frontpage.
newsnewestaskshowjobs

Open Source @Github

fp.

Open in hackernews

How much of Thermo Fisher's antibody data has been manipulated?

https://reeserichardson.blog/2026/05/28/how-much-of-thermo-fishers-antibody-data-has-been-manipulated/
45•mhrmsn•4h ago

Comments

DonsDiscountGas•1h ago
Concerning but not really surprising. They offer about hundred thousand antibodies, a few hundred frauds is likely the tip of the iceberg.

> “Similar image” searches using Google Lens, Bing Images or DuckDuckGo betray hundreds more that we have yet to document

In my experience these would return any image of an antibody PCR, not just the exactly matching background. Would be curious to hear others thoughts.

Amorymeltzer•1h ago
Without engaging in your point, small nitpick: These are images of Western blots[1], not PCR.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_blot

boxed•8m ago
From the comments on the article by the author it looks more like 10% so far and they haven't systematically looked. That means ~10% if a probable floor of how much fraud there is.
noodlesUK•54m ago
Exactly what is the "data" that's being shown here? Is it essentially some kind of marketing material showing "this sort of thing is what you should expect to see" or is it actually data or for compliance? If it's essentially marketing material or an instructional example that isn't meant to be representative it being magically clearer than real life doesn't seem like a great sin (unless it's being claimed it is representative). If it's something to be relied upon for compliance or as data to be used, that's pretty damming.
voidUpdate•46m ago
> "This image is supposed to demonstrate that the antibody being sold works as intended. It is labeled as “Advanced Verification” data on Thermo Fisher’s site"

(links to https://www.thermofisher.com/uk/en/home/life-science/antibod...)

I think it is technically marketing material, but if you have to fabricate your marketing material, that's not a good sign that the material is accurate. If I buy a car based on an advert where it shows the car going at 300 mph, and in real life it maxes out at 30mph, that's misleading advertising and something should be done about it.

Given that "at Thermo Fisher, a single vial containing a 0.1 mL aliquot of antibody solution typically costs 400 to 500 USD", you'd want to have accurate marketing material before buying it

noodlesUK•41m ago
It definitely isn't a good look but I'm not entirely sure where this lands on "the line drawing on my IKEA instruction manual doesn't look like the furniture" to "VW diesel emissions report" spectrum. I'd appreciate if any bioscientists in the audience could clear that up a bit.
flobosg•29m ago
arcade79•12m ago
I have no idea about this catalogue, however, looking at the article and how the image manipulation has happened - it looks very much like "repro" work back in the day.

Anything that large companies published in/as magazines, etc, back in the 80/90s first went to a design company. Then to a repro company for the "finishing touches" to make it look nice. Faces were touched up, photo artifacts was removed, everything was to look neat and tidy.

This looks so much like that. I wouldn't be surprised if Thermo Fisher still ran everything that is to be published through a marketing/repro cycle, who has tampered with this without realizing what it looks like.

It'll be interesting to see if any actual data has been changed, or just the presentation of the data.

From the article:

> This image is supposed to demonstrate that the antibody being sold works as intended. (…) Antibodies are near-ubiquitous but notoriously fickle laboratory reagents in biomedical research. For many applications, it is absolutely crucial that the antibodies that you use are selective (i.e., the antibody binds strongly to the target protein) and specific (i.e., the antibody binds to the protein of interest and little else).

Antibodies showing a different picture (Western blot) than what is expected can drastically change the interpretation of the results as well as the conclusion of a study, for example. It may also encourage scientific fraud by authors by forcing them to unknowingly/coincidentally make to a blot image the same (or similar) fraudulent modifications performed by the vendor.

Now I’m curious about how much of the blot photoshopping present in retracted papers can be attributed to these misleading verification data.

raverbashing•11m ago
I would be more worried if the blotted area was different (the dark blob) - or if data in a datasheet (something like test specificity, level of detection, etc) was wrong

Now, if while preparing the images they needed to do some editorial choices (or it is well possible a person in the editorial group was told to 'enhance the images' but wasn't aware of the details) because of limitations in doing the experiment then this is probably not a big deal

jhart99•25m ago
This is 'used car salesman' levels of fraud on that scale. People rapidly acknowledge these antibodies work or they don't. There are websites with reviews of them. However in addition to getting ripped off for a few hundred bucks, these antibodies are generally produced by immunizing animals and by faking this data they are unnecessarily increasing the discomfort to these animals for a fraudulent reason. Look up the Santa Cruz antibody scandal for more of that.

The Cypherpunk Library

https://www.cypherpunkbooks.com
121•yu3zhou4•3h ago•17 comments

Dopamine Fracking

https://igerman.cc/blog/dopamine-fracking/
392•igmn•9h ago•194 comments

1k Data Breaches Later, the Disclosure Lag Is Worse

https://www.troyhunt.com/1000-data-breaches-later-the-disclosure-lag-is-worse-than-ever/
170•882542F3884314B•8h ago•63 comments

A Family Project (2022)

https://bittersoutherner.com/feature/2022/a-family-project
37•surprisetalk•2d ago•2 comments

Building from zero after addiction, prison, and a felony

https://gavinray97.github.io/blog/building-from-zero-after-addiction-prison-felony
673•gavinray•17h ago•297 comments

APC–2 – A professional record cutter for producing original playback discs

https://teenage.engineering/products/apc-2
223•vthommeret•10h ago•120 comments

How much of Thermo Fisher's antibody data has been manipulated?

https://reeserichardson.blog/2026/05/28/how-much-of-thermo-fishers-antibody-data-has-been-manipul...
45•mhrmsn•4h ago•11 comments

Spherical Voronoi Diagram

https://www.jasondavies.com/maps/voronoi/
27•marysminefnuf•4d ago•9 comments

The Smallest Brain You Can Build: A Perceptron in Python

https://ranpara.net/posts/perceptron-explained-from-scratch/
210•DevarshRanpara•11h ago•37 comments

Richard Scolyer Has Died

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c14yz5jg476o
82•nicwilson•7h ago•19 comments

Playing with Vision Embeddings

https://prestonbjensen.com/posts/playing-with-vision-embeddings
70•prestoj•2d ago•6 comments

OneDrive data now has an expiry date

https://ms365news.com/blogs/f/your-onedrive-data-now-has-an-expiry-data
87•taubek•3h ago•71 comments

The EU Open Source Strategy

https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/policies/open-source-strategy
83•vrganj•3h ago•40 comments

New drug 'functionally cures' many hepatitis B virus infections

https://www.science.org/content/article/new-drug-functionally-cures-many-hepatitis-b-virus-infect...
195•gmays•10h ago•35 comments

Zig Structs of Arrays (2024)

https://andreashohmann.com/zig-struct-of-arrays/
8•Tomte•4d ago•1 comments

Making peace with your unlived dreams (2023)

https://nik.art/making-peace-with-your-unlived-dreams/
247•herbertl•17h ago•142 comments

Algorithmic Monocultures in Hiring

https://algorithmichiring.github.io/
110•drchiu•9h ago•45 comments

DeepSeek V4 Pro beats GPT-5.5 Pro on precision

https://runtimewire.com/article/deepseek-v4-pro-beats-gpt-5-5-pro-on-precision
297•yogthos•10h ago•145 comments

Tiny hackable CUDA language model implementation

https://github.com/markusheimerl/gpt
37•markusheimerl•2d ago•2 comments

Show HN: I Derived a Pancake

https://www.absurdlyoptimized.com/recipes/pancakes/
254•bkazez•3d ago•102 comments

Age verification tech could put children at greater risk, says think tank

https://www.computerweekly.com/news/366643835/Age-verification-tech-could-put-children-at-greater...
59•robtherobber•4h ago•16 comments

Replies to comments on my "LLMs are eroding my career" post

https://human-in-the-loop.bearblog.dev/replies-to-comments-on-my-llms-are-eroding-my-career-post/
60•omblivion•1h ago•71 comments

A Matter Wi-Fi Light Bulb in Rust on the Raspberry Pi Pico 2 W

https://github.com/melastmohican/rust-rpico2-embassy-examples
129•melastmohican•11h ago•19 comments

Config Files That Run Code: Supply Chain Security Blindspot

https://safedep.io/config-files-that-run-code/
4•signa11•2h ago•0 comments

What is the purpose of the lost+found folder in Linux and Unix? (2014)

https://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/18154/what-is-the-purpose-of-the-lostfound-folder-in-lin...
202•tosh•3d ago•71 comments

Show HN: Lathe – Use LLMs to learn a new domain, not skip past it

https://github.com/devenjarvis/lathe
329•devenjarvis•1d ago•58 comments

The 29th International Obfuscated C Code Contest (IOCCC) 2025 Winners

https://www.ioccc.org/2025/
398•matt_d•1d ago•90 comments

How's Linear so fast? A technical breakdown

https://performance.dev/how-is-linear-so-fast-a-technical-breakdown
427•howToTestFE•16h ago•198 comments

A discovery about GCC's unidirectional rotation algorithm

https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20260603-00/?p=112378
28•soheilpro•4d ago•10 comments

LLMs are eroding my software engineering career and I don't know what to do

https://human-in-the-loop.bearblog.dev/llms-are-eroding-my-software-engineering-career-and-i-dont...
1010•poisonfountain•22h ago•960 comments