frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

The Art of the Critic

https://www.metropolitanreview.org/p/the-art-of-the-critic
46•benbreen•8mo ago

Comments

billfruit•8mo ago
At one time, reading Henry James(and a few others) was considered one of the pleasures of being an Adult. Perhaps because he so analysed people and their actions in a complex worldly-wise manner. Perhaps in a manner in which one would analyze one's own life.

People making life choices makes for the most riveting novels.

I'm guessing he's not that popular presently.

cafard•8mo ago
Considering the disappointing sales of the New York Edition, I wonder whether he was ever that popular.

I find the earlier work much more readable than the later. John Lukacs quotes somebody's quip about James's manners: James the First, James the Second, the Old Pretender.

nyeah•8mo ago
Alternate explanation: Dickens was pretty good but sometimes a critic, even Henry James, is just someone who doesn't like stuff.

IANAEM, I am not an English major.

hresvelgr•8mo ago
While I believe there is scant value in being a critic, a good point is nevertheless made: it should be made by practicing artists.

Elaborating on both points, as a practicing artist, paying attention to what you like is important as it shapes your tastes. Critique is useful only insofar as it allows one to create more of what perfectly embodies one's taste, whatever that may be. To be a public critic is to believe one's taste is superior. In my opinion, the only important taste is one's own to one, and should be cultivated by unabashedly following what you find intriguing.

If you're not a practicing artist, like what you like earnestly. Plenty will bemoan the state of the art crumbling, but there's a reason people still enjoy the greats of old to this day. What's good will persist.

pickleglitch•8mo ago
I think this is a myopic view of critique. A good critic helps potential consumers gauge the likelihood they will or won't enjoy a given work, and offers insights that facilitate a deeper engagement with the material. Of course one's own taste is the final arbiter of enjoyment, and of course every critic's own taste is going to flavor their criticism, but that doesn't mean they must believe their own tastes are superior, or that non-critics should take their views as objective facts, or that the whole enterprise serves no purpose for anyone other than practicing artists.

For example, if I watch a movie and don't understand it I could shrug it off and forget about it and there would be nothing wrong with that. But I could also go read critiques of the film and maybe gain an understanding which makes my interaction with the film more enriching, even if it doesn't necessarily change my overall opinion.

I think it's true that critique can never be as valuable as the work it examines, but art only becomes part of culture when it is discussed by the culture. That is what critics are doing.

ahalbert4•8mo ago
Vladimir Nabokov's opinions on various writers, culled from Strong Opinions. (http://wmjas.wikidot.com/nabokov-s-recommendations)

* James, Henry. Dislike him rather intensely, but now and then his wording causes a kind of electric tingle. Certainly not a genius.

miiiiiike•8mo ago
I've worked with professional [0] critics.

They're constantly workshopping their bad opinions. And, if you try to straighten them out on a subject I can almost guarantee that your words and arguments, the ones that they'll dismiss or ridicule (usually verbosely) in the moment, are going to appear on the page under their byline. Typically expressed in tone that makes the reader feel lucky that they have decided to share their holy knowledge with mere mortals.

Is what you're talking about in their field? No? Well they're going to use the same tone and rhetorical tactics to talk about the things they know nothing about.

Demonstrate that they're wrong in a way that's not useful to them? Well, you've just made an enemy for life. Hope you like receiving 9,000 word emails that could have been boiled down to "How dare you tell me that I'm not perfect?" Why use 9 words when you can use 9,000? Not getting the point? No worries, they'll tag in three of their friends.

As a class, they were poorly paid people, personal lives in tatters, with little knowledge or experience of the world, all crawling over eachother to be see as the "thought leader". The one who gets to tell everyone how the world is to be run.

To be famous.

The kind of people who, if you were stuck on a snowy mountain, would burn down the shelter you're building (too slowly in their opinion), complain that it's too hot, and the when the fire goes out, attack you for letting it get so cold. "What happened to that shelter you were building? It burned down? Well, how could you let that happen?"

Don't even get me started on the lies and excuses (never. ending.) While still maintaining a public reputation for "honesty and transparency". It doesn't matter if it's true as long as you keep saying it.

Ended up getting lawyers involved and maneuvered them into putting every stupid thing that they did in writing before walking away. They're still doing the same kind of stuff at about the same level that were doing it 10-12 years ago. Self-limiting. It's not even worth attacking them publicly, there's nothing that I could do to them that they aren't already doing to themselves.

Learned a few things from the experience:

-1: If you have something to communicate, communicate it yourself. Never allow anyone communicate an important message for you unless you’re standing right behind them.

0. Don't try to help people if you need help yourself.

1. Work with people who want to be known for what they do, rather than what they say.

2. Selfishness and myopia have no floor. You can set the bar for success as low as possible and some people will still find a way to blame you when they trip over it.

3. End quickly. If someone acts in bad faith even once, it's over.

[0]: Professional meaning that someone, somewhere, paid them something for their opinion. Not to be confused with professional conduct.

OpenCiv3: Open-source, cross-platform reimagining of Civilization III

https://openciv3.org/
455•klaussilveira•6h ago•111 comments

The Waymo World Model

https://waymo.com/blog/2026/02/the-waymo-world-model-a-new-frontier-for-autonomous-driving-simula...
795•xnx•12h ago•482 comments

Show HN: Look Ma, No Linux: Shell, App Installer, Vi, Cc on ESP32-S3 / BreezyBox

https://github.com/valdanylchuk/breezydemo
153•isitcontent•7h ago•15 comments

Monty: A minimal, secure Python interpreter written in Rust for use by AI

https://github.com/pydantic/monty
145•dmpetrov•7h ago•66 comments

Dark Alley Mathematics

https://blog.szczepan.org/blog/three-points/
47•quibono•4d ago•5 comments

A century of hair samples proves leaded gas ban worked

https://arstechnica.com/science/2026/02/a-century-of-hair-samples-proves-leaded-gas-ban-worked/
87•jnord•3d ago•9 comments

How we made geo joins 400× faster with H3 indexes

https://floedb.ai/blog/how-we-made-geo-joins-400-faster-with-h3-indexes
23•matheusalmeida•1d ago•0 comments

Show HN: I spent 4 years building a UI design tool with only the features I use

https://vecti.com
258•vecti•9h ago•120 comments

Microsoft open-sources LiteBox, a security-focused library OS

https://github.com/microsoft/litebox
323•aktau•13h ago•156 comments

Show HN: If you lose your memory, how to regain access to your computer?

https://eljojo.github.io/rememory/
194•eljojo•9h ago•127 comments

Sheldon Brown's Bicycle Technical Info

https://www.sheldonbrown.com/
318•ostacke•12h ago•85 comments

Hackers (1995) Animated Experience

https://hackers-1995.vercel.app/
405•todsacerdoti•14h ago•218 comments

An Update on Heroku

https://www.heroku.com/blog/an-update-on-heroku/
330•lstoll•13h ago•238 comments

PC Floppy Copy Protection: Vault Prolok

https://martypc.blogspot.com/2024/09/pc-floppy-copy-protection-vault-prolok.html
20•kmm•4d ago•1 comments

Show HN: R3forth, a ColorForth-inspired language with a tiny VM

https://github.com/phreda4/r3
51•phreda4•6h ago•8 comments

I spent 5 years in DevOps – Solutions engineering gave me what I was missing

https://infisical.com/blog/devops-to-solutions-engineering
113•vmatsiiako•11h ago•36 comments

How to effectively write quality code with AI

https://heidenstedt.org/posts/2026/how-to-effectively-write-quality-code-with-ai/
190•i5heu•9h ago•137 comments

Learning from context is harder than we thought

https://hy.tencent.com/research/100025?langVersion=en
150•limoce•3d ago•79 comments

Delimited Continuations vs. Lwt for Threads

https://mirageos.org/blog/delimcc-vs-lwt
3•romes•4d ago•0 comments

Understanding Neural Network, Visually

https://visualrambling.space/neural-network/
240•surprisetalk•3d ago•31 comments

Make Trust Irrelevant: A Gamer's Take on Agentic AI Safety

https://github.com/Deso-PK/make-trust-irrelevant
7•DesoPK•1h ago•4 comments

I now assume that all ads on Apple news are scams

https://kirkville.com/i-now-assume-that-all-ads-on-apple-news-are-scams/
988•cdrnsf•16h ago•417 comments

Introducing the Developer Knowledge API and MCP Server

https://developers.googleblog.com/introducing-the-developer-knowledge-api-and-mcp-server/
23•gfortaine•4h ago•2 comments

FORTH? Really!?

https://rescrv.net/w/2026/02/06/associative
44•rescrv•14h ago•17 comments

I'm going to cure my girlfriend's brain tumor

https://andrewjrod.substack.com/p/im-going-to-cure-my-girlfriends-brain
61•ray__•3h ago•15 comments

Evaluating and mitigating the growing risk of LLM-discovered 0-days

https://red.anthropic.com/2026/zero-days/
36•lebovic•1d ago•11 comments

Show HN: Smooth CLI – Token-efficient browser for AI agents

https://docs.smooth.sh/cli/overview
78•antves•1d ago•57 comments

Female Asian Elephant Calf Born at the Smithsonian National Zoo

https://www.si.edu/newsdesk/releases/female-asian-elephant-calf-born-smithsonians-national-zoo-an...
5•gmays•1h ago•0 comments

Show HN: Slack CLI for Agents

https://github.com/stablyai/agent-slack
40•nwparker•1d ago•10 comments

The Oklahoma Architect Who Turned Kitsch into Art

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2026-01-31/oklahoma-architect-bruce-goff-s-wild-home-desi...
21•MarlonPro•3d ago•4 comments