It's not just this hospital, it's widespread ([1] report 38%)
[1] https://www.emro.who.int/emhj-volume-26-2020/volume-26-issue...
It’s exactly the same way with contact lenses. When I was in college in the ’90s, I could get a pair of permanent contact lenses. They would cost a few hundred bucks, but they would last me several years if the prescription didn’t change. They were the same as glasses. You would clean them everyday and disinfect them, and they would serve quite well permanently.
But the contact lens industry decided that wasn’t good enough, and decided that they could sell subscription services for contact lenses that you would need to discard every night.
And those daily wear contact lenses, the disposable kind, basically forced out of the market the permanent ones and now the optometrist regards me as a Martian when I request permanent lenses instead.
That's driving the insistence on injections, and rural doctors/clinics cutting corners.
That's 4 cents per syringe. Seems quite reasonable to me. Seems they don't have economics as an excuse.
https://ailaaj.pk/products/apple-disposable-syringe-5ml-100s
It's less about the money and more about the logistics of transporting and stocking these goods in a country that doesn't have decent basic infrastructure.
See?
> An injection was provided during 53% of patient visits in Rawalpindi and 92% in Tando Allah Yar
> Patients from Tando Allah Yar reported a mean 3.8 visits to a healthcare provider by a member of their household during the previous month, compared to 2.5 by those from Rawalpindi (Table 2). During all such visits, an injection was given. Overall, 56% patients felt that an injection was necessary. Such perceptions were higher in Tando Allah Yar than in Rawalpindi (79% vs. 39%) (Table 2). Providers reciprocated such perceptions in that 44–56% of providers felt that an injection was required for common ailments such as fever, influenza, body aches or diarrhoea.
> Patients expect to receive injections for minor ailments such as fever or influenza-like symptoms and willingly pay for these, on the mistaken belief in the efficacy of injections to overcome common symptoms that eventually abate with time (10). Healthcare providers comply with such wishes and are convinced of the necessity of injections.
> We have previously demonstrated that the total national supply of syringes in Pakistan is sufficient to meet the demand for the ~1.1 billion syringes used annually for immunization, diabetes, laboratory testing and drug administration in clinics or hospitals
On the last point, I did a bit of a search to look for the total number of syringes used worldwide. I'm actually questioning whether that number is using similar methodology to arrive at the ~1.1 billion number, since I'm seeing numbers around 15 billion for the annual number of injections - meaning that Pakistan would be using over double the average per-capita number of syringes (and re-using many of them) while simultaneously having a population that's much younger (23 vs 31 median age) and poorer ($7k vs $26k median PPP/capita) than average.
If those numbers check out, the simple solution would just be to stop giving unnecessary injections, money would be saved, and there'd be no need to reuse syringes.
Do you mean "developing?" This is not common practice in rich Western countries.
Additionally, as sibling has already pointed out, sterile disposable syringes are extremely cheap.
Does anyone have alternative archival sites? I want to switch away from archive.today because of the uncivil behavior [1] but can't find any other archival sites that can unpaywall websites.
[1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/02/wikipedia-might-...
It includes the website, the live streaming BBC News TV channel, and a library of documentaries.
If you're not willing to do that, it's "uncivil" to pirate their content, wouldn't you say?
The cost of a new needle, syringe or new gloves is quite cheap.
The cost of an infection is high.
The cost of a HIV infection is life altering.
So, its clear that whoever did this thought that whatever small savings they obtained from not using a fresh syringe was more important to them than the high likelihood their patients would get infections, including HIV.
t1234s•1h ago
mothballed•1h ago
corndoge•1h ago
FTA
> Our investigation suggests that unsafe practices are in part driven by systemic pressures including a reliance on, and cultural preference for, injections as treatment.
> Pakistan has one of the highest rates of therapeutic injections in the world, many of them medically unnecessary. Members of the general public ask for them, including for their children, and doctors happily oblige, says Mir.
Stop making shit up
mothballed•1h ago
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vacci...
https://www.cgdev.org/blog/white-house-bans-cia-use-vaccine-...
killing of vaccine workers:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10185917/
Not made up. Although I would understand why people might think it's crazy enough that it would be.
corndoge•58m ago
mothballed•54m ago
I did claim Pakistanis have executed vaccine workers ("circumspect people with needles").... because as I cited they have. In part because they have been used as CIA operations.
SanjayMehta•27m ago
This goes back to the polio vaccination campaign started in the 1990s. Bin Laden op happened in 2010-2011.
Polio workers were being chased away and lynched longer that. [1]
Still happening BTW [2]
[1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2727330/ [2] https://www.rediff.com/news/report/polio-team-attacked-in-pa...
calmworm•1h ago
ceejayoz•1h ago
Not gonna fix this with education if they won't admit to having a problem in the first place.
plutomeetsyou•56m ago
ceejayoz•45m ago
jabedude•56m ago
supjeff•35m ago
esalman•28m ago
Too bad Elon got rid of it.
OutOfHere•31m ago