Ask HN: Is building for the web even worth it now?

28•spaceman_2020•1h ago

Of late, I’ve found my relationship with internet changing. I was here back in the early 2000s and it has always been the first place I go to for entertainment, advice, and work

But increasingly, I find myself completely disengaged with the internet. Every time I see a text post, I start asking myself: is this even a real person? Am I just talking to a bot?

Every time I see a yellow-tinged image on any of my social media feeds, I mentally switch off. I know it was made by AI and I just find it hard to engage with anything AI-made, no matter how good

Same for any AI video that pops up on my feed. It just doesn’t make me scroll past it, it makes me question why am I even here and I end up leaving

I know I can’t be the only one. I used to love the internet because it was one place where I could engage with people from all over the world. But now, it feels like I just spend half my energy on figuring out which one is real, which one is AI

The line will eventually blur and as a late 30s guy, I really don’t want to spend any more of my time on earth talking to a bot

As someone who used to create and build for the web, I find myself increasingly disengaged and discouraged. I’m pouring into a rapidly emptying cup

Anyone else feel the same way?

Comments

dutchbrit•1h ago

You are definitely not alone - I miss the days of small forums, articles not written by AI or for SEO etc...

I also miss the creatively built small websites where people shared their hobbies etc. "Social" media killed a lot.

The web is becoming less and less genuine, it's depressing.

mstipetic•1h ago

I've been on some weird path of discovery of the internet and am loving it. Generating my own ambient sounds for work from freesound.org. Finding internet radio stations to stream. Music from bandcamp and https://www.nts.live/. Rediscovering RSS and building my own tooling on top of it. You just have to be deliberate and step away from the convenience of big aggregators and algorithms and there's a whole wonderful world out there.

onion2k•1h ago

I just find it hard to engage with anything AI-made, no matter how good

I don't think this is true for many people.

The best example is the movie industry. Hollywood was using AI (in the form of convolutional neural networks mostly) a decade ago to produce CGI effects for film. The younger versions of the actors in Captain America: Civil War (2016) was basically done with AI. No one outside of movie effects and CGI nerds really cared. They just enjoyed the film because the AI was done well.

When AI is done really well you can't tell. It's similar to good design. If something is designed well you don't notice. You only ever see bad design. Same for AI, you only see it when it's bad.

(Someone will now reply to say they thought the effects in Captain America were terrible, obviously. :) )

piker•1h ago

Yes, but 100 or 1000x the amount of it and make grandma curate it and that analysis changes.

mattmanser•1h ago

That's not what anyone means when they talk about AI.

I wouldn't say the de-aging was done well, at best acceptably. I can only assume you've never watched The Irishman which really highlights the limitations and uncanny valley realms it's in.

dutchbrit•1h ago

The effects in Captain America were terrible - joking! The thing is, AI is plastered everywhere these days on platforms (that were already deteriorating before AI, lets be honest). A lot of people don't want to be bombed with fake content.

onion2k•1h ago

A lot of people don't want to be bombed with fake content.

People don't want to be bombed with obviously fake content. If the content is sufficiently good enough for them to accept it they'll happily click Like on it. And that bar is a heck of a lot lower for most people than you'd think. People crave novelty over almost every other attribute of content. They want to see things they've not seen before, and to share those things with their friends so they get the kudos of being the person who discovered something first.

exasperaited•1h ago

It is obvious that the generative AI era is different qualitatively. There are still some developments in non-generative AI that are having positive impacts but I think if you ask most people about what they understand about AI they are alarmed and concerned by it, or bored and depressed with it, on some level. This is caused by Generative AI and it will affect perceptions of all AI tools, causing growing cynicism, and this will rapidly spread to very broad distrust and loathing of the tech industry as a whole. This is not an industry people trust to bring liberating progress anymore; rather they see it as a machine that empowers arrogant, uncultured, fragile middle-aged male overlords.

It may be because I am British and we are cynical about the disruptive confidence of US tech people (especially two or three who loom over our politics, threatening to empower the very worst of them) or it may be that upwards of 90% of my friends are involved in the creative industry in some way, but there is no good feeling at the moment. Nobody is excited about what it will bring, and the interesting thing is that many of my friends who are unaware of the concerns about circular money movements or the AI bubble collapsing have a strong sense that an edifice is going collapse and take a lot of positive things with it.

We are not just heading towards an AI bubble collapse. We are heading towards a collapse in belief in progress at all, because every time we see progress, it is enshittified and "disrupted" by callous forces chained to grotesque private equity firms and the new kings.

m-i-l•1h ago

I think this is missing the point - it is a bit like saying "you only ever notice bad fraud, if the fraud is well done you never notice it". With AI in movies at the moment there are still people behind, and reviewing, the AI output, so it is just another creative tool. We're not yet at the point when someone enters a prompt and generates an entire 90 minute film and puts it online without even bothering to watch it themselves first, which is where we are with the internet. Personally, when I realised I've had my time wasted on some AI generated slop, especially when it is clear no-one has even had the decency to proof-read it, then I feel quite disrespected (to put it politely).

ktallett•1h ago

I have always been an offline only guy but I do see the need to build for the web. I feel small good at one thing tools are as useful as ever and can still have a place. The issue is people thinking every tool they need, use, or build, needs to incorporate the latest tech or reasoning behind it. A lot of needs have never changed, but the way we have met them for some reason has become far more complex and that is what needs to change.

0x6d61646f•1h ago

removing social media and focusing on the good parts of the internet is the best approach (and was even before AI trend)

you don't need social media, everybody as excuses as to why they're there, but none of them are real

self hosting saved most of the internet for me, from jellyfin for movies TV shows and movies to piped for YouTube

Degoogling and removing big tech from your life also helps a lot, changing from gmail to protonmail was a small change from the outside but it made how I interact with account creation and handling of my data so much more enjoyable

so I dont personally feel this way, but I dont engange with any part of the internet terrorized by AI (and human) slop

zkmon•1h ago

Well, you built it. You built internet and now dismantling it, or filling it with garbage. You can't complain as if it is being done by aliens. The transformation was very gradual and long the expected lines. There is nothing drastic. You knew it all along.

When you build a sand castle on a beach, you can't say you did not expect waves.

Are you a bot?

bayindirh•1h ago

> Anyone else feel the same way?

Actually yes, but as a result, I left the internet I know behind. I don't use Twitter (aka X) or Facebook. I'm following friends on Instagram, but not adding any photos to the training pool anymore. I read Reddit as a last resort.

I use a small Mastodon instance, follow people who are interesting. Read blogs of a select few, and discover new ones via their links or rings. Instead of IRC, I have found a Discord server frequented by the same people. Oh, also, I frequent here.

I also left GitHub because of their AI shenanigans and don't miss that place. I still use it for work reasons, but my code lives in quieter places. Left Google search for Kagi. Started to self-host things, cutting ties with online services more.

As a result, I'm building my own sub-internet with the resources I choose to use. I refuse to be bombarded with ads and AI-slop. I miss the old internet, but not the new one. The one I'm curating for myself serves all purposes for me.

ferrouswheel•1h ago

I'm also building out a sub-internet...

I have more media than I can ever watch, more ebooks/comics than I can read in 10 lifetimes, a copy of pre-2021 reddit, a copy of pre-2021 Wikipedia, etc etc.

I also have a physical library too, for the more crucial knowledge.

hollowturtle•1h ago

I believe you're conflating too much "the internet" with "your feed", you cna step away from any feed that exploits your attention and now does so easily with ai generated content. That's not the internet that's mostly social media. If you love builsing for the web why don't you and many others step up and start something new? You're even in the right place here. Whatever you want to do to make the web a place where you'd still hang out do it. But first, close the feed. The internet is not the feed, the feed is you behaving like a zombie

austin-cheney•1h ago

I know exactly how you feel. There is too much noise. It isn’t just the internet though. It’s phone calls, snail mail, and everywhere else conmen can try to steal parts of your attention.

This is the wrong way to look at this though because it would occur everywhere it could anyways.

Instead there are two things you should consider: what do you want to build and do you want it to work. Don’t worry about anything else.

I can’t fucking stand React so my career as a JavaScript developer is dead. I also can’t stand jquery or working with whiners and quitters too complicated by first world problems to learn things or apply any concept of engineering, so my career as a web developer has been dead for a very long time.

Nonetheless, I still build projects for the web because I enjoy JavaScript (now TypeScript). It’s fast and doesn’t force OOP decoration nonsense on you. It’s a great place to produce MVPs if you are comfortable with it at a low level. I don’t enjoy it for other people’s admiration. I enjoy it for the things I build primarily for personal use.

Do what you enjoy and make it work for you the way you want it to work.

manuelmoreale•1h ago

You are not alone in feeling that way but personally, I don't think it's like pouring into a rapidly emptying cup. I think that, relatively speaking, the signal vs noise ratio is changing and noise is increasing, percentage wise.

But in absolute terms, I think there's still A LOT of good, human content out there and the web is still full of interesting people worth following and engage with.

Personally I'm a big fan of blogs as a way to get to know people and see what they're up to. And those are still going strong. If you want to go down that path for example, there are plenty of starting point:

- The ooh.directory (https://ooh.directory) has thousands of blogs listed from all over the world - My own blogroll.org (https://blogroll.org) has just passed 1k blogs listed - Kagi has their own small web tool thingy https://kagi.com/smallweb

And then you even have even more old school style projects like the Internet Phone Book (https://internetphonebook.net)

Are.na (https://www.are.na) is also an excellent place to stumble on more quirky and obscure corners of the web.

The list goes on and on and on. Interesting content is still out there. And there are plenty of people who still maintain personal sites and forums. But in 2025 you're not going to just casually stumbled on them. You have to actively go hunt for them because everything is now getting drowned by the sea of AI garbage.

That's partly the reason why I started my people and Blogs (https://peopleandblogs.com) series a couple of years ago, to help people discover other humans more easily.

I think just accepting that the web is shit and we have to let it die is the wrong mindset. The web is, for you, what you make of it. If you want to find more interesting content, go search for it. And when you find it, share it on a space you control.

ferrouswheel•1h ago

Yes I feel the same way. Early 40s.

Even TikTok is just slopaganda, AI videos to promote fascism. So it's not just text, it's all content online only unless it's come from someone you trust and know.

thaumaturgy•1h ago

You're not alone. I've been on the web since around 1997, something like that. I remember it as a fun distraction, but also as a place that had recognizable handles, behind which sat a real person somewhere else in the world.

Unrestrained SEO and the failure of search engines (or, in Google's case, complicity veering towards enthusiastic support) to do anything about that was the first thing that, for me, took a lot of the fun out of the web.

Cheap botting, engagement farming, walled gardens, social media, and now AI has left me in a state of active avoidance. I don't feel good when I use the web. Like, any of it, at all.

Casual cruelty has always been a problem of online interaction, but at one time it was also balanced out by familiarity, friendliness sometimes, creativity ... but those things have gotten a lot harder to find.

The most engaging online interaction I've had recently has been some local community groups on Signal, and even that is best in small and infrequent doses.

piva00•1h ago

Also in my late 30s, and I've accepted that the web from the past we grew up in is gone.

One can find snippets of it here and there, stumbling upon a niche forum for a hobby is still exciting, participating in those and recognising the users over time, that sense of community still lurks around for some stuff. Overall it's just gone, it's not what the web is anymore.

Most of it has been monetised, captured in a few big platforms, closed off in walled gardens, made to be ephemeral. I don't mean that there isn't remnants of the old web at all, you can find some treasures around but there's no more discoverability for it, it's kinda like finding the underground scene of your city.

It's more than figuring out who is real and who is a bot, there's no sense of permanence of a community around, you don't recognise the names/nicknames to form any bond/rapport...

notarobot123•1h ago

There are a growing number of disillusioned makers that have the capacity to build alternatives - maybe that critical mass will lead to a reactive innovation cycle where an authentic and grassroots internet will reassert itself.

sim7c00•47m ago

you survived a lot longer than I did. I feel like this for a long time now. I just use it now to do research, check HN feed for some news / procrastinating when I'm bored. Despite posting here n there I kind of assume its just talking into the wind or getting reviewed by bots.

I even like AI somewhat, some things it produces. pretty pictures i guess. scfi-fi. but still its not engaging anymore, you get saturated very quickly if things are always available.

The internet seems pretty much dead for a long long time already. a few bastions here n there of maybe-real-people talking. I had some minor hope AI/ML might actually improve things, get rid a bit of the bubbles caused by algos, but its gotten much much worse actually.

AI is not the cause of the decline or rot, but its definitely accelerating it.

A lot of things I cared about are taken over by the loud-n-stupid bunch who yells only in blanket statements and never seems to be able to produce any sound reasoning or evidence for their discourse. i call them bots despite them likely being confused humans...

The worse thing is, that it seems now more and more actual people in the real world are mimicking this behavior. Trying to say smart things about topics they know nothing about, because if chatGPT can give some smart sounding lines, why shouldnt I be able to? I am researcher of technology and the number of times people hand my vibe-coded or written totalgarbage to review or fix, (papers, experiments etc.). Their capacity to think and reason is diminishing fast. They will be fierce and toxic if you highlight this as a concern, or point at any of their hallucinations.

I've expeirenced already a few times that people, like a group of zombies, gang up on me (debate/argument) and all jump on arguments which are trivially proven to be incorrect. Even if you prove them incorrect infront of them, they will just try to eat your brain/prove you wrong by talking louder etc. - and these are 'highly educated individuals'.

Considering to leave my research job, after about 12 years of trying to work myself into such a position, and just go back where i started.. to drive a forklift. its more likely i'd be working with real humans there. and if it's a robot, atleast its a real fuckin robot, not one of these infiltrator units...

oladipomd•34m ago

How are we sure you are not a bot? Wait, am I a bot?

poisonborz•22m ago

This happens for decades - Eternal September, email spam, login-only social networks, curated algorithmic feeds - AI is but one late-stage catalysator. I'm actually glad that the change happens faster. Every revolution needs a high pressure tipping point. The internet changed from being a niche platform to an actually global (if not main) scene of society, with all the very human abuse, crime, slave work, authoritarian controls that come with it. I'm excited for what the same forces - that created the early internet - will now make over these emptied fiber veins.

ch_fr•9m ago

You should probably engage more with (or find) your hobbies, because this definitely feels like a "recommendation algorithms decide what I see" issue.

There are extensions that disable youtube's recommended page and redirect you to your subscriptions page.

There are extensions that disable twitter's for-you tab.

If you're using said sites' mobile apps, uninstall them and use stuff like Revanced or whatever.

You don't need to radically disconnect from everything, there are smaller steps that can be taken to make "being online" a radically better experience.

RegreSQL: Regression Testing for PostgreSQL Queries

Nano Banana can be prompt engineered for nuanced AI image generation

Show HN: Pegma, the free and open-source version of the classic Peg solitaire

What Happened with the CIA and The Paris Review?

Hooked on Sonics: Experimenting with Sound in 19th-Century Popular Science

Disrupting the first reported AI-orchestrated cyber espionage campaign

Launch HN: Tweeks (YC W25) – Browser extension to deshittify the web

How to Get a North Korea / Antarctica VPS

Why I'm Learning Sumerian

Sarah Mason, inventor of the continuity script, first script supervisor

Operating Margins

650GB of Data (Delta Lake on S3). Polars vs. DuckDB vs. Daft vs. Spark

OpenMANET Wi-Fi HaLow open-source project for Raspberry Pi–based MANET radios

Think in math, write in code (2019)

Blender Lab

'The Dream Factory' Review: A Building and Its Bard

A Brutal Look at Balanced Parentheses, Computing Machines, and Pushdown Automata

Why do we need dithering?

The Floating Head Phenomenon

Kubernetes Ingress Nginx is retiring

SlopStop: Community-driven AI slop detection in Kagi Search

Blue Origin lands New Glenn rocket booster on second try

Steam Machine

Show HN: DBOS Java – Postgres-Backed Durable Workflows

SIMA 2: An agent that plays, reasons, and learns with you in virtual 3D worlds

Android developer verification: Early access starts

Zed is our office

The Eggstraordinary Fortress

Itiner-E – The Digital Atlas of Ancient Roads

Checkout.com hacked, refuses ransom payment, donates to security labs