(One of my favorite Sci-Fi Young Adult series I read growing up)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortal_Engines
tl;dr = Post apocalypse, cities are giant mobile machines that eat and integrate smaller cities to survive
For mostly-self-sufficient organisms in earth's environment, the versatility of carbon appears to outperform silicon on every metric that counts.
The molecular complexity of a single human lung cell still absolutely dwarfs that of even the most modern CPUs we are able to manufacture (apple to oranges, but true).
To reiterate, The belief that evolving machines have to match the kind of evolution we're subjected to is illogical. Machines wouldn't be there without us and we wouldn't have what we have now without evolving our machines.
We're just way more capable of high complexity.
But also don't forget that evolution is not determinist : although you are probably right that silicon based life cannot exist, it's not because it doesn't exist that it is impossible
What are you even measuring with complexity there? We don't go out of our way to make CPUs more complex, either chemically or in terms of circuits, their complexity is just what results from what we want them to do. What we want them to do isn't (yet) "reproduce" or "eat", unless you count the entire larger industrial ecosystem of which they are vital element as well as being a byproduct, as even this paper is in the hypothetical.
Looking at the abstract and skimming the rest, it is suggesting something involving a much bigger system than a silicon chip, but it's still more akin to how a virus hijacks the molecular processes of the actual factory (i.e. the cell it infects), or primates using bones as tools if you prefer a macro-scale analogy.
Tech Company: At long last, we have created the Torment Nexus from classic sci-fi novel Don't Create The Torment Nexus »
Not only this is extremely restrictive, but it is in contradiction with the second point
> Second, the only external provision to robot metabolism is energy and material in the form of robots or robot parts.
littlestymaar•6mo ago
neom•6mo ago
More seriously, are there public examples where inventors/technologists have ever actually said "we could do this but we won't"?
aeve890•6mo ago
h2zizzle•6mo ago
littlestymaar•6mo ago
jolmg•6mo ago
littlestymaar•6mo ago
Nasrudith•6mo ago
akomtu•6mo ago
MrFoof•6mo ago
A recent "popular culture" reference to the scenario mentioned in the article is the video game, "Horizon: Zero Dawn."