The Constitution Was a Coup

https://lucasvance.github.io/2100/coup/

13•sirponm•1mo ago

Comments

erichocean•1mo ago

The Federalist Constitution (as we now accept it) wasn't accepted until two years later, after the concession to the Anti-Federalists with the Bill of Rights.

(Ironically, the Bill of Rights is what Americans today cherish most.)

Point is, our system of government today was negotiated by the people and the States and can't reasonably be called a "coup."

compsciphd•1mo ago

and the idea being that the bill of rights was only supposed to limit the federal government (i.e. "concession to the anti-federalists") and not the states themselves. It's only incorporation under the 14th amendment that made them applicable to the states and it wasn't particularly clear from the 14th itself that this applied to all.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorporation_of_the_Bill_of_R...

OgsyedIE•1mo ago

This narrative omits the strong, repeated and extensively documented disagreements between the colonists and Britain on whether or not to launch expansionist wars of conquest against the neighbouring American Indian polities.

polotics•1mo ago

interesting, were the colonists the expansionist ones?

OgsyedIE•1mo ago

Yes, with strong religious and historically early ethnonationalist motivations, including against denominations of European colonists who weren't English-speaking, while the British opposition was largely motivated by pragmatic diplomatic efforts to avoid large wars, expenses or both. Taylor's book American Revolutions is a great starting point for the period (with depth exceeding the typical ACOUP article) and the bibliography delivers plenty of follow-up material by topic and/or place.

paulddraper•1mo ago

This glosses over one very important point: the Constitution was ratified by every State.

It was a change in government to be sure, but a coup is the wrong word. Or at least an extreme exaggeration.

A coup replaces the rulers suddenly; no such event happened.

First, the overwhelming majority (42/55) of the Convention delegates were part of the existing government. Any resistance was on the actual terms of the Constitution not who was taking over. In fact, the first President was elected unanimously.

Second, the Convention plus ratification by three-fourths took over a year.

Show HN: One-click AI employee with its own cloud desktop

Show HN: Poddley – Search podcasts by who's speaking

Same Surface, Different Weight

The Rise of Spec Driven Development

The first good Raspberry Pi Laptop

Seas to Rise Around the World – But Not in Greenland

Will Future Generations Think We're Gross?

State Department will delete Xitter posts from before Trump returned to office

Show HN: Verifiable server roundtrip demo for a decision interruption system

Impl Rust – Avro IDL Tool in Rust via Antlr

Stories from 25 Years of Software Development

minikeyvalue

Neomacs: GPU-accelerated Emacs with inline video, WebKit, and terminal via wgpu

Show HN: Moli P2P – An ephemeral, serverless image gallery (Rust and WebRTC)

How I grow my X presence?

What's the cost of the most expensive Super Bowl ad slot?

What if you just did a startup instead?

Hacking up your own shell completion (2020)

Show HN: Gorse 0.5 – Open-source recommender system with visual workflow editor

GLM-OCR: Accurate × Fast × Comprehensive

Local Agent Bench: Test 11 small LLMs on tool-calling judgment, on CPU, no GPU

Show HN: AboutMyProject – A public log for developer proof-of-work

Expertise, AI and Work of Future [video]

So Long to Cheap Books You Could Fit in Your Pocket

PID Controller

SpaceX Rocket Generates 100GW of Power, or 20% of US Electricity

Kubernetes MCP Server

I Built a Movie Recommendation Agent to Solve Movie Nights with My Wife

What were the first animals? The fierce sponge–jelly battle that just won't end

Sidestepping Evaluation Awareness and Anticipating Misalignment