Like, I get that leaf functions with truly huge computational cores are a thing that would benefit from more ISA-visible registers, but... don't we have GPUs for that now? And TPUs? NPUs? Whatever those things are called?
On a 16 register machine with 9 call-clobbered registers and 7 call-invariant ones (one of which is the stack pointer) we put 6 temporaries into call-invariant registers (so there are 6 spills in the prologue of this big function), another 9 into the call-clobbered registers; 2 of those 9 are the helper function's arguments, but 7 other temporaries have to be spilled to survive the call. And the rest 25 temporaries live on the stack in the first place.
If we instead take a machine with 31 registers, 19 being call-clobbered and 12 call-invariant ones (one of which is a stack pointer), we can put 11 temporaries into call-invariant registers (so there are 11 spills in the prologue of this big function), and another 19 into the call-clobbered registers; 2 of those 19 are the helper function's arguments, so 17 other temporaries have to be spilled to survive the call. And the rest of 10 temporaries live on the stack in the first place.
So, there seems to be more spilling/reloading whether you count pre-emptive spills or the on-demand-at-the-call-site spills, at least to me.
That would be a major headache — even if current instruction encodings were somehow preserved.
It’s not just about compilers and assemblers. Every single system implementing virtualization has a software emulation of the instruction set - easily 10k lines of very dense code/tables.
sylware•2h ago