I strongly suspect he had far more than 40 videos. The Animal Crush Act states that for videos to be illegal, they must qualify as legally obscene, which means passing all 3 prongs of the Miller Obscenity Test, one of which requires it be sexual in nature. This is why child pornography is illegal despite the 1st Amendment. I believe animal cruelty videos were illegal but the Supreme Court ruled they were protected by the 1st Amendment, so the Animal Crush Act was a compromise since it utilizes the Miller Test, which is already used for 1st Amendment exemptions. That's why the article had to specify "sexual" as that part is essential to proving he broke the law.
These are hundreds of videos, but the overwhelming majority of them are zoosadism. I get the feeling had the guy gotten a lawyer, his lawyer could have gotten him acquitted because if a minority of the torture videos were at the monkey's sexual area, a lawyer can argue these videos just happened to be on the monkey's sexual area and were purely for zoosadism, which makes them legal, as messed up as it is.
What I believe happened is the police bluffed him into a confession; they made him think they could put him away for decades for the hundreds of videos he had but if he confessed, they would only charge him for the 40 sexual videos (the only videos they can charge him with) to make it look like he was getting a good deal when in reality, he was getting nothing. Law enforcement heavily depend on your ignorance of the law; that's why, contrary to popular belief, invoking your 5th and 6th Amendment rights does not make you look suspicious in the eyes of the law; it just means you're well-versed and your goal isn't to convince police you're innocent, it's to keep them from convicting you and the best way to do that is to shut up and lawyer up right away, even if you are innocent and it's the advice lawyers give.
regularuser•54s ago
These are hundreds of videos, but the overwhelming majority of them are zoosadism. I get the feeling had the guy gotten a lawyer, his lawyer could have gotten him acquitted because if a minority of the torture videos were at the monkey's sexual area, a lawyer can argue these videos just happened to be on the monkey's sexual area and were purely for zoosadism, which makes them legal, as messed up as it is.
What I believe happened is the police bluffed him into a confession; they made him think they could put him away for decades for the hundreds of videos he had but if he confessed, they would only charge him for the 40 sexual videos (the only videos they can charge him with) to make it look like he was getting a good deal when in reality, he was getting nothing. Law enforcement heavily depend on your ignorance of the law; that's why, contrary to popular belief, invoking your 5th and 6th Amendment rights does not make you look suspicious in the eyes of the law; it just means you're well-versed and your goal isn't to convince police you're innocent, it's to keep them from convicting you and the best way to do that is to shut up and lawyer up right away, even if you are innocent and it's the advice lawyers give.