Fast(er) regular expression engines in Ruby

https://serpapi.com/blog/faster-regular-expression-engines-in-ruby/

60•davidsojevic•12mo ago

Comments

yxhuvud•11mo ago

Eww, pretending to support utf8 matchers while not supporting them at all was not pretty to see.

gitroom•11mo ago

Honestly that part bugs me, fake support is worse than no support imo

kayodelycaon•11mo ago

> Another nuance was found in ruby, which cannot scan the haystack with invalid UTF-8 byte sequences.

This is extremely basic ruby: UTF-8 encoded strings must be valid UTF-8. This is not unique to ruby. If I recall correctly, python 3 does the same thing.

    2.7.1 :001 > haystack = "\xfc\xa1\xa1\xa1\xa1\xa1abc"
    2.7.1 :003 > haystack.force_encoding "ASCII-8BIT"
    => "\xFC\xA1\xA1\xA1\xA1\xA1abc" 
    2.7.1 :004 > haystack.scan(/.+/)
    => ["\xFC\xA1\xA1\xA1\xA1\xA1abc"]

This person is a senior engineer on their Team page. All they had to do was google "ArgumentError: invalid byte sequence in UTF-8". Or ask a coworker... the company has Ruby on Rails applications. headdesk

burntsushi•11mo ago

The nuance is specifically relevant here because neither of the other two regex engines benchmarked have this requirement. It's doubly relevant because that means running a regex search doesn't require a UTF-8 validation step, and is therefore likely beneficial from a perf perspective, dependening on the workload.

kayodelycaon•11mo ago

That’s a good point. I hadn’t considered it because I’ve hit the validation error long before getting to search. It is possible to avoid string operations with careful coding prior to the search.

Edit: After a little testing, the strings can be read from and written to files without triggering validation. Presumably this applies to sockets as well.

DmitryOlshansky•11mo ago

I wonder how std.regex of dlang would fare in such test. Sadly due to a tiny bit of D’s GC use it’s hard to provide as a library for other languages. If there is an interest I might take it through the tests.

I bought Friendster for $30k – Here's what I'm doing with it

Self-updating screenshots

Three constraints before I build anything

Fast16: High-precision software sabotage 5 years before Stuxnet

Box to save memory in Rust

Google banks on AI edge to catch up to cloud rivals Amazon and Microsoft

Butterflies are in decline across North America, a look at the Western Monarch

AI should elevate your thinking, not replace it

SWE-bench Verified no longer measures frontier coding capabilities

Show HN: AI memory with biological decay (52% recall)

The fastest Linux timestamps

Lessons from building multiplayer browsers

Magic: The Gathering took me from N2 to Japanese fluency

When the cheap one is the cool one

Running Bare-Metal Rust Alongside ESP-IDF on the ESP32-S3's Second Core

Quirks of Human Anatomy

MoQ Boy

Sawe becomes first athlete to run a sub-two-hour marathon in a competitive race

Clay PCB Tutorial

XOXO Festival Archive

The Visible Zorker: Zork 1

Chernobyl Wildlife Forty Years On

An AI agent deleted our production database. The agent's confession is below

Music of the BBC Microcomputer System

Show HN: Startup Equity Adventure Game

Show HN: Free textbook on engineering thermodynamics

Statecharts: hierarchical state machines

Show HN: Tiao, A two-player turn-based board game

Dear friend, you have built a Kubernetes (2024)

The Last of the Lost Generation