frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

Garbage collection of object storage at scale

https://www.warpstream.com/blog/taking-out-the-trash-garbage-collection-of-object-storage-at-massive-scale
96•ko_pivot•1y ago

Comments

juancn•1y ago
Another possible mechanism for doing GC at scale (a variation on Asynchronous Reconciliation in the article) in some file/object store, is doing a probabilistic mark and sweep using bloom filters.

The mark phase can be done in parallel building many bloom filters for the files/objects found.

Then the bloom filters are merged (or'ed together essentially) and then a parallel sweep phase can use the bloom filter to answer the question: is this file/object live?

The bloom filter then answers either "No" with 100% certainty or "Maybe" with some probability p that depends on the parameters used for the bitset and the hash function family.

cogman10•1y ago
What does the bloom filter solve?

The expensive portion of the mark and sweep for the object store is the mark phase, not the storage of what's been marked. 100s, 1000s, or even millions of live objects wouldn't hardly take any space to keep in a remembered set.

On the other hand, querying the S3 bucket to list those 1M objects would be expensive no matter how you store the results.

But this does tickle my brain. Perhaps something akin to the generational hypotheses can be applied? Maybe it's the case that very old, very young, or very untouched objects are more likely to be garbage than not. If there's some way to divide the objects up and only look at objects whose are in "probably need to be collected" regions, then you could do minor fast sweeps semi frequently and schedule more expensive "really delete untracked stuff" infrequently.

Cicero22•1y ago
I was thinking they could use something like cloudwatch events, or something, to trigger sweeps and significantly reduce scheduled sweeps.

They could even use cost allocation tags to predict if a bucket or group of buckets should be scanned if it's growing unexpectedly. Cost isn't a perfect metric but there's definitely signal there.

juancn•1y ago
Building the set of used files or objects (which is what mark does in a mark/sweep).

Sometimes it's too expensive to mark in place, even if it's a bit that you need to write to disk and keeping a set of references may be prohibitive (or the structure holding the references is mostly/effectively immutable).

If it's all memory and mutable it doesn't (normally) really matter, but when it's not, you ideally would have some mechanism to move the code to where the data is, rather than stream the data to where the compute is (it is really wasteful for large scale data processing).

In any case, you would not be moving/scanning the files themselves, but the metadata is what you want to read for the mark phase.

The article if I understood correctly implies that the files and the metadata of the files (Kafka queues and so on) are separate, so presumably, the metadata is much much smaller than the data itself, but still potentially large.

For example if you had a large scale content addressed store (think a massive version of git's blob storage), you typically add to something like that and keep a few mutable root references to start your GC from to seed a mark/sweep.

Following the git example, the roots would be the branches, tags and reflogs, and the metadata you scan the transitive closur of the trees that are reachable from those (simplifying a bit) but not the file blobs themselves.

I use git as an example because a a CAS lends itself very well to large scale distributed systems because you can reason about it as an immutable data structure, but you can still change it effectively with sane semantics.

donavanm•1y ago
If you like big beautiful storage and probabilistic structures check out https://www.usenix.org/conference/osdi14/technical-sessions/.... The coho data folks ended up in AWS S3 a few years later.
juancn•1y ago
Thanks! I hadn't seen it and it may come handy!
deathanatos•1y ago
> Why Not Just Use a Bucket Policy?

I've heard these words so many times, it's refreshing to see someone dig into why bucket policies aren't a cure-all.

As for "Why not use synchronous deletion?" — regarding the pitfall there, what about a WAL? I.e., you WAL the deletions you want to perform into an object in the object store, perform the deletions, and then delete the WAL. If you crash and find a WAL file, you repeat the delete commands contained in the WAL.

(I've used this to handle this problem where some of the deletions are mixed: i.e., some in an object store, some in a SQL DB, etc. The object store is essentially being used as strongly consistent storage.)

(Perhaps this is essentially the same as your "delayed queue"? All I've got is an object store though, not a queue, and it's pretty useful hammer.)

telotortium•1y ago
> HN Disclaimer: WarpStream sells a drop-in replacement for Apache Kafka built directly on-top of object storage.

First time I’ve seen one of these. That’s actually a better way to advertise your product than putting it at the end.

hencq•1y ago
Yes, though I think they meant to say disclosure instead of disclaimer.
siscia•1y ago
What I see working extremely well, arguably in a setting where cost was not really an issue was a much simpler approach.

Keep compacting files at some regular cadence `t` and keep a bucket policy to delete files older than `t+delta+buffer`.

Then have an alarm for files older than `t+buffer`

Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on YouTube for free

https://www.cs.cmu.edu/learn/
797•pcompeau•6h ago•133 comments

Windows 11 Is Collecting Data on Which Coding Agents and Developer Tools You Use

https://xusheng.dev/posts/windows-coding-agent-telemetry/
280•cwaffles•3h ago•157 comments

BugMeNot has closed

https://www.bugmenot.com/
340•lode•5h ago•171 comments

Optimizely Compromised, Served Malware on Zoom, GitLab

https://blog.report-uri.com/worlds-largest-brands-infected-with-malware-via-optimizely/
131•kristjansson•3h ago•73 comments

Running coding agents without handing them my credentials

https://blog.antonio.cx/running-agents-with-lend
25•antoniomika•1h ago•4 comments

OpenCode Browse

https://opencode.ai/product/browse
134•mfiguiere•5h ago•62 comments

Chemistry is Actually Geometry

https://chillphysicsenjoyer.substack.com/p/chemistry-is-actually-geometry
124•sebg•6h ago•43 comments

Mem Is Shutting Down

https://get.mem.ai/blog/mem-is-shutting-down
9•qainsights•30m ago•5 comments

How to Break into Security, Ptacek Edition (2012)

https://krebsonsecurity.com/2012/06/how-to-break-into-security-ptacek-edition/
82•ronfriedhaber•4h ago•20 comments

Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display

https://trmnl.com/blog/introducing-frame
312•geerlingguy•10h ago•221 comments

Jiff 1.0: A datetime library for Rust

https://burntsushi.net/jiff/
318•burntsushi•9h ago•74 comments

Grazing sheep in fields with solar arrays

https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2026/10/sheep-grazing-solar-fields-offers-farmers-economic-ecolo...
226•PaulHoule•9h ago•226 comments

Formal Verification Is Not Verifiable

https://alperenkeles.com/posts/formal-verification-is-not-verifiable/
73•zdw•2d ago•16 comments

Do Repeat Yourself

https://arcentry.com/blog/do-repeat-yourself/
35•max_sendfeld•14h ago•13 comments

Technical issue at JPMorgan Chase triggers online banking delays for US banks

https://apnews.com/article/bank-outage-chase-wells-fargo-truist-50fee2693c22f597fa6ca51a97ef2cda
723•samk3nny•8h ago•600 comments

Show HN: Sutra-OS – A self-hosted ontology platform

https://github.com/0nelight/sutra-os
33•0nelight•3h ago•12 comments

Show HN: 1.499x speedup and 28.5% dynamic energy drop on A40 via BF16 tiling

https://cwtractors.com
10•ktractor123•1h ago•0 comments

New open source C4 Diagram tool

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZCAHP50Zly8
19•oliveralbertini•1d ago•4 comments

Squircles

https://linebender.org/wiki/curves/squircle/
139•raphlinus•18h ago•41 comments

Show HN: A free interactive course on AI agent governance

https://studio.sinapsdata.com.br
6•sadrk•32m ago•1 comments

Launch HN: Axonnic (YC F26) – Sleeves that track fingers and estimate force

29•arshpatankar•6h ago•10 comments

Rust changed me as a developer

https://blog.startifact.com/posts/how-rust-changed-me/
193•speckx•6h ago•126 comments

Microsoft blames monster email outage on software defect introduced in July fix

https://www.theregister.com/saas/2026/11/16/microsoft-blames-monster-email-outage-on-software-def...
231•Bender•13h ago•171 comments

United Airlines experiencing a widespread system outage, airline says

https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/16/us/united-airlines-outage
181•bearsyankees•4h ago•97 comments

My Quest to push native Three.js quality match AAA Game Engines

https://ben3d.ca/blog/building-the-aaa-lighting-pipeline-in-threejs
98•bhouston•5h ago•40 comments

The Secret ThinkPad Powerbutton Code to Bring Dead Laptops Back to Life (2007)

https://masnick.com/posts/the-secret-thinkpad-powerbutton-code-to-bring-dead-laptops-back-to-life/
300•sammatilda•15h ago•117 comments

Large Angle Period of the Pendulum

https://jslandy.com/pendulum/
5•efavdb•20h ago•1 comments

How to Intercept HTTP/3 Traffic: QUIC and Qpack

https://interceptsuite.com/blog/intercept-http3-traffic-quic-qpack-explained/
65•anof-cyber•7h ago•7 comments

Aristotle Expands into Rust

https://www.harmonic.fun/news/aristotle-rust-verification/
106•maufl•9h ago•55 comments

Pentagon fails ninth straight audit despite progress in organizing finances

https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/pentagon-fails-ninth-straight-audit-despite-pr...
41•petethomas•2h ago•5 comments