frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Made with ♥ by @iamnishanth

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

World’s most powerful literary critic is on TikTok

https://www.newstatesman.com/culture/books/2026/01/the-worlds-most-powerful-literary-critic-is-on-tiktok
22•insistey•13h ago

Comments

dang•1h ago
I expected that to be a hit job but it's actually rather poignant.
Xmd5a•1h ago
poignant?

> His next major growth spurt came when his university career ended. When Oxford University rejected his master’s application in 2020, Edwards posted a video of himself crying, entitled “oxford university rejected my masters application… (sorry this video is sad)”. Social media rewards confession. Authenticity, sincerity and vulnerability were important – more important than orthodox intellectual baubles.

It's literally pathetic.

    pathetic
    /pəˈθɛtɪk/
    arousing pity, especially through vulnerability or sadness.
    "she looked so pathetic that I bent down to comfort her"
tolerance•46m ago
Please don't post snark to HN threads. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

(I felt the same way when I read this paragraph and the one about Jack being a target of abuse but I couldn’t resist an opportunity to ‘dang’ a ‘dang’ thread. At the same time it is touching how Jack has forged some semblance of a real world community out of this. I still can’t take what he does serious as a whole and I’m not warm to the idea that the “World’s most powerful literary critic is on TikTok” and I do have a sort of apathy toward the cultural intrigue borne from people in their twenties today. Like dang I was expecting a hit piece and was no less impressed to find it the opposite—fluff. Both poignant in some ways and pathetic in most per my own sensibilities.)

direwolf20•45m ago
Backseat moderation is also against the guidelines.
sph•23m ago
Oh, the irony.
Permit•23m ago
It's always amusing that you cannot tell people this rule without in fact breaking it yourself.
Avicebron•20m ago
I mean yeah? I'm pretty sure BookTok is a form of porn after I heard a friend describe it, which would make TFA like fanfic. Idk, there's this whole thing I'm calling "Darcy-Core" which isn't a real term but I don't have a better categorization.
kubb•1h ago
I wish we had more plurality. Not just convergence on one ultra influencer for books, but an ecosystem, with offerings tailored to audiences.
swang•1h ago
I had to go through a cookie request, a subscribe to us popup and then had to close another popup telling me I could only read two articles.
squigz•1h ago
Install uBlock Origin and you won't see any of that
dmix•1h ago
uBlock doesn’t handle euro cookie banners by default
squigz•1h ago
Yeah, I think you have to enable a couple extra filter lists to get rid of cookie banners and some of the other annoying popups that aren't strictly "ads"
firtoz•1h ago
Prefix the whole url with `archive.is` e.g. `archive.is/https://www.newstatesman.com/culture/books/2026/01/the-world...`

This will work on most article sites to show you an archived version of it without any of these annoyances

IlikeMadison•1h ago
> "The world’s most powerful literary critic"

yea, a 28 yo youtuber/tiktoker/influencer/poser/whatever nobody heard about, posting videos about his bookshelves is the most powerful literary critic. right. get off your high horse.

jasonlotito•1h ago
Your ignorance doesn't make reality.
nlawalker•1h ago
>on YouTube, has 1.5 million subscribers and 158 million views
sph•26m ago
There are 8 billion people on this Earth. It is an extraordinary claim to say that a channel with 1.5 million subscribers is the "world's most powerful" in its niche.

Unless, and much more likely, this is clickbait and by world only USA, or the Western world at best, is considered; of those, only the terminally-online that seek literary criticism on TikTok.

cdrini•44m ago
Depends on how you define power, and the article is defining it as influence. Do Jack Edwards reviews influence a substantial population of people to buy/read certain books? Seems like yes. If he's the world's most powerful, that depends on if others are _more_ influential. I personally don't know of any individual who has as big a following that influences reading. So the claim holds for me and doesn't seem hyperbolic.
3rodents•59m ago
Worlds collide. Jack is a hack. Literally. He does not review books in any meaningful capacity, he takes other people’s reviews and restates them. He doesn’t read most of the books. He is, unfortunately, the perfect example of a social media something. Entirely performative, zero substance. The article hand waves it away as online abuse (“Edwards is subject to copious online abuse”) but doesn’t interrogate it. Maybe, if he is so often accused of plagiarism and not reading books… there is something to it? You only need to actually watch his videos (and not these fawning articles) to realize the complete absence of any literary critique. There are thousands of thoughtful literary critics on TikTok and YouTube, it is sad to see Jack stealing their work and credit. He has great agents though.
HPsquared•33m ago
They said most powerful, not highest quality! These are very different things.
terespuwash•52m ago
I acknowledge his expertise in literature. I find his approach to non-fiction sometimes less insightful and note a recent shift toward following popular book trends but it’s still great to see his videos.
jalev•51m ago
I went and looked at the Tiktoks. As far as I can see from the few videos I've watched it's not so much "criticism" as "plot overview, small background details, and what I liked about it".

It's kind of weird it's being framed as a tiktok sensation when there's nothing to really differenciate him from other booktokers? Other than perhaps more subscribers than usual.

Also, per the article:

> Edwards champions BookTok and also defends it...

Kind of interesting to note given his video saying he doesn't like booktok books[1]. I suppose he knows not to piss in the pond he drinks from.

[1] https://youtu.be/AuEipfQbHrU

publicdebates•34m ago
You misunderstand the nature of newspapers. Playing devil's advocate just a little here, I absolutely can see the financial benefit of an author taking a single epitome out of a group of near clones, even a random one among them at that, and placing him right on top of a pedestal positioned just before a podium. The more details the audience drowns in, no matter how truthful, the more you simply clutter your narrative with unfortunate facts and drown out the whole point. I'm not saying the author is lying, nor advocating it. But sometimes a slice of the truth is more useful than the whole pi of it in a given moment for a given story.
BoredPositron•40m ago
influence ≠ powerful I admit if you are permanently only this might blend together.
cdrini•9m ago
Second definition of power on Google: "the capacity or ability to direct or influence the behavior of others or the course of events." Influence is a reasonable part of the definition.
leoc•17m ago
How good is the book he successfully sold to HarperCollins, The Uni-Verse? Either he's pretty good, or he was quite lucky, or he had some inside track.
xorvoid•15m ago
This is garbage clickbait that's unworthy of HN front page. I'm disappointed.
mullingitover•7m ago
Sort of an aside, but what's next now that Tiktok is deeply into end-stage enshittification? It'd dead now, a formerly fun app morphed into grotesque eyeball milking system owned by one of the worst people on the planet. I deleted the app this week after the feed ramped ad content up to being an ad every other video, frequently with ads back to back to back.

It's cooked.

A macOS app that blurs your screen when you slouch

https://github.com/tldev/posturr
276•dnw•3h ago•107 comments

Using PostgreSQL as a Dead Letter Queue for Event-Driven Systems

https://www.diljitpr.net/blog-post-postgresql-dlq
87•tanelpoder•3h ago•24 comments

Doom has been ported to an earbud

https://doombuds.com
218•arin-s•7h ago•68 comments

A flawed paper in Management Science has been cited more than 6,000 times

https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2026/01/22/aking/
521•timr•10h ago•278 comments

World’s most powerful literary critic is on TikTok

https://www.newstatesman.com/culture/books/2026/01/the-worlds-most-powerful-literary-critic-is-on...
22•insistey•13h ago•28 comments

The AI Revolution in Coding: Why I'm Ignoring the Prophets of Doom

https://codingismycraft.blog/index.php/2026/01/23/the-ai-revolution-in-coding-why-im-ignoring-the...
8•mmphosis•15m ago•1 comments

Web-based image editor modeled after Deluxe Paint

https://github.com/steffest/DPaint-js
101•bananaboy•6h ago•7 comments

Google confirms 'high-friction' sideloading flow is coming to Android

https://www.androidauthority.com/google-sideloading-android-high-friction-process-3633468/
510•_____k•5d ago•539 comments

ICE Using Palantir Tool That Feeds on Medicaid Data

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2026/01/report-ice-using-palantir-tool-feeds-medicaid-data
322•JKCalhoun•1h ago•153 comments

Introduction to PostgreSQL Indexes

https://dlt.github.io/blog/posts/introduction-to-postgresql-indexes/
224•dlt•11h ago•12 comments

What Is Starlink Mesh? – Starlink Help Center

https://starlink.com/ca/support/article/57f4bd5c-4125-2210-8bb2-30c90b558b7b
9•janandonly•1h ago•3 comments

Show HN: Bonsplit – Tabs and splits for native macOS apps

https://bonsplit.alasdairmonk.com
143•sgottit•7h ago•20 comments

Publishing on the ATmosphere

https://tynanistyping.offprint.app/a/3mcsvjjceei23-publishing-on-the-atmosphere
11•danabramov•5d ago•4 comments

Show HN: TUI for managing XDG default applications

https://github.com/mitjafelicijan/xdgctl
86•mitjafelicijan•8h ago•24 comments

Show HN: Netfence – Like Envoy for eBPF Filters

https://github.com/danthegoodman1/netfence
28•dangoodmanUT•4h ago•5 comments

ANN v3: 200ms p99 query latency over 100B vectors

https://turbopuffer.com/blog/ann-v3
75•_peregrine_•3d ago•24 comments

Jurassic Park - Tablet device on Nedry's desk? (2012)

https://www.therpf.com/forums/threads/jurassic-park-tablet-device-on-nedrys-desk.169883/
123•exvi•10h ago•43 comments

Nango (YC W23, Dev Infrastructure) Is Hiring Remotely

https://jobs.ashbyhq.com/Nango
1•bastienbeurier•7h ago

Social Dynamics at Arm's Length

https://www.jenn.site/social-truths-at-arms-length/
10•surprisetalk•4d ago•5 comments

Wine-Staging 11.1 Adds Patches for Enabling Recent Photoshop Versions on Linux

https://www.phoronix.com/news/Wine-Staging-11.1
85•LorenDB•4h ago•26 comments

The Rebirth of Pennsylvania's Infamous Burning Town

https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/centralia-pennsylvania-rebirth
53•pbshgthm•5d ago•25 comments

I built a 2x faster lexer, then discovered I/O was the real bottleneck

https://modulovalue.com/blog/syscall-overhead-tar-gz-io-performance/
123•modulovalue•5d ago•60 comments

150k lines of vibe coded Elixir: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

https://getboothiq.com/blog/150k-lines-vibe-coded-elixir-good-bad-ugly
43•InternetGiant•8h ago•33 comments

A Lament for Aperture

https://ikennd.ac/blog/2026/01/old-man-yells-at-modern-software-design/
192•firloop•4d ago•50 comments

Sony Data Discman

https://huguesjohnson.com/random/sony-ebook/
74•naves•11h ago•15 comments

Alarm overload is undermining safety at sea as crews face thousands of alerts

https://www.lr.org/en/knowledge/press-room/press-listing/press-release/2026/alarm-overload-is-und...
110•geox•6h ago•74 comments

Bridging the Gap Between PLECS and SPICE

https://erickschulz.dev/posts/plecs-spice/
21•eschu•8h ago•7 comments

Deutsche Telekom is throttling the internet

https://netzbremse.de/en/
493•tietjens•11h ago•237 comments

Adoption of EVs tied to real-world reductions in air pollution: study

https://keck.usc.edu/news/adoption-of-electric-vehicles-tied-to-real-world-reductions-in-air-poll...
538•hhs•19h ago•519 comments

Hands-On with Two Apple Network Server Prototype ROMs

http://oldvcr.blogspot.com/2026/01/hands-on-with-two-apple-network-server.html
48•todsacerdoti•11h ago•1 comments