What's the downside of open-sourcing this?
We should commend bureaucracies on the rare instance that they open-source their software, not ridicule them for it.
Let’s zoom in on your reply, the people who are interested and look at it and use it. What will they be able to do with it?
e.g. Right now the UK grid is running on just over 80%+ renewable. But when the wind isn't cooperating french nuclear helps.
Broad reliance on renewables just doesn't work without interconnects across large geo regions
The repo linked “seeks to complement the tools currently used in the TYNDP cycles, especially for Scenario Building (SB) and Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA). This approach is designed to enhance transparency and lower barriers to stakeholder participation in European energy planning. Beyond Europe, the project aspires to demonstrate the viability of open-source (OS) frameworks in energy planning, encouraging broader global adoption.
To build trust in and ensure reproducibility with the new open-source toolchain, the project first focuses on replicating key figures from the 2024 TYNDP cycle, before aligning with the current 2026 TYNDP cycle. This process involves developing new features within the open-source domain to address existing gaps, integrating tools for data interoperability and dynamic visualizations, and publishing best practices to encourage the adoption of open energy models.”
Why this report is shared appears to be an application of PyPSA for others to reference and become inspired by its implementation.
Why it’s open source I think is clear from the above paragraph. Open source standards make it drastically easier to harmonise and collaborate while allowing as much engagement as possible to scrutinise the framework.
12345ieee•1h ago
Someday we'll get there, someday.
hokkos•1h ago
lyoncy•1h ago
bcye•59m ago
Phelinofist•50m ago
greenleafone7•46m ago
davorak•33m ago
I guess if the github UI becomes critical to their continued development or PR then they expose themselves to a potential rug pull by github/microsoft.
I do not know much about the project so I can not tell if that is concern or if there is some other concern at play here or if those concerns apply to this project or not.
Those are the types of details I wanted to see in the comment.
pvitz•59m ago
raverbashing•41m ago
dopidopHN2•30m ago
The moat on that is non existant.
gmueckl•12m ago
nicexe•28m ago
based2•23m ago
https://code.europa.eu/info/about
https://code.europa.eu/explore/projects/active