frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

The Titanic’s Best Lifeboat

https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/632-the-titanics-best-lifeboat/
63•zeristor•2w ago

Comments

zeristor•2w ago
An interesting podcast.

The mind set was that life boats were dangerous, only with the Titanic’s sinking did occur on a tranquil sea, otherwise many others would have died.

That and the California’s radio operator having just turned in for the night missing the distress call, which the ship could have transferred the passengers to.

bcraven•2w ago
That is indeed a rough two-sentence summary of the featured article.
HPsquared•2w ago
We're all about efficiency here on HN.
drittich•2w ago
tl;dr

HN values efficiency

nosianu•2w ago
Plus, according to the article, even sinking relatively slowly the crew did not even manage to launch all the lifeboats they had, so more of them would probably not have made a difference.

They also based the decision for the number of lifeboats on empiric data. According to the article, until then lifeboats launched from ships out at sea had a very bad track record. Rarely did anyone survive, they just died from lack of food and water.

Instead, they started to making the actual ships much more survivable. The main purpose of those lifeboats then was to ferry passengers to rescue ships, so a full set for every single person on board was not needed.

It is a very interesting article. Every time I hear some simple story, as soon as someone more knowledgeable has a look it begins to look very different from the little snippet known and spread by the public. I never trust simple stories any more, so I am glad I heard a different version of the simple "The Titanic did not have enough lifeboats".

Reading the whole still short article is worth it! I'm summarizing a few additional points because I am definitely not complaining about common habits of readers who are more likely to read the comments :-)

bombcar•2w ago
It also explains more of the reluctance to get in the lifeboats. If most cases you’ve heard about end in disaster or nothing (because the big boat don’t sink) it makes it less desirable.
bravesoul2•2w ago
This reminds me of the London fire (Grenfell) where people were advised to stay in their appartment because usually that is the safest thing to do due to fire doors. It's like the counter-intuitive thing is safer until it isn't.
IAmBroom•1w ago
People in the Twin Towers were advised the same: you're safer waiting it out than risking getting trampled by panicky people needlessly in the stairs.
zeristor•2w ago
This is a podcast first, the article is a nice to have.

The podcast came up in my feed and I listened to it.

UncleSlacky•2w ago
Not sure why they think the Titanic's boats were overcrowded - many of them werre only about half-full, as the crew thought that they couldn't be winched down when full (it was a recent innovation). Also the list of the ship made launching the boats on one side difficult, even with nobody in them.
hoseja•2w ago
Genuinely, why are people/culture seemingly more concerned with the 1500 lives lost on Titanic than the 15~20 MILLION lost in The Great War? Similarly airplane vs automobile casualties. Is it just about the power of the story to sell in a newspaper?
snapcaster•2w ago
I think it's because the massive death of men in war is "priced in" to people's mental model and things like a huge cruise ship sinking aren't
PretzelPirate•2w ago
It's easier to relate to people on a trip than in a war, too many people died during the great war so being concerned is overwhelming, the Titanic had the perfect headline as the unsinkable ship, rich people were on the Titanic and we care about them more than poors dying in a war, etc...
randomcarbloke•1w ago
lots of rich people died during the war too, noblesse oblige saw to that.
potato3732842•2w ago
People are supposed to die in war, and automobiles are operated at the whim of the one person driving them whereas commercial airplanes are operated in strict accordance with a protocol that's supposed to prevent killing people and trashing the multimillion dollar commercial equipment. Nobody gives a crap when two guys in a float plane crash in the middle of nowhere, because the circumstances said aircraft is operated under are pretty close to that of a car.

I'm not gonna call your question silly because it was in earnest, but it does seem to indicate problems with your world view that you consider deaths under these differing circumstances fungible at a 1 for 1 rate or thereabouts.

hoseja•2w ago
Why are they not fungible for you? What difference is there when a drunk t-bones you two thousand times versus an iceberg t-boning fifteen hundred people one time? Also what the hell do you mean "supposed to die in a war", who decides that?

But I see the line about "multimillion dollar commercial equipment". The shareholder value must be protected after all. Conversely, a wrecked car is a potential new sale.

pookha•2w ago
I can tell you haven't been a software developer or engineer long if the woes of the Titanic aren't resonating with you at some level. They built out this lux tricked out master facade to make the most high-end ocean liner in the world but built it with rivets that were high in slag (cheap). They took shortcuts that got exposed on the product launch which sent over a thousand people to the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean. As a dev I look at this as the worst, most historically atrocious user experience in the history of human civilization and it continues to live on in the memories of everyone in 2025. And RIP to those that gave up their seats on those shifty lifeboats so that other peoples kids could survive this debacle.
jodrellblank•2w ago
> "As a dev I look at this as the worst, most historically atrocious user experience in the history of human civilization"

Another contender: during the fire and sinking of the steamship General Slocum carrying people on a family picnic in New York, 1904, people reached for the fire hoses which were cheap and rotten and useless. The lifeboats were inaccessible. The life jackets unmaintained for a decade and had rotted to cork dust and the inspection records had been falsified. Imagine with no fire extinguishing, no lifeboats, you grab a remaining life preserver and put it on your kid and throw them overboard only to watch them sink to their death because the life preserver manufacturing company had put iron bars in them instead of cork floats because that was cheaper.

957 people died in the whole disaster. The headlines are here:

https://www.nytimes.com/1904/10/02/archives/put-iron-bars-in...

https://www.nytimes.com/1905/05/25/archives/for-life-preserv...

and the story here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38NfsPVC6m8

ahazred8ta•1w ago
The rivets and plates were made of material that was strong enough at room temperature but brittle at freezing temperatures. This phenomenon was not known to metallurgists at the time. It was an industry-wide problem.
justinrubek•1w ago
> who decides that

The people that sent them to war and the people trying to kill them. It's a collaboration.

IAmBroom•1w ago
Deaths are not fungible.

My grandma died in her 90s. That was a pity.

My friend committed suicide in his 40s. That was gut-wrenching.

Another friend died unexpectedly of heart issue in his 40s. That was sad.

Some deaths insert periods into sentences; others, ellipses or question marks.

Jeema101•2w ago
I don't think people are 'more concerned' - it's just that the sinking of the Titanic was (and still is) a shocking and compelling story. It was the largest ocean liner in the world, on it's maiden voyage, supposedly unsinkable, sinking in frigid waters in a single tragic night.
emmelaich•2w ago
How many lives would be lost by not fighting?
yread•2w ago
They were rich and white!

Ex-Waymo engineers launch Bedrock Robotics to automate construction

https://techcrunch.com/2025/07/16/ex-waymo-engineers-launch-bedrock-robotics-with-80m-to-automate-construction/
152•boulos•8h ago•124 comments

Show HN: A 'Choose Your Own Adventure' written in Emacs Org Mode

https://tendollaradventure.com/sample/
54•dskhatri•2h ago•3 comments

I want an iPhone Mini-sized Android phone (2022)

https://smallandroidphone.com/
63•asimops•3h ago•100 comments

Altermagnets: The first new type of magnet in nearly a century

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2487013-weve-discovered-a-new-kind-of-magnetism-what-can-we-do-with-it/
274•Brajeshwar•9h ago•64 comments

Gaslight-Driven Development

https://tonsky.me/blog/gaslight-driven-development/
12•theodorejb•29m ago•7 comments

From engineer to manager: A practical guide to your first months in leadership

https://humansinsystems.com/blog/new-manager-essentials-a-practical-guide-to-your-first-months
41•yunusozen•2d ago•34 comments

Artisanal handcrafted Git repositories

https://drew.silcock.dev/blog/artisanal-git/
101•drewsberry•5h ago•22 comments

AI therapy bots fuel delusions and give dangerous advice, Stanford study finds

https://arstechnica.com/ai/2025/07/ai-therapy-bots-fuel-delusions-and-give-dangerous-advice-stanford-study-finds/
69•pseudolus•3d ago•25 comments

Tin Can – The landline, reinvented for kids

https://tincan.kids/
124•derwiki•3h ago•91 comments

Signs of autism could be encoded in the way you walk

https://www.sciencealert.com/signs-of-autism-could-be-encoded-in-the-way-you-walk
64•amichail•6h ago•75 comments

Pgactive: Postgres active-active replication extension

https://github.com/aws/pgactive
257•ForHackernews•15h ago•69 comments

A recap on May/June stability at Neon

https://neon.com/blog/an-apology-and-a-recap-on-may-june-stability
37•nikita•4h ago•4 comments

Intel's retreat is unlike anything it's done before in Oregon

https://www.oregonlive.com/silicon-forest/2025/07/intels-retreat-is-unlike-anything-its-done-before-in-oregon.html
65•cbzbc•5h ago•74 comments

Show HN: 0xDEAD//TYPE – A fast-paced typing shooter with retro vibes

https://0xdeadtype.theden.sh/
58•theden•3d ago•16 comments

Show HN: Improving search ranking with chess Elo scores

https://www.zeroentropy.dev/blog/improving-rag-with-elo-scores
133•ghita_•10h ago•44 comments

Chain of thought monitorability: A new and fragile opportunity for AI safety

https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.11473
100•mfiguiere•10h ago•45 comments

Roman dodecahedron: 12-sided object has baffled archaeologists for centuries

https://www.livescience.com/archaeology/romans/roman-dodecahedron-a-mysterious-12-sided-object-that-has-baffled-archaeologists-for-centuries
31•bookofjoe•2d ago•66 comments

I'm switching to Python and actually liking it

https://www.cesarsotovalero.net/blog/i-am-switching-to-python-and-actually-liking-it.html
324•cesarsotovalero•17h ago•499 comments

Shipping WebGPU on Windows in Firefox 141

https://mozillagfx.wordpress.com/2025/07/15/shipping-webgpu-on-windows-in-firefox-141/
338•Bogdanp•18h ago•140 comments

Scanned piano rolls database

http://www.pianorollmusic.org/rolldatabase.php
22•bookofjoe•4d ago•7 comments

Weave (YC W25) is hiring an AI engineer

https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/weave-3/jobs/SqFnIFE-founding-ai-engineer
1•adchurch•7h ago

A Rust shaped hole

https://mnvr.in/rust
35•vishnumohandas•1d ago•91 comments

Young graduates are facing an employment crisis

https://www.wsj.com/economy/jobs/jobs-unemployment-rise-young-people-ce4704d8
120•bdev12345•4h ago•191 comments

How and where will agents ship software?

https://www.instantdb.com/essays/agents
102•stopachka•7h ago•50 comments

Show HN: The HTML Maze – Escape an eerie labyrinth built with HTML pages

https://htmlmaze.com/
57•kyrylo•2d ago•16 comments

What's happening to reading?

https://www.newyorker.com/culture/open-questions/whats-happening-to-reading
126•Kaibeezy•3d ago•261 comments

Tilck: A tiny Linux-compatible kernel

https://github.com/vvaltchev/tilck
266•chubot•21h ago•51 comments

Atopile – Design circuit boards with code

https://atopile.io/atopile/introduction
88•poly2it•3d ago•24 comments

Mkosi – Build Bespoke OS Images

https://mkosi.systemd.io/
54•leetrout•8h ago•16 comments

Show HN: BloomSearch – Keyword search with hierarchical Bloom filters

https://github.com/danthegoodman1/bloomsearch
49•dangoodmanUT•3d ago•10 comments