Allowlisting some Bash commands is often the same as allowlisting all

https://www.joinformal.com/blog/allowlisting-some-bash-commands-is-often-the-same-as-allowlisting-all-with-claude-code/

37•drewgregory•1w ago

Comments

teddyh•1w ago

“…with Claude Code”

adastra22•1w ago

Are there any agent permission systems that do this correctly?

extraduder_ire•1w ago

The same caveats would apply to most kinds of restricted shell environments.

zufallsheld•1w ago

Same thing for allowing specific sudo-commands. Many tools (like vim or the tools mentioned in the article) would have the same problem when allowing them to be run with root privileges.

denysvitali•1w ago

=> https://gtfobins.org/

Terr_•6d ago

Now I feel a bit more justified for over-engineering my automatic restic backup to not run as root, but to instead use "capabilities" to read files it doesn't own.

Namely, CAP_DAC_READ_SEARCH [0] and related systemd settings. The only problem is that it inhibits using a convenience/wrapper script.

[0] https://www.man7.org/linux/man-pages/man7/capabilities.7.htm...

illusive4080•1w ago

Some at work want to let me run sudo vim only to edit my hosts file. This is silly for a variety of reasons, one of them being that vim can allow the user to exec arbitrary commands. If you give me root for vim, just save me the trouble and let me have unrestricted root so I can do my job.

bauruine•1w ago

I had the same few years ago. When I pointed out that I can get full root with most of the whitelisted commands they answered "We know. It's not about security but to prevent lusers from accidentally rm -rf /* the server. Feel free to spawn a root shell. You obviously know what you do"

CableNinja•1w ago

I deal with some regulated things and some users who usually wouldnt be allowed to see/work on a thing are granted special access to do so, with extreme limitations. Recently i was approached asking if we could strip down the users desktops to no gui, no sudo, for use as a jumpbox. I explained why users need sudo to do what they need, and was asked about limiting sudo.

Its really tough to tell someone who is all about security (not linux security but regulatory security and such) that basically granting any bit of sudo access can lead to full access.

There is a way that this can be handled, but its honestly sort of an afterthought functionality. facls. You can delegate multiple owners/groups and permissions for things, and it can work well, but you have to deal with facls on multiple fronts, setting them for basically the entire system. facls are great, in theory, but they feel like such an afterthought that they are often ignored.

bloppe•1w ago

You could provide decently meaningful and targeted sandboxing using mount namespaces and an overlay FS, while retaining sudo privileges for what you need to do.

sadnboxx•1w ago

Allowing a "command" (executable, I believe) that isn't a read-only absolute path is a fool's errand. I will modify PATH and run my own implementation of it.

pimlottc•1w ago

I know they’re just being through but the “go test” part is a bit “Pray, Mr Babbage”… Test code is just code. I know of no language where tests are sandboxed in any meaningful way.

bloppe•1w ago

They're sandboxed if you use bazel. Not as much as the nix people would like, but bazel tests get read-only access to the host filesystem except /tmp

pimlottc•1w ago

Right, I should have said there are conventions and libraries you can use to limit the scope of tests but that requires intention and diligence. But fundamentally , “go tests” could run anything a normal go program can.

eqvinox•1w ago

everything is a container these days, and yet somehow collective-we don't manage to have AI agents run in a container layer on top of our current work, so we can later commit or rollback?

Neywiny•1w ago

I feel like if I ever used an agentic AI that's how I'd need it to be done. Too many cases of AIs getting access to files that it shouldn't. But then then, how do I allow it to look things up online without sending all my code to some scammer that prompt injected on a tutorial? I don't think I'll ever trust it with anything proprietary or otherwise less than publicly available.

iberator•1w ago

What do you mean?! Where? I would claim otherwise: 99% of software is not in the containers. Like 100% windows or debian software

slipheen•5d ago

I don't know much about how windows software is packaged, but I find that a solid majority of desktop software I use is in flatpack and server software in OCI images

hbogert•1w ago

> I really thought `eval` would not be abused on non validated input

    - your colleague, or you 1 year before.

with•6d ago

True, you can do almost anything if find is allowlisted.

find / -exec sh -c 'whatever u wanna do' \;

bandrami•6d ago

I'm sorry but the idea of giving an AI agent a non-restricted shell is insane. If you don't want it to perform certain commands those commands should not be in its environment at all.

totetsu•6d ago

I remember when I was starting out, someone on my team showed me, that in the case where we were allowed to run vi and root on a machine there was noting stopping one from just starting a child shell from within vi with root privileges.

AllegedAlec•6d ago

Not entirely related to the content but man 'allowlisting' reads so badly. We should just out of ease of reading return to whitelisting.

slipheen•5d ago

I'm trying not to get nerdsniped, but in the realm of subjective pragmatics, I personally find `allowlisting` to be drastically more clear.

AllegedAlec•5d ago

My concern isn't really clarity of intention, but that 'allowlisting' just doesn't flow as well when reading as whitelisting does.

DoNotNotify is now Open Source

Show HN: LocalGPT – A local-first AI assistant in Rust with persistent memory

Matchlock: Linux-based sandboxing for AI agents

Reverse Engineering Raiders of the Lost Ark for the Atari 2600

Haskell for all: Beyond agentic coding

SectorC: A C Compiler in 512 bytes (2023)

LLMs as the new high level language

The Architecture of Open Source Applications (Volume 1) Berkeley DB

Software factories and the agentic moment

Modern and Antique Technologies Reveal a Dynamic Cosmos

Speed up responses with fast mode

LineageOS 23.2

Stories from 25 Years of Software Development

Hoot: Scheme on WebAssembly

uLauncher

Brookhaven Lab's RHIC concludes 25-year run with final collisions

Vocal Guide – belt sing without killing yourself

In the Australian outback, we're listening for nuclear tests

Wood Gas Vehicles: Firewood in the Fuel Tank (2010)

Rabbit Ear "Origami": programmable origami in the browser (JS)

Show HN: I saw this cool navigation reveal, so I made a simple HTML+CSS version

First Proof

Substack confirms data breach affects users’ email addresses and phone numbers

Start all of your commands with a comma (2009)

Al Lowe on model trains, funny deaths and working with Disney

The AI boom is causing shortages everywhere else

OpenCiv3: Open-source, cross-platform reimagining of Civilization III

Where did all the starships go?

Show HN: A luma dependent chroma compression algorithm (image compression)

Show HN: Look Ma, No Linux: Shell, App Installer, Vi, Cc on ESP32-S3 / BreezyBox