frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

Imagineers defend new Walt Disney robot

https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/articles/keeps-walt-alive-medium-pioneered-170000117.html
41•rmason•2d ago

Comments

schlauerfox•4h ago
in the 80s AVG built a robotic Andy Warhol but he was enthused about it. Abraham lincoln is an American icon. Not sure someone who still has family in living memory is the same category despite being a sort of icon for a big corporation and a big emerging ethical concern of the 21st century seems to be bodily autonomy and consent. I see a lot of AI generated 'animated' photos, of the living and the dead. I tend to see a lot of people ignore someone's consent like they ignore media piracy, with a disinterested immoral hand-wave.
givinguflac•3h ago
I’m seriously blown away that you equated a person’s consent for their own autonomy and legacy to media piracy. What?
schlauerfox•3h ago
I live in America so 'moral rights' aren't a thing, but in europe it appears to give artist/creators rights over how their work is portrayed. How our legacy is carried forward of our own likeness or our work is a moral question, and cultural, and defines our values.
ronsor•2h ago
In America, the implementation of "moral rights" would unquestionably be a First Amendment violation.
stickfigure•3h ago
Walt Disney is unquestionably an American icon.
bombcar•3h ago
There's some fuzzy line somewhere - building an animatronic person just after they passed against (what would have been) their will or that of close relatives seems wrong.

But at some point personalities and people themselves fade into history, and it becomes a historical figure (such as Lincoln).

Isamu•4h ago
>Yet soon a social media missive critical of the attraction from Walt's granddaughter would go viral. It raised anew ethical questions that often surround any project attempting to capture the dead via technology, be it holographic representations of performers or digitally re-created cinematic animations, namely debates surrounding the wishes of the deceased and whether such creations are exploitative.

Exactly the same reaction happened when Disney developed the first Abraham Lincoln animatronic for the New York World’s Fair in the 1960’s.

tough•3h ago
Funny how history likes to rhyme eh
ryanhecht•3h ago
Great exploration of this in Defunctland's latest piece: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjNca1L6CUk (There's a "part 2" on Disney's "Living Characters" coming this year!)
wongarsu•3h ago
There is a time component to it. I don't think anybody would give a second thought to a Blackbeard animatronic. In the 60s Lincoln would have been dead about 100 years. His great-grandchildren were still alive. Today, Walt Disney has been dead 58 years. His daughter died a decade ago, his grandchildren are still alive
dehrmann•3h ago
It also hints at what his reaction would be. It seems unfair for the family to criticize them doing to Walt what he did to Lincoln.
Retric•3h ago
Dead for 10 years vs dead for 100 is a meaningful difference to me.

Namely how many people alive actually knew the person.

jelled•3h ago
I agree that the number of years matter, but Walt Disney died in 1966.
Retric•2h ago
I was bringing up the existence of a meaningful transition point not where it specifically lies.

There’s more creepy versions of the same kind of thing using recently dead performers for example.

havblue•2h ago
So I guess the standard is: dead for 100 years is acceptable. Dead for 60 years is "too soon".
wongarsu•1h ago
Was 100 years acceptable at the time? 160 years seems fine since I doubt anyone would complain about a Lincoln animatronic today
Isamu•3h ago
I think what would be unfair is putting words in the mouth of the animatronic, making Walt say something that he wouldn’t have agreed with. Same with any historical figure.
mmooss•2h ago
> Exactly the same reaction happened when Disney developed the first Abraham Lincoln animatronic for the New York World’s Fair in the 1960’s.

Is there some story that you've read and might share?

lawlessone•3h ago
It's cute now, but will people like it so much when it adopts Walt's uh... views on things...?
tetris11•3h ago
he had other facets of his personality which they will try to capture, and lessen the others. I do agree that you can't pick and choose parts of a person, and claim it's still them, but here we are
krunck•3h ago
Can't help thinking about the Kier Eagan animatronic statue in Severance.
nharada•2h ago
Yeah the quote “the goal .. is to capture what it would have been like to be in Walt’s presence” sounds like it could be straight out of that show.
RajT88•3h ago
I have seen this one before. The robot ends up trying to to eat Elian Gonzalez.
amiga386•2h ago
So Robot Chicken wasn't lying to me!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LymbI4Dxj4c

aetherson•2h ago
Surely if there is one person in history who we would be pretty sure would be thrilled to have a posthumous animatronic version of himself, it is Walt Disney.
havblue•2h ago
The problem I see with this is just the lack of originality. Disneyland originally focused on subjects like early America, the frontier or the future. This robot is about the guy who built a company that focused on that. It's very self referential. Couldn't they do something new like a Louis Armstrong robot that plays trumpet?
gopher_space•42m ago
I feel like any discussion of where the idea came from or how it developed would trigger disparagement clauses. I bet everyone's notebooks are full of better ideas.
Electricniko•1h ago
Most of Disney's works are protected by IP law, but Disney himself is public domain.
n3storm•54m ago
Wait what? yahoo.com exists? XD

Void: Open-source Cursor alternative

https://github.com/voideditor/void
248•sharjeelsayed•2h ago•141 comments

Reservoir Sampling

https://samwho.dev/reservoir-sampling/
103•chrisdemarco•2h ago•22 comments

Progress toward fusion energy gain as measured against the Lawson criteria

https://www.fusionenergybase.com/articles/continuing-progress-toward-fusion-energy-breakeven-and-gain-as-measured-against-the-lawson-criteria
91•sam•3h ago•15 comments

Notes on rolling out Cursor and Claude Code

https://ghiculescu.substack.com/p/nobody-codes-here-anymore
65•jermaustin1•2h ago•6 comments

From: Steve Jobs. "Great idea, thank you."

https://blog.hayman.net/2025/05/06/from-steve-jobs-great-idea.html
140•mattl•51m ago•31 comments

Show HN: Using eBPF to see through encryption without a proxy

https://github.com/qpoint-io/qtap
124•tylerflint•2h ago•35 comments

Static as a Server

https://overreacted.io/static-as-a-server/
29•danabramov•1h ago•7 comments

First American pope elected and will be known as Pope Leo XIV

https://www.cnn.com/world/live-news/new-pope-conclave-day-two-05-08-25
245•saikatsg•3h ago•390 comments

When Abandoned Mines Collapse

https://practical.engineering/blog/2025/5/6/when-abandoned-mines-collapse
50•impish9208•2d ago•4 comments

Using NASA’s SMAP satellite to detect L-band interference

https://radioandnukes.substack.com/p/how-dare-you-transmit-at-14-ghz
278•c16•10h ago•62 comments

Ciro (YC S22) is hiring a software engineer to build AI agents for sales

https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/ciro/jobs
1•dwiner•2h ago

The Rise and Fall of the Visual Telegraph (2017)

https://parisianfields.com/2017/11/05/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-visual-telegraph/
3•geox•17m ago•0 comments

Ask HN: What are good high-information density UIs (screenshots, apps, sites)?

285•troupo•6h ago•230 comments

Using Coalton to implement a quantum compiler (2022)

https://coalton-lang.github.io/20220906-quantum-compiler/
35•andsoitis•3d ago•4 comments

How to harden GitHub Actions

https://www.wiz.io/blog/github-actions-security-guide
172•moyer•2d ago•56 comments

Google Measures and Manages Tech Debt

https://newsletter.techworld-with-milan.com/p/how-google-measures-and-manages-tech
25•daigoba66•3h ago•3 comments

Mycoria is an open and secure overlay network that connects all participants

https://mycoria.org/
299•doener•13h ago•111 comments

How linear regression works intuitively and how it leads to gradient descent

https://briefer.cloud/blog/posts/least-squares/
297•lucasfcosta•3d ago•95 comments

My new deadline: 20 years to give away virtually all my wealth

https://www.gatesnotes.com/home/home-page-topic/reader/n20-years-to-give-away-virtually-all-my-wealth
395•nrvn•5h ago•423 comments

Google to back three new nuclear projects

https://www.esgtoday.com/google-to-back-three-new-advanced-nuclear-projects/
226•aburan28•5h ago•243 comments

How Obama’s BlackBerry got secured (2013)

https://www.electrospaces.net/2013/04/how-obamas-blackberry-got-secured.html
158•lastdong•3d ago•56 comments

Show HN: Checking Pope's election results with smoke test script for chimney

https://github.com/donobu-inc/donobu-papal-election-tests/blob/main/tests/papal_election_smoke.test.ts
20•vasusen•3h ago•10 comments

Hypermode Model Router Preview – OpenRouter Alternative

https://hypermode.com/blog/introducing-model-router
21•iamtherhino•3h ago•18 comments

AI focused on brain regions recreates what you're looking at (2024)

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2438107-mind-reading-ai-recreates-what-youre-looking-at-with-amazing-accuracy/
23•openquery•1d ago•16 comments

Block Diffusion: Interpolating Autoregressive and Diffusion Language Models

https://m-arriola.com/bd3lms/
3•t55•1h ago•0 comments

Will protein design tools solve the snake antivenom shortage?

https://www.owlposting.com/p/will-protein-design-tools-solve-the
51•sebg•7h ago•19 comments

Shape and topology morphing of closed surfaces integrating origami and kirigami

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ads5659
5•bryanrasmussen•2d ago•1 comments

More people are getting tattoos removed

https://www.gq.com/story/why-is-everyone-getting-their-tattoos-removed
66•speckx•2h ago•102 comments

Mass spectrometry method identifies pathogens within minutes instead of days

https://phys.org/news/2025-05-mass-spectrometry-method-pathogens-minutes.html
119•pseudolus•2d ago•40 comments

Brokk: AI for Large Codebases

https://brokk.ai
30•handfuloflight•1h ago•7 comments