I was reading this version of RE4B: https://github.com/Cactus-proj/RE-for-Beginners/releases/tag/v1.0.0

The section about std::string (3.21.4) claims that the MSVC implementation of std::string looks like this:

  struct std_string
  {
      size_t unk1;
      union
      {
          char buf[16];
          char *ptr;
      } u;

      size_t size;     // Mysize
      size_t capacity; // Myres
  };

However this structure is 24 bytes in 32 bit and 32 bytes in 64 bit. Meanwhile the current MSVC std::string is 28 bytes in 32 bit and 40 bytes in 64 bit.

I noticed that the book's implementation is exactly 1 size_t short, so i tried adding a size_t to the top of the struct, and it worked perfectly, as in this dump function now outputs correctly:

#include <string> #include <stdio.h>

struct std_string { union { char buf[16]; char ptr; } u;

    size_t size;     // Mysize
    size_t capacity; // Myres

};

void dump_std_string(std::string s) { struct std_string p = (struct std_string *)&s; printf("[%s] size:%d capacity:%d\n", p->size > 16 ? p->u.ptr : p->u.buf, p->size, p->capacity); }; int main() { printf("sizeof std string: %d\nours: %d\n\n", sizeof(std::string), sizeof(struct std_string));

    std::string s1 = "a short string";
    std::string s2 = "a string longer than 16 bytes";
    dump_std_string(s1);
    dump_std_string(s2);

};

What has changed and what is that size_t that is now before the string buffer ? Is it some kind of reference counter ?

Karl Deisseroth awarded 2026 Nobel Prize in physiology or medicine

People are asking ChatGPT to help them decide how to vote in the midterms

I built a $5/month TV app because I got tired of how expensive streaming is

Meta Rushed to Fix Muse 'VM Escape' Vulnerability Soon Before Launch

Smart glasses under scrutiny as Norway seeks temporary ban

Altman: The world should accept some bad things happening for the benefits of AI

Writing Extensions in Sliver C2

The Forget() Function: Erasing Data Without Breaking Your Audit Trail

From v0.7 to v0.8: How group commit changed Turso's tail latency

Mining Unwritten Data for AI's Edge

The Double Headed Stack Allocator

Are your AI evals measuring the right things?

Cull Lumber at Menards

L5 Cyber Cafe at Processing Community Day NYC

AgentLedger – a spend cap that refuses the call before it happens

A Letter for You, Dad

Show HN: Cachetoast

Rivet - Shared development workflow for teams and their coding agents

Commodified Intelligence

North 2

When the pentester is a fleet of AI agents: inside an autonomous vuln-hunting

As robotaxi accidents increase in L.A., the data reveal the safer driver

Mosquitoes Are a Choice

Britain Learned to Love Chinese Cars

NASA-IBM Lunar Foundation Model and fine-tuning code

Discover AI – A Learning Guide

Show HN: DevBoard – a simpler ClickUp for small dev teams, native apps and MCP

What changed in MSVC's implementation of std:string from the 2022 copy of RE4B?

Anthropic Filed the Most Alarming Risk Disclosure in IPO History

Lazy Websites

Show HN: EtherPK – an Obsidian and Logseq alternative with prose and blocks