frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Incident with Multple GitHub Services

https://www.githubstatus.com/incidents/myrbk7jvvs6p
79•bwannasek•1h ago

Comments

supakeen•1h ago
I mean; this is the normal mode of operation for GitHub at this point.
napolux•1h ago
0 nines.
causal•1h ago
9 nines found somewhere after the decimal point if you measure with enough precision
argee•1h ago
I moved to Gitlab a while ago. It's a whole new level of freedom not having to pay for self-hosted CI runners.
cjonas•1h ago
It would be wild if they dropped below the "two 9's" metric. I think they would need an additional ~16hr of outage in the 90 day rolling period.
waiwai933•1h ago
https://mrshu.github.io/github-statuses/ suggests that their combined uptime doesn't even meet 1 nine, let alone 2.
cjonas•1h ago
ya i was just doing the math on their chart for the git operations. I added up 14.93 hours combined hours, which puts them WAY lower than the reported 99.7 metric they show right next to it.

So based on their own reporting, the uptime number should be 99.31. Which means only like 6 additional hours and they'd fall below 99.0%

cjonas•55m ago
also I never had considered that breaking your up-time into a bunch of different components is just a strategy to make your SRE look better than it actually is. The combined up-time tells the real story (88%!). Thanks for the link
femiagbabiaka•45m ago
The number of nines assigned to a suite of services is not indicative of the quality of SRE at any given company, but rather a reflection of the tradeoffs a business has decided to make. Guaranteed there's a dashboard somewhere at Github looking at platform stickiness vs. reliability and deciding how hard to let teams push on various initiatives.
CamouflagedKiwi•19m ago
The intersection of uptime across every possible service they offer isn't a particularly great metric. I get the point that they are doing badly, but it makes it look worse than I think it really is.

What I would like to see is a combined uptime for "code services", basically Git+Webhooks+API+Issues+PRs, which corresponds to a set of user workflows that really should be their bread & butter, without highlighting things you might not care about (Codespaces, Copilot).

fishgoesblub•1h ago
At this point it'll be better to have alerts for when GitHub is online, rather than offline.
josefritzishere•1h ago
Microslop is destroying Github
AnkerSkallebank•1h ago
Some of my jobs are completing, some are failing. Seems to be random. Kind of wish they would just fail outright, instead of running for 10 minutes and then failing.
ossa-ma•1h ago
Seems like outages are increasingly more frequent nowadays. Obviously, this is not the best state of affairs, and developers should not be limited by services. In the meantime I've been experimenting with building third spaces for people to chill while they wait for the services they are dependent on to go back up.

The first one I've built is a little ASCII hangout for Claude @ https://clawdpenguin.com but threads like this make me want to build it for Github too.

0xbadcafebee•1h ago
I am this > < close to just running Gogs or Forgejo on some Hetzner boxes, quit my job, charge people for access. Why aren't there like 10 startups doing this yet? Please? I want to give you my money. Just give me a git host that doesn't suck. (All the current ones suck)
linhns•1h ago
Business as usual.
ChrisArchitect•1h ago
Multple 9s
embedding-shape•1h ago
I've been on a somewhat binge to move a bunch of stuff to self-hosting at home. Yesterday I finally completed my self-hosted Forgejo instance at home, together with Linux, Windows (via VM) and macOS (via Mac Mini) runners/workers for CI/CD, so everything finally lives in-house (literally), instead of all source code + Actions being on GitHub but the infrastructure actually living locally.

This is probably the first time I felt vindicated with my self-hosting move literally the day after I finished the migration, very pleasant feeling. Usually it takes a month or two before I get here.

shevy-java•56m ago
Interesting. I speculated not long ago that Microsoft is really taking a dive here, and other companies may look to provide better alternatives to GitHub, as one idea. Today I read your comment about self-hosting here; while that is not quite what I compared or had in mind, it is interesting to read about it, of people who go that route. Microsoft is really putting themselves into trouble in the last year or two. Some things no longer work, so much is clear here.
yakattak•51m ago
I moved my forge to my home, outside of a little stress getting all the containers wrangled it was pretty effortless to setup Forgejo.

I do need a good backup solution though, that’s one thing I’m missing.

lisplist•45m ago
The only problem I've found with Forgejo is a lack of fine grained permissions and also the lack of an API for pulling action invocations. The actions log api endpoints are present in gitea from what I can tell.
mfenniak•23m ago
Forgejo 15 was just released last week with repo-specific access tokens. More to come in the future.
cedws•42m ago
The idea of a homelab is appealing to me, but then I actually start building one and get tired of it quickly. When I’ve been fixing broken systems at work all day I don’t really want to have to be my own sysadmin too.

I’ve got a nice and powerful Minisforum on my desk that I bought at Christmas not even switched on.

embedding-shape•33m ago
I've tried for 15 years to have my homelab, but always get lost in the complexity after a year or so, in the past. About 3 years ago I gave NixOS a try instead for managing everything, which suddenly made everything easier (counter-intuitively perhaps) as now I can come back after months and still understand where everything is and how it works after just reading.

Setting up Forgejo + runners declaratively is probably ~100 lines in total, and doesn't matter I forget how it works, just have to spend five minutes reading to catch up after I come back in 6 months to change/fix something.

I think the trick to avoid getting tired of it is trying to just make it as simple as humanly possible. The less stuff you have, the easier it gets, at least that's intuitive :)

cedws•6m ago
Thanks. Yeah, I've probably been overcomplicating it before. I was running Kubernetes on Talos thinking that at least it would be familiar. Such power tools for running simple workloads on a single node is inviting headaches.
neilv•31m ago
I self-host Forgejo for personal and indie-startup purposes, and like it well enough.

The downside with that is it misses one of the key purposes of GitHub: posturing for job-hunting/hopping. It's another performative checkbox, like memorizing Leetcode and practicing delivery for brogrammer interviews.

If you don't appear active on GitHub specifically (not even Codeberg, GitLab, nor something else), you're going to get dismissed from a lot of job applications, with "do you even lift, bro" style dissing, from people who have very simple conceptions of what software engineers do, and why.

johnmaguire•27m ago
There is a fairly straightforward feature in Forgejo to sync your repos to Github, if that's what you want to do. It's not perfect, of course, but should help to advertise your projects and keep your activity heatmap green.

I mostly use Forgejo for my private repos, which are free at Github, but with many limitations. One month I burned all my private CI tokens on the 1st due to a hung Mac runner. Love not having to worry about this now!

gill-bates•24m ago
I get that. To counter it I usually try to have at least one public repo on my Forgejo instance and link to that on my resume/LinkedIn. It helps that I'm angling for security/infra positions so the self-hosting aspect actually helps but even without that I would imagine it signals something. Maybe not ideal for the most mainstream jobs (whatever that even means...), but I suspect some people will be intrigued by the initiative.

Edit: to the "do you even lift bro", the response becomes "yeah man, I've built my own gym - oh, you go to Planet Fitness? Good luck."

8cvor6j844qw_d6•14m ago
> If you don't appear active on GitHub specifically... you're going to get dismissed from a lot of job applications

Sometimes wonder if my coursemates back in the days, who automated commits to private repos just to keep the green box packed, actually got any mileage out of it.

johnmaguire•28m ago
I recently did this as well and one of the things that has struck me is just how fast Actions are compared to Github!

That said, I've got Linux and macOS setup with a Mac Mini (using a Claude-generated Ansible task file), but configuring a Windows VM seemed a bit painful. You didn't happen to find anything to simplify the deployment process here, did you?

colechristensen•7m ago
Instability aside I found several things about GitHub awkward, annoying, or missing features so I spent a month building my own. I think we're going to be seeing a lot more of this.
rvz•3m ago
Self hosting was the correct solution.

6 years early [0] and you have better uptime than GitHub.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22867803

dankobgd•1h ago
Don't worry, status page says that it's 100% working - green color, all good. even though i can't access a static page
surya2006•58m ago
what are the good alternatives available for github i find some alternative but as long as widely people use github i cant use other service right like i cant share my alternative to other developer and force him to use this for me. so i feel like i locked in even i want to move i can't
embedding-shape•55m ago
Huh? Why not? Say "My git repository is here $URL" then if they want to visit and/or clone it, they'll do that, otherwise don't, why does it matter?

Sure, if you're out after reaching the most people, gaining stars or otherwise try to attract "popularity" rather than just sharing and collaborate on code, then I'd understand what you mean. But then I'd begin with questioning your motivation first, that'll be a deeper issue than what SCM platform you use.

shevy-java•57m ago
Microsoft again.

I think it is time that Microsoft lets go of GitHub. They are handling it too poorly.

surya2006•57m ago
even vercel also have more downtime nowadays
buildbot•55m ago
Anyone also seeing Active Directory/Entra issues?
throwatdem12311•54m ago
Seems like they just can’t deal with the absolute deluge of AI vomit being uploaded every day.

Good riddance I hope it completely destroys them.

mijoharas•39m ago
Are you taking about what they write to run the service? Because looking at the uptime, and considering it's Microslop, I wouldn't be surprised.
LorenDB•53m ago
https://mrshu.github.io/github-statuses/ says they are down to 88.15% uptime. Even when you consider uptime of individual components, their best is 99.78%, so two nines.
tomjen3•41m ago
At this point it should almost be news when it works.
jasoncartwright•40m ago
Just cancelled my GitHub Copilot Pro+ year subscription. Removal of Opus 4.6 stung, but the repeated continued downtime makes it unusable for me. Very disappointed.

No fuss instant refund of my unused subscription (£160) appreciated.

miltonlaxer•36m ago
What will you use now?
jasoncartwright•34m ago
Claude Code
tgrowazay•31m ago
Doesn’t GitHub Copilot Pro+ only have month-to-month payment option?

Only Pro (without plus) can be paid annually for some reason.

jasoncartwright•25m ago
I paid 390 USD for a year Pro+ subscription in November 2025.

I used all the 'Premium Requests' every month on (mainly) Opus 4.5 & 4.6. From what I've read on here it seems I was probably a rather unprofitable customer - it felt like a steal.

bakies•38m ago
I definitely have better uptime hosting my own gitea instance. It's faster too. It's basically a knock off GitHub. Plus with privacy concerns, I'm just happier overall. Easy setup, all I did was deploy the helm chart.
CamouflagedKiwi•22m ago
I wondered. We'd seen for most of today that Actions were slow to trigger, I had at least one that was just missed, it felt like something was definitely off but the status was green all day until this.

GPT-5.5 Bio Bug Bounty

https://openai.com/index/gpt-5-5-bio-bug-bounty/
2•ilreb•51s ago•0 comments

India to tackle global obesity with cheap fat-loss jabs

https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20260320-india-to-tackle-global-obesity-with-cheap-fat-loss...
1•PaulHoule•1m ago•0 comments

Introducing GPT-5.5

https://openai.com/index/introducing-gpt-5-5/
9•rd•1m ago•0 comments

The Ancient Roots of the Crab Walk

https://nautil.us/the-ancient-roots-of-the-crab-walk-1280144
1•Brajeshwar•1m ago•0 comments

YouTuber has DIMM idea, builds working DRAM in backyard

https://www.theregister.com/2026/04/23/youtuber_builds_working_dram/
1•omer_k•2m ago•0 comments

This Robot can beat you at table tennis [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EH8kZDc7OLk
1•mhb•2m ago•0 comments

Why IBM Turned to Microsoft for Basic

https://nemanjatrifunovic.substack.com/p/why-ibm-turned-to-microsoft-for-basic
1•rbanffy•2m ago•0 comments

Apple Bandai Pippin: That time Apple made a game console

https://www.xda-developers.com/apple-bandai-pippin-history/
1•rbanffy•3m ago•0 comments

Life Beyond Biosignatures: A New Method in the Search for Life

https://www.universetoday.com/articles/life-beyond-biosignatures-a-new-method-in-the-search-for-life
1•rbanffy•3m ago•0 comments

UAE to be the first government to operate through autonomous systems

https://twitter.com/HHShkMohd/status/2047277766769545352
1•bko•7m ago•0 comments

The Content Management System Is Dead. Long Live the Context Management System

https://www.hackshackers.com/cms-is-dead-long-live-the-context-management-system/
2•ZacnyLos•7m ago•0 comments

Kemal – Fast, Effective, Simple Web Framework for Crystal

https://kemalcr.com/
1•thunderbong•9m ago•0 comments

The "agentic spectrum" is a category error

https://marklubin.me/posts/bounding-agency/
1•mlubin01•9m ago•1 comments

Ubuntu 26.04 ("Resolute Raccoon") LTS released

https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/ubuntu-26-04-resolute-raccoon-lts-released/80833
2•guilherme-puida•10m ago•0 comments

Onyx Pro, a local desktop utility for re-evaluating AI IDEs

https://getonyxpro.com
1•ChloeVPin•11m ago•1 comments

Ghostscope: DWARF-aware eBPF tracer for source-level userspace tracing

https://github.com/swananan/ghostscope
2•tanelpoder•13m ago•0 comments

An update on recent Claude Code quality reports

https://www.anthropic.com/engineering/april-23-postmortem
29•mfiguiere•14m ago•8 comments

Andrew Kelley live coding stream – changes to Zig's build system and Q&A

https://mastodon.social/@andrewrk/116455170889340599
3•emigre•15m ago•0 comments

GitHub Ace - an Experimental Collaboraite Agentic Coding Environment

https://maggieappleton.com/zero-alignment
2•jryio•16m ago•0 comments

Law grad employment hit record high again in 2025, ABA data shows

https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/law-grad-employment-hit-record-high-again-2025-aba-data-...
1•1vuio0pswjnm7•16m ago•1 comments

Meta Tells Staff It Will Cut 10% of Jobs in Push for Efficiency

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-04-23/meta-tells-staff-it-will-cut-10-of-jobs-in-pus...
7•sinemetu11•17m ago•2 comments

Microsoft brings Xbox back, scraps Microsoft Gaming

https://www.theverge.com/report/917485/microsoft-return-of-xbox-no-more-microsoft-gaming
2•omer_k•18m ago•0 comments

Show HN: God.ad – Real-time BGP routing data and DNS/IP lookups

https://god.ad/
1•afshari•19m ago•0 comments

Show HN: mls-go – pure Go implementation of RFC 9420 (MLS)

https://github.com/thomas-vilte/mls-go
1•tomasvilte•19m ago•1 comments

Older and Wiser: How Elder Animals Help Species to Survive

https://e360.yale.edu/features/longevity-conservation
2•Brajeshwar•19m ago•0 comments

Built for a Hostile Internet: Canonical VP of Engineering on Ubuntu 26.04 LTS

https://www.zdnet.com/article/built-for-a-hostile-internet-canonical-vp-of-engineering-on-ubuntu-...
1•CrankyBear•20m ago•0 comments

ParaRNN: Large-Scale Nonlinear RNNs, Trainable in Parallel

https://machinelearning.apple.com/research/large-scale-rnns
1•2bit•21m ago•0 comments

Recall – Local-first semantic search over Gmail, Drive, Canvas, Notion, and more

https://github.com/aayu22809/Recall
1•patel_aayushya•24m ago•1 comments

Canton vs. Public Crypto: A Technical Comparison

https://eric.mann.blog/canton-vs-public-crypto/
2•eamann•25m ago•0 comments

Your RAG Pipeline has no brakes

https://medium.com/open-source-journal/your-rag-pipeline-has-no-brakes-cf946894b85a
1•iwantchips•25m ago•0 comments