frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

Open in hackernews

Class-action suit claims Otter AI records private work conversations

https://www.npr.org/2025/08/15/g-s1-83087/otter-ai-transcription-class-action-lawsuit
71•nsedlet•2h ago

Comments

DaiPlusPlus•1h ago
Assuming the courts simplify Otter AI down to being a glorified call recording and transcribing tool (because the fact it's "AI" isn't really relevant here w.r.t. privacy/one/two-party-consent rules then doesn't the legal responsibility here lie with whichever person added Otter AI to group-calls without informing the other members?

----

EDIT: So the crux of the matter is whether-or-not having Otter AI automatically join meetings via their Slack/Zoom/etc integrations is by-itself legally wrong - or not:

> "In fact, if the meeting host is an Otter accountholder who has integrated their relevant Google Meet, Zoom, or Microsoft Teams accounts with Otter, an Otter Notetaker may join the meeting without obtaining the affirmative consent from any meeting participant, including the host," the lawsuit alleges. "What Otter has done is use its Otter Notetaker meeting assistant to record, transcribe, and utilize the contents of conversations without the Class members' informed consent."

I'm surprised the NPR article doesn't touch on the possible liability of whoever added Otter in the first place - surely the buck stops there?

gruez•1h ago
>doesn't the legal responsibility here lie with whichever person added Otter AI to group-calls without informing the other members

IANAL but companies providing a product has certain responsibilities too, especially when they're intended to be used for a given purpose (ie. recording meetings with other people on it). Most call recording software I come across have a recording notice that can't be disabled, presumably to avoid lawsuits like this.

>EDIT: So the crux of the matter is whether-or-not having Otter AI automatically join meetings via their Slack/Zoom/etc integrations is by-itself legally wrong - or not:

Note the preceding paragraph also notes that even when the integrations aren't used, otter only obtains consent from the meeting host. In all-party consent states that's clearly not sufficient.

>because the fact it's "AI" isn't really relevant here

Again, IANAL, but "recording" laws might not apply if they're merely transcribing the audio? To take an extreme case, it's (probably) legal to hire a stenographer to sit next to you on meetings and transcribe everything on the call, even if you don't tell any other participants. Otter is a note-taking app, so they might have been in the clear if they weren't recording for AI training.

boothby•1h ago
I had a conversation with a lawyer who had invited OtterAI to our confidential meeting. I was gobsmacked, and I quickly read Otter's privacy statement -- my impression was that they retain your data in a cloud service and use your "anonymized" (or was it "depersonalized"?) recordings as future training data. Even if they have a bona fide reason for all that, I question their ability to store the data securely and succeed in anonymizing data that contains unique identifiers that could be tied to future court records. I refused to continue in the presence of the bot.

And, even beyond security is their ability to hold promises made over the data in the event of a private equity takeover, a rogue employee, etc.

nkotov•1h ago
Wait until they find out about Granola AI
klabb3•1h ago
Before AI, you needed to trust the recipient and the provider (Gmail, Signal, WhatsApp, discord). You could at least make educated guesses about both for the risk profile. Such as: if someone leaks the code to this repo, it’s likely a collaborator or GitHub.

Today, you invite someone to a private repo and the code gets exfiltrated by a collaborator running whatever AI tool simply by opening their IDE.

Or you send someone an e2ee message on Signal but their AI reads the screen/text to summarize and now that message is exfiltrated.

Yes, I know it’s ”nothing new” ”in principle this could happen because you don’t control the client”. But opsec is also about what happens when well-meaning participants being accomplices in data collection. I used to trust that my friends enough to not share our conversations. Now the default assumption is that text & media on even private messaging will be harvested.

Personally I’m not ever giving keys to the kingdom to a remote data-hungry company, no matter how reputable. I’ll reconsider when local or self-hosted AI is available.

xnx•1h ago
Why does Otter AI exist? Aren't those features built-in to videoconferencing now?
jorts•59m ago
Most of the ones built into the video conferencing solutions aren't as good.
bilekas•8m ago
> Last year, an AI researcher and engineer said Otter had recorded a Zoom meeting with investors, then shared with him a transcription of the chat including "intimate, confidential details" about a business discussed after he had left the meeting. Those portions of the conversation ended up killing a deal,

I'm sorry but this is another example of not checking AI's work. Whatever about the excessive recording, that's one thing, but blindly trusting the AI's output and then using it blindly as a company document for a client is on you.

FFmpeg Assembly Language Lessons

https://github.com/FFmpeg/asm-lessons
127•flykespice•2h ago•30 comments

Show HN: I built an app to block Shorts and Reels

https://scrollguard.app/
233•adrianhacar•2d ago•73 comments

Who Invented Backpropagation?

https://people.idsia.ch/~juergen/who-invented-backpropagation.html
13•nothrowaways•30m ago•2 comments

The Weight of a Cell

https://www.asimov.press/p/cell-weight
17•arbesman•51m ago•3 comments

Launch HN: Reality Defender (YC W22) – API for Deepfake and GenAI Detection

https://www.realitydefender.com/platform/api
16•bpcrd•1h ago•5 comments

Web apps in a single, portable, self-updating, vanilla HTML file

https://hyperclay.com/
471•pil0u•9h ago•165 comments

Show HN: A Minimal Hacker News Reader for Apple Watch Built with SwiftUI

https://github.com/wieslawsoltes/HackerNewsWatch
43•wiso•1h ago•7 comments

Typechecker Zoo

https://sdiehl.github.io/typechecker-zoo/
36•todsacerdoti•2d ago•9 comments

Walkie-Textie Wireless Communicator

http://www.technoblogy.com/show?2AON
82•chrisjj•2d ago•40 comments

A gigantic jet caught on camera: A spritacular moment for NASA astronaut

https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/heliophysics/a-gigantic-jet-caught-on-camera-a-spritacular-moment-for-nasa-astronaut-nicole-ayers/
326•acossta•3d ago•71 comments

Electromechanical reshaping, an alternative to laser eye surgery

https://medicalxpress.com/news/2025-08-alternative-lasik-lasers.html
145•Gaishan•6h ago•66 comments

The Coming Robot Home Invasion

https://www.andykessler.com/andy_kessler/2025/08/wsj-home-robots.html
15•walterbell•2h ago•12 comments

Image Fulgurator (2011)

https://juliusvonbismarck.com/bank/index.php/projects/image-fulgurator/2/
9•Liftyee•2d ago•1 comments

The Road That Killed Legend Jenkins Was Working as Designed

https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2025/8/18/the-road-that-killed-legend-jenkins-was-working-exactly-as-designed
74•h14h•47m ago•35 comments

Win10 users looking for a new OS? Apple $599 MacBook can't come at a better time

https://www.zdnet.com/article/windows-10-users-looking-for-a-new-os-apples-599-macbook-cant-come-at-a-better-time/
12•walterbell•27m ago•4 comments

Sky Calendar

https://abramsplanetarium.org/SkyCalendar/index.html
37•NaOH•3d ago•3 comments

Class-action suit claims Otter AI records private work conversations

https://www.npr.org/2025/08/15/g-s1-83087/otter-ai-transcription-class-action-lawsuit
71•nsedlet•2h ago•8 comments

SystemD Service Hardening

https://roguesecurity.dev/blog/systemd-hardening
176•todsacerdoti•11h ago•70 comments

Vibe coding tips and tricks

https://github.com/awslabs/mcp/blob/main/VIBE_CODING_TIPS_TRICKS.md
83•mooreds•3h ago•52 comments

MCP doesn't need tools, it needs code

https://lucumr.pocoo.org/2025/8/18/code-mcps/
137•the_mitsuhiko•6h ago•95 comments

MCP tools with dependent types

https://vlaaad.github.io/mcp-tools-with-dependent-types
56•vlaaad•6h ago•14 comments

8x19 Text Mode Font Origins

https://www.os2museum.com/wp/8x19-text-mode-font-origins/
48•userbinator•2d ago•16 comments

Texas law gives grid operator power to disconnect data centers during crisis

https://www.utilitydive.com/news/texas-law-gives-grid-operator-power-to-disconnect-data-centers-during-crisi/751587/
67•walterbell•2h ago•63 comments

The Lives and Loves of James Baldwin

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2025/08/18/baldwin-a-love-story-nicholas-boggs-book-review
63•Caiero•17h ago•11 comments

When you're asking AI chatbots for answers, they're data-mining you

https://www.theregister.com/2025/08/18/opinion_column_ai_surveillance/
111•rntn•4h ago•51 comments

Weather Radar APIs in 2025: A Founder's Complete Market Overview

https://www.rainviewer.com/blog/weather-radar-apis-2025-overview.html
18•sea-gold•2d ago•23 comments

AI is predominantly replacing outsourced, offshore workers

https://www.axios.com/2025/08/18/ai-jobs-layoffs
124•toomuchtodo•2h ago•105 comments

Scientists discover surprising language 'shortcuts' in birdsong – like humans

https://www.manchester.ac.uk/about/news/scientists-discover-surprising-language-shortcuts-in-birdsong--just-like-humans/
33•gnufx•4d ago•20 comments

The administration's assault on science feels eerily Soviet

https://grist.org/politics/the-trump-administrations-assault-on-science-feels-eerily-soviet/
16•rntn•35m ago•0 comments

LLMs and coding agents are a security nightmare

https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/llms-coding-agents-security-nightmare
129•flail•5h ago•65 comments