seedance 2.0 Release

Leisure Suit Larry's Al Lowe on model trains, funny deaths and Disney

Towards Self-Driving Codebases

VCF West: Whirlwind Software Restoration – Guy Fedorkow [video]

Show HN: COGext – A minimalist, open-source system monitor for Chrome (<550KB)

FOSDEM 26 – My Hallway Track Takeaways

Show HN: Env-shelf – Open-source desktop app to manage .env files

Show HN: Almostnode – Run Node.js, Next.js, and Express in the Browser

Dell support (and hardware) is so bad, I almost sued them

Project Pterodactyl: Incremental Architecture

Styling: Search-Text and Other Highlight-Y Pseudo-Elements

Crypto firm accidentally sends $40B in Bitcoin to users

Ask HN: Why Do People Prefer YouTube Videos over Big-Budget Movies and TV Shows?

Comments