frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

SynthID Detector

https://synthid.com/
46•ilreb•1h ago

Comments

latexr•1h ago
Can’t be used without signing in with a Google, Apple, or ChatGPT account.
giancarlostoro•50m ago
Also it can't detect any Synths in The Commonwealth.
Tiberium•49m ago
It's baffling that this requires auth. OpenAI's own tool (https://openai.com/research/verify/) doesn't require auth.

Even Google themselves previously offered a no-auth way (just very niche): if you uploaded an image to Google Image search, and went to "About this image", it would show if the image was Google AI-generated. Now it doesn't.

lelandfe•47m ago
I've never seen it mentioned anywhere so I will just here complain that Google also removed the ability to paste images into Google Image search some years ago for no apparent reason. It worked great and I used it all the time.
RugnirViking•41m ago
this + image translate with copy+paste is the only reason I ever use yandex of all places...
bossyTeacher•26m ago
I might be missing something but Google Image Search still works for me.
dannyw•17m ago
I wonder if it’s a deliberate anti-user decision to get more URLs and less pasted images.

URLs expand Googlebot’s indexes; pasted images don’t.

mh-•15m ago
Click the little camera icon in the search box and it pops a modal that says Search any image with Google Lens.

The textbox below it says Paste image link, but you can actually paste an image from your clipboard here, too.

lelandfe•14m ago
You’re a hero. So glad I complained. Why would they not just keep this working with the main text box focused…
mh-•12m ago
No idea. I used it a lot too, not sure if pasting here worked from the beginning of them introducing this Google Lens thing or not.
apefulsin•40m ago
Any access to a watermark detector can be used to remove the watermark. Presumably they want to be able to track who is doing that.
brokensegue•38m ago
Yeah I've been wanting to run a ton of Wikipedia images through the detector to see if fakes snuck in. Doesn't seem to be a practical way to do this. Even Open AIs tool has a low rate limit
wodenokoto•28m ago
The EULA you have to accept hints that they are afraid you are going to abuse it to remove synthID - e.g, set up and edit and check loop
dannyw•12m ago
That’s the justification, but the EULA incorporates Google’s regular consumer terms; which means what you upload can also be used for advertising and targeting; and basically any purpose whatsoever by Google.
possibilistic•27m ago
These are "spy"marks, not watermarks:

https://brand.io/article/spymarks/

We need to inform everyone that this technology can encode database identifiers and enough entropy to uniquely identify you as an author (or downloader).

This extends to other forms of media as well.

cubefox•8m ago
They are not spymarks if they don't encode any personal IDs and are merely used to indicate that an image was AI-generated. I don't think Google or OpenAI use SynthID to include personal data.
morkalork•3m ago
And there lies the rub. You can't verify if they do or don't embed such content. These companies are just like "trust me bro".
Retr0id•21m ago
It's presumably so they can rate-limit people who are trying to reverse-engineer or otherwise strip it (e.g. iteratively tweaking until it stops getting detected)
user43928•3m ago
I wonder how relevant this really is.

How hard can it be to download a set of real images and generated ones in order to train a model to detect and strip the watermark with minimal perceptual difference?

pbronez•37m ago
This is a Google Deepmind project to “Identify AI generated media”

More detail at https://deepmind.google/models/synthid/

For those who, like me, were hoping it was a vision model to identify synthesizer models from photos of concerts and music studios!

jakozaur•35m ago
I worry we’ll have to approach this the other way around: verify that photos came from a camera, using hardware support like Apple’s Reference Image, rather than try to detect every AI generated one.

In many situations, photos are evidence. AI tools make convincing fakes, such as images of defect product.

sha-3•34m ago
No option to detect generated text. SynthID also watermarks text, right?
nonethewiser•6m ago
Thats what I was expecting. I thought so.
tosh•29m ago
is this by Google?
spuz•24m ago
Yes but OpenAI, NVIDIA, Kakao, Apple have said they will also implement SynthID
nialv7•29m ago
Why the hell do I need to sign in?
Retr0id•16m ago
It's a real shame Google isn't more transparent about how it actually works, and doesn't provide any mechanism for classifying images in bulk or offline.

This is the best SynthID write-up I've found so far: https://fyx.me/articles/attempting-model-extraction-of-googl...

It covers how it actually works (probably), and how to train your own classifier for it, with some seemingly decent results.

MisterMunchkin•8m ago
They don't want you to know, because they're the baddies. Imagine how much money they can get from advertisers if they're able to identify every single piece of code, reddit thread, email, GitHub readme that you've ever written based on your secret ID. They're creaming themselves just thinking about it.

"Excellent work acquiring that outlook data Anat, now let's cross check the defunct company emails against YouTube videos edited with Google PrivateEditAI™ to figure out what the social security number of this YouTube account is."

Avicebron•3m ago
Unfortunately this is the truth, no one can be given a benefit of the doubt because despite years of good grace they have been anti-user and enshittified everything they touch.
elevation•7m ago
> It's a real shame Google isn't more transparent about how it actually works

> classifying images in bulk or offline

You've described exactly the elements spammers and fraudsters need to be able to defeat this mechanism.

anon48293•16m ago
Hey OpenAi, generate a text of 100 words.

Hey Gemini, find a synonym for every second adjective. Replace in text.

Hey Grok, find a synonym for every third proper noun. Replace in text.

Hey …

MisterMunchkin•6m ago
Ah but that's the genius of the scheme. Every single one of those providers will detect your secret ID and refuse the request. And sneak their own one in for good measure.
m00dy•15m ago
Deepwalker cracked this one long time ago

https://deepwalker.xyz/blog/evaluating-synthid-watermark-rob...

ChrisArchitect•9m ago
(2025)? https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/products/google-synthi...

Or did it just become public

Edit:

Blog post today https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/models-and-research/go...

sarkarghya•9m ago
Here is openai:

https://help.openai.com/en/articles/8912793-provenance-signa...

There is rate limit though

cubefox•7m ago
There is a rate limit of around 10 checks in 24 hours.
jdranczewski•4m ago
Finally, the previous implementations were very silly! OpenAI had a nice tool, but it only detected their own watermarks, and Google's process was "upload the image to Gemini and ask if it's AI generated", which seemed like a perplexing waste of tokens and breath.

(While a sibling comment points out putting the image through Google Image Search as an alternative, I don't remember this being signposted in the support article I've read, so I unfortunately didn't know about it)

Retr0id•5m ago
Well it's not a very good mechanism then, is it.

Across the Globe, People Increasingly Say Social Media Is Harming Democracy

https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2026/10/01/across-the-globe-people-increasingly-say-social-med...
1•karakoram•41s ago•0 comments

Normal Tools – Useful online tools, no nonsense

https://www.normaltools.com/
1•eustoria•1m ago•0 comments

Show HN: One – Post-labor biophysical resource coordination

https://github.com/kyberlex/ONE
1•kyberlex•1m ago•0 comments

Nobel Prize in Chemistry 2026

https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/chemistry/2026/summary/
1•divbzero•3m ago•0 comments

Reverse Engineering of the M-VAVE FM-1 Pocket Synthesizer Firmware

https://github.com/AL-255/FM-1-RE
1•0bytes•4m ago•0 comments

Why Texas Is Making Data Centers Wait

https://www.a16z.news/p/why-texas-is-making-data-centers
1•crescit_eundo•5m ago•0 comments

GitHub Incident with Git Operations, Pull Requests and Actions

https://www.githubstatus.com/incidents/djlmxz2zd0j7
20•gagan2020•6m ago•8 comments

A new AI assistant called Tab has launched; it competes with Meta's Muse

https://techcrunch.com/2026/10/07/another-personal-ai-assistant-has-launched-meet-tab-which-emerg...
1•mikelgan•7m ago•0 comments

GitHub Is Down (Again)

5•Andugal•7m ago•0 comments

Stop asking AI what you should build

https://leoanthias.com/stop-asking-ai/
1•pea•7m ago•0 comments

GitHub Outage: Incident with Git Operations, Pull Requests and Actions

https://www.githubstatus.com/incidents/djlmxz2zd0j7
7•wbnns•8m ago•2 comments

ShinyHunters Extorted Boeing Spin-Off Prior to Arrests

https://krebsonsecurity.com/2026/10/shinyhunters-extorted-boeing-spin-off-prior-to-arrests/
2•speckx•8m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Collision avoidance in industrial robotics using robotsimulator.ai

https://www.babacad.com/robotics/web/
1•comirza•8m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Checkout this open-source, local-first bioinformatics/AI desktop app

https://github.com/Liatir/liatir-app
1•Suffro•9m ago•0 comments

Show HN: Zetteldesk – An MCP server that prints and mails letters

https://zetteldesk.com/en
1•akrost•10m ago•0 comments

Codex Cloud shipped with Tailscale support. Nobody told us

https://tailscale.com/blog/codex-cloud-tailscale
1•mfiguiere•11m ago•0 comments

Zephon: Fast, Flexible, Elastically Deterministic Data Loading

https://www.datologyai.com/blog/zephon
1•mboether•13m ago•0 comments

Visa, Mastercard, Major Banks Facing New Litigation over 'Anticompetitive' Fees

https://www.classaction.org/news/visa-mastercard-major-banks-facing-new-litigation-over-anticompe...
1•DeepLogin•14m ago•0 comments

Reverse Engineering AirPods Self-Calibration

https://ateliti99.substack.com/p/reverse-engineering-airpods-self
1•olirex99•14m ago•0 comments

Why Were Victorian Elites So Effective?

https://worksinprogress.co/issue/the-seven-vices-of-highly-effective-victorians/
3•karakoram•14m ago•0 comments

US: Trump administration Rejects External Election Observers

https://www.hrw.org/news/2026/09/25/us-trump-administration-rejects-external-election-observers
6•mikhael•15m ago•1 comments

How to Assemble Science

https://aeon.co/essays/the-life-saving-scientific-knowledge-hiding-in-plain-sight
1•karakoram•16m ago•0 comments

LLM Running in Factorio

https://github.com/RomOSTiny/factorio-transformer
1•Destiner•18m ago•0 comments

Animated ASCII Art for Web Pages

https://ascii.rest/
2•turrini•18m ago•0 comments

Mumsnet denies using AI for content after prompt appears on message board

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2026/oct/07/mumsnet-denies-using-ai-for-content-message-board-p...
2•ljf•19m ago•0 comments

Building Git infrastructure for agent-scale development

https://github.blog/engineering/architecture-optimization/building-git-infrastructure-for-agent-s...
1•digitallogic•19m ago•3 comments

Show HN: Mecum, open source Mac app that lets agents use ANY desktop software

https://github.com/ForteAI-Org/mecum
4•loriscomba•19m ago•2 comments

We Built an Alternative to Vector RAG for AI Agent Memory

https://www.claix.dev/blog/rag-for-ai-agents-agentic-retrieval
3•gael_dev•21m ago•1 comments

The Nixon Tapes, Unlocked

https://niallferguson.substack.com/p/the-nixon-tapes-unlocked
1•codechicago277•21m ago•0 comments

JengaBot: Pez for Robots

https://thisismypersonalblog.com/posts/2026-10-07-pez-for-robots/
1•systemerror•22m ago•0 comments