frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

A large number of protocols on Ethereum and Solana blockchains have no revenue

https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2025/07/23/disguised-unemployment-in-blockchain-data-shows-only-12-of-ethereum-25-of-solana-protocols-have-revenue
21•PaulHoule•4h ago

Comments

charcircuit•4h ago
What percentage of businesses have revenue, including dissolved businesses?

12% and 25% is higher than I would have predicted since I'd suspect most to fail.

daft_pink•3h ago
You’d think that smart contracts would have very high levels of inactivity and once you create a smart contract it’s impractical for it to be depracated.
alphazard•3h ago
This is a statistic that no one asked for and no one should care about. How much L2 value is transacted every day on each ledger? is a much better first question. A good second question is how that value is distributed amongst the various L2 protocols.
chrisco255•2h ago
Defi Llama is generally a good source for this info: https://defillama.com/
latchkey•3h ago
The tone of the article sounds like an attempt to make news out of nothing, while ETH is nearing ATH's.

Years ago, we went through a DeFi summer where a ton of protocols were built. Then, multiple years of nothing as the summer ended.

Since then, many of the protocols condensed into a few very very active protocols. Turtle has $1.1B deployed in only two campaigns. AAVE has $55B. Morpho has $10B. There are tons more protocols doing just fine.

bo1024•3h ago
Yeah, this is odd, a bit like calling out the percent of registered web domains that don’t generate revenue.
moomin•3h ago
Is there really a security exposure to protocols you don’t yourself employ? How do protocols get updated? Can they be EOLed? Turns out there’s a lot I don’t know about Ethereum.
baobun•3h ago
It depends.

Say you're participating in a lending protocol utilizing some form of on-chain price oracles (ie smart contracts exposing updating data), such that gaming of some particular third decentralized exchange would manipulate the pricing data and could thereby affect your position (triggering liquidation or whatnot).

Say you're holding some on-chain stablecoin backed by other tokens. Issues with contracts of those tokens could tank their value and thereby affecting your stablecoin value.

It all comes down to introduction of points of trust in interconnected systems. Tale as old as time.

chrisco255•2h ago
As sibling comment mentioned, depends on if you integrate with those protocols whether or not you are exposed to external security issues.

As for upgrades, some protocols are immutable and can't be updated, however, most complex protocols implement some kind of upgrade mechanic.

Smart contracts cannot change their code once deployed, but you can implement a proxy pattern that delegates calls to an implementation contract, and swap out implementation contracts as needed by updating the pointer on the proxy. Some protocols have simple single owner systems for updating the implementation. Some are owned by multisigs and may require a 5 of 9 (or whataver arbitrary majority configuration) committee to sign off on the upgrade. Others require a vote by the token holders of the protocol to approve an upgrade.

If it's an upgradeable protocol then it can be EOLed, otherwise it lives forever onchain.

mcintyre1994•3h ago
I don’t really understand the angle they’re going for here. I’d expect that most of these are just abandoned products that failed to become a viable business, and don’t claim to employ anybody. You could get a similar stat if you looked at projects that have used AWS or something like that.
baobun•2h ago
A lot of them have never intended or claimed to be businesses or revenue-yielding in the first place.
j45•2h ago
Especially if a lot of them are ideas being explored and not coming from a business background or use case.

When businesses with their use cases start using something like this, I'd say watch out, but the reality is it might just be invisible and just print the same receipt we're used to.

raffy•2h ago
why are we debating ai slop from a [dude](https://www.coindesk.com/author/omkar-godbole) who wrote about XRP in the last 2 of 4 articles?
wslh•2h ago
CoinDesk is ignoring the elephant in the room: for most protocol owners, revenue is almost irrelevant. Early investors in crypto startups often get tokens worth many times their cash investment. Once the protocol is live and popular, the money pours in. Vesting rules? A few years is plenty. The real kicker is that there's no transparency about how many tokens these investors get, only the round investment totals make it into public reports.
chrisco255•2h ago
A large number of apps in any ecosystem have little to no revenue. Coindesk discovers the Pareto principle, breaking news...
Animats•2h ago
Blockchains store data as long as someone, somewhere has a node. There's no way to purge old data. So old, useless data does build up.

It's not that bad, though. The Ethereum chain is about 1.4TB right now.[1] Growth is roughly linear. Bitcoin is under half a terabyte. Those are manageable numbers given current disk sizes.

The size of the Solana blockchain is claimed to be only 10MB. That's tiny. Where is the data stored?

From the article: "Parts of this article were generated with the assistance from AI tools and reviewed by our editorial team to ensure accuracy and adherence to our standards." Right. That's Coinbase trolling for clicks.

[1] https://ycharts.com/indicators/ethereum_chain_full_sync_data...

wslh•1h ago
> The size of the Solana blockchain is claimed to be only 10MB. That's tiny. Where is the data stored?

Based on this answer[1] it was 100TB in 2022.

[1] https://solana.stackexchange.com/questions/146/whats-the-cur...

Compiling a Lisp: Lambda Lifting

https://bernsteinbear.com/blog/compiling-a-lisp-12/
54•azhenley•3h ago•4 comments

Show HN: Reactive: A React Book for the Reluctant – a book written by Claude

https://github.com/cloudstreet-dev/React-is-Awful
17•DavidCanHelp•57m ago•13 comments

Try and

https://ygdp.yale.edu/phenomena/try-and
416•treetalker•12h ago•218 comments

GPT-OSS vs. Qwen3 and a detailed look how things evolved since GPT-2

https://magazine.sebastianraschka.com/p/from-gpt-2-to-gpt-oss-analyzing-the
301•ModelForge•10h ago•56 comments

1910: The year the modern world lost its mind

https://www.derekthompson.org/p/1910-the-year-the-modern-world-lost
180•purgator•4h ago•136 comments

Show HN: Bolt – A super-fast, statically-typed scripting language written in C

https://github.com/Beariish/bolt
140•beariish•7h ago•47 comments

Fight Chat Control

https://fightchatcontrol.eu/
796•tokai•8h ago•228 comments

Show HN: Engineering.fyi – Search across tech engineering blogs in one place

https://engineering.fyi/
282•indiehackerman•11h ago•74 comments

One Million Screenshots

https://onemillionscreenshots.com/?q=random
120•gaws•5h ago•45 comments

Diffusion language models are super data learners

https://jinjieni.notion.site/Diffusion-Language-Models-are-Super-Data-Learners-239d8f03a866800ab196e49928c019ac
140•babelfish•9h ago•10 comments

Creating the Longest Possible Ski Jump in “The Games: Winter Challenge”

https://mrwint.github.io/winter/writeup/writeup2.html
101•alberto-m•3d ago•4 comments

PHP compile time generics: yay or nay?

https://thephp.foundation/blog/2025/08/05/compile-generics/
47•moebrowne•3d ago•14 comments

Show HN: A Sinclair ZX81 retro web assembler+simulator

3•andromaton•58m ago•0 comments

Battery charge limiter for Apple Silicon MacBook devices

https://github.com/actuallymentor/battery
44•rahimnathwani•3d ago•30 comments

Reflections on Soviet Amateur Photography

https://www.publicbooks.org/strangers-in-the-family-album-reflections-on-soviet-amateur-photography/
21•prismatic•3d ago•2 comments

Booting 5000 Erlangs on Ampere One 192-core

https://underjord.io/booting-5000-erlangs-on-ampere-one.html
175•ingve•14h ago•29 comments

Squashing my dumb bugs and why I log build IDs

https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2025/08/03/scope/
10•wglb•3d ago•0 comments

Writing simple tab-completions for Bash and Zsh

https://mill-build.org/blog/14-bash-zsh-completion.html
218•lihaoyi•15h ago•70 comments

How I code with AI on a budget/free

https://wuu73.org/blog/aiguide1.html
563•indigodaddy•1d ago•188 comments

Abogen – Generate audiobooks from EPUBs, PDFs and text

https://github.com/denizsafak/abogen
277•mzehrer•19h ago•66 comments

Conversations remotely detected from cell phone vibrations, researchers report

https://www.psu.edu/news/engineering/story/conversations-remotely-detected-cell-phone-vibrations-researchers-report
29•giuliomagnifico•7h ago•4 comments

Type (YC W23) is hiring a founding engineer to build an AI-native doc editor

https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/type/jobs/1idOunL-founding-product-engineer
1•stewfortier•8h ago

Events

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Learn_web_development/Core/Scripting/Events
32•aanthonymax•5h ago•12 comments

ECScape: Understanding IAM Privilege Boundaries in Amazon ECS

https://www.sweet.security/blog/ecscape-understanding-iam-privilege-boundaries-in-amazon-ecs
12•eyberg•4d ago•4 comments

My Dream Productivity Device Is Done – and It's Becoming a Kit [video]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pf3BxNq1cp4
47•surprisetalk•4d ago•38 comments

Inside OS/2 (1987)

https://gitpi.us/article-archive/inside-os2/
101•rbanffy•12h ago•47 comments

Open Lovable

https://github.com/mendableai/open-lovable
142•iamflimflam1•15h ago•42 comments

Abusing Entra OAuth for fun and access to internal Microsoft applications

https://research.eye.security/consent-and-compromise/
329•the1bernard•1d ago•98 comments

Flintlock – Create and manage the lifecycle of MicroVMs, backed by containerd

https://github.com/liquidmetal-dev/flintlock
67•Palmik•10h ago•3 comments

The Framework Desktop is a beast

https://world.hey.com/dhh/the-framework-desktop-is-a-beast-636fb4ff
413•lemonberry•2d ago•383 comments